List Mgmt. 2017 Trade Period - Done and dusted for 2017. Thank you SOS!

[StandByyourMan]

Take the Carlton glasses off. Those picks would be pretty much spot on fair. Gives us plenty to trade with too.

This.

 

[Vhaluus]

“Journalists” who intently dislike Carlton eg Jon Ralph also stirring pot, he thinks Carlton would be happy with pick 10 and 16.

Pick 16 in 2016 for example got you Todd Marshall whose played about 5 games. Anything outside top 5 in picks is largely gamble. Pick 10 & 16 is nothing for genuine A grade midfielder.

Agreed, those 2 picks are fair for an A grade midfielder. so Cripps for 10 and 16? Only A grade midfielder on your list.

 

[Mondyboy]

I don’t want Gibbs to leave. But if he does go I hope those here who have been pushing him out the door are quiet next year when we struggle to scrape together five or six wins.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[bluemahogany]

“Journalists” who intently dislike Carlton eg Jon Ralph also stirring pot, he thinks Carlton would be happy with pick 10 and 16.

Pick 16 in 2016 for example got you Todd Marshall whose played about 5 games. Anything outside top 5 in picks is largely gamble. Pick 10 & 16 is nothing for genuine A grade midfielder.

Mate we'd take that in a heartbeat.

 

[bluemahogany]

Agreed, those 2 picks are fair for an A grade midfielder. so Cripps for 10 and 16? Only A grade midfielder on your list.

Triple that value maybe

 

[StandByyourMan]

Agreed, those 2 picks are fair for an A grade midfielder. so Cripps for 10 and 16? Only A grade midfielder on your list.

Just go away. Its such a circular dumb argument.

 

[Vhaluus]

Triple that value maybe

I know you wouldn't actually take that deal for Cripps.. it was my hint that it'd be massive overs for Gibbs.

 

[StandByyourMan]

I don’t want Gibbs to leave. But if he does go I hope those here who have been pushing him out the door are quiet next year when we struggle to scrape together five or six wins.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

its not pushing him out the door - its calling a spade a spade.

 

[FairKouta]

Agreed, those 2 picks are fair for an A grade midfielder. so Cripps for 10 and 16? Only A grade midfielder on your list.

Good luck breaking top 4 next year. Now go back to your board

 

[bluemahogany]

I know you wouldn't actually take that deal for Cripps.. it was my hint that it'd be massive overs for Gibbs.

No shit

 

[BlackGoanna]

I know you wouldn't actually take that deal for Cripps.. it was my hint that it'd be massive overs for Gibbs.

Yes would be overs. That's the only way you will get Gibbs... being bent overs

 

[Vhaluus]

Yes would be overs. That's the only way you will get Gibbs... being bent overs

Sorry, we're not Melbourne.

 

[Mondyboy]

its not pushing him out the door - its calling a spade a spade.

How is it calling it a spade a spade when Gibbs has said nothing, Ried has said he hasn’t spoken to Gibbs, McKay has said he’s a required player and everything else has been rumour and innuendo. If this is calling it a spade a spade then I’m a shovel.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[BlackGoanna]

Sorry, we're not Melbourne.

Only difference between you and Melbourne. Melbourne choked on the eve of the finals.. you guys choked on the big stage = big time chokers

 

[Crocodilian1]

Sorry, we're not Melbourne.

You payed well unders when you got Jacobs as he was uncontracted and he threatened to walk to PSD, this time you pay up as Gibbs is CONTRACTED. Karma baby, KARMA

 

[Vhaluus]

You payed well unders when you got Jacobs as he was uncontracted and he threatened to walk to PSD, this time you pay up as Gibbs is CONTRACTED. Karma baby, KARMA

Or we don't.

Do we need Gibbs more, or do you need picks more for your rebuild?

I think you all realize that even with player development your list won't get to a flag as it sits currently, so you need to keep improving it by getting in picks and players. If it's not Gibbs who else are you trading out?

 

[TooBlue14]

Agreed, those 2 picks are fair for an A grade midfielder. so Cripps for 10 and 16? Only A grade midfielder on your list.

Says the 40+ and 3 goals Gibbs kicked versus your mob on the mcg with year. Gd luck with it. Lol

 

[Crocodilian1]

Or we don't.

Do we need Gibbs more, or do you need picks more for your rebuild?

I think you all realize that even with player development your list won't get to a flag as it sits currently, so you need to keep improving it by getting in picks and players. If it's not Gibbs who else are you trading out?

its not always about picks, you need experience aswell, younger bodies need protecting. Will you win a premiership without Gibbs. NO. Who are you going to bring in to replace Lever and Cameron. You guys also need to improve your list, or go backwards

 

[Vhaluus]

Says the 40+ and 3 goals Gibbs kicked versus your mob on the mcg with year. Gd luck with it. Lol

30 touches, 2 goals, you should try watching games your team plays.

 

[Vhaluus]

its not always about picks, you need experience aswell, younger bodies need protecting. Will you win a premiership without Gibbs. NO. Who are you going to bring in to replace Lever and Cameron. You guys also need to improve your list, or go backwards

Organic growth.

People were asking us the same questions about Dangerfield leaving and he's better than those two combined.

 

[TooBlue14]

Or we don't.

Do we need Gibbs more, or do you need picks more for your rebuild?

I think you all realize that even with player development your list won't get to a flag as it sits currently, so you need to keep improving it by getting in picks and players. If it's not Gibbs who else are you trading out?

We will just take Sloane as a FA in 2018.

 

[Vhaluus]

We will just take Sloane as a FA in 2018.

Just like you were going to get Rockliff this year?

Go ahead and make an offer to Sloane, even if he wants to go we'll match like we did with Danger.

 

[TooBlue14]

30 touches, 2 goals, you should try watching games your team plays.

When you come here expect a little bit of sauce.

 

[Aussie Joe]

I don’t want Gibbs to leave. But if he does go I hope those here who have been pushing him out the door are quiet next year when we struggle to scrape together five or six wins.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

No, they won’t. They will bitch about recruiting a high priced cast off because our midfield is a shambles.

 

[TooBlue14]

Just like you were going to get Rockliff this year?

Go ahead and make an offer to Sloane, even if he wants to go we'll match like we did with Danger.

You do realise how much cap space we have right. You wouldn't get near our price. Paid 95% of cap for 2 years straight. Not like we have anything to spend it on this year apart from Kennedy.