List Mgmt. Gibbs - 2017 Trade Discussions! V2.0

[amer]

There is not a shred of evidence that Adelaide and Carlton are talking.

Not one. No solid media sources. Nothing.

 

[mattymac]

12 + 16 with a second round back next year might not be terrible this years draft is very weak

But Carlton approached us so we should have the upper hand

I would do 12 + 16 for Gibbs + 2018 2nd (likely around pick 20).

Hold onto 10 hope Fogarty slides through

 

[GrommoT]

All depends and IMO we need to look at the overall transactions to balance out the net effect

Lever deal is a big tick
Getting 12 back for Charlie would be a big tick
Getting a future 2nd round pick back from Carlton would be a small tick

So it's a tick contest?

 

[GROTTO]

I would do 12 + 16 for Gibbs + 2018 2nd (likely around pick 20).

Hold onto 10 hope Fogarty slides through

There is always a slider or two in the top 10. Which is why picks 10 and 12 are so massive.

Crows would know this, similarly so too does Carlton.

We are potentially giving up a 200+ gamer for a 29 year old guy who may have at best ~50 games left in him.

 

[siinfekl]

I would do 12 + 16 for Gibbs + 2018 2nd (likely around pick 20).

Hold onto 10 hope Fogarty slides through

I like it, keeps us from flooding our sanfl team with too many guys who wont be playing for a couple of years. Lets Carlton go home with a win of 2x 1sts but really its just a downgrade of 16 to a low 20s

 

[GrommoT]

2 ist rounders for Gibbs is ok this year but not last year?
if that deal goes through, the AFC have confirmed their insanity.

Last year we didn't lose Smith for a year or more ... plus a 2018 second coming back would sweeten it a bit.

 

[dogs105]

It's over

 

[GROTTO]

It's over

Thats game, set and match..........

 

[dogs105]

Brilliant post from some genius in the Carlton board about us giving up 10 and 16 in the year we lose cameron and lever, saying we should have just given up our first and lever for gibbs last year and we're idiots not to have done this.

 

[Sidthehat]

Callum Twomey has Fogarty coming to us at 10 in mock draft on Trade Radio.

 

[goyoucrows]

gut feel 10 is off the table, crows want the sa lad from the draft.

Rightly so. If we don't add anything with a 1st pick, then Gibbs alone is an offseason fail.

Looks like a good chance Fogarty could drop to 10, and we definitely won't get Lukosius or Rankine next year as they'll go top 5. Can't miss out on all 3 upcoming SA guns, need to atleast get up for Fogarty.

 

[GROTTO]

We wouldnt have won the flag last year with Gibbs and would have lost two 1sts for it if we caved to Carlton in 2016.

2016 1st and 2017 1st. That should set in before anything else.

 

[footy4ever]

It's over

It's over?

I don't think it ever started this year did it?

 

[The Karma Bus]

Never seen so many twists/turns, ups/downs, it's happenings/no it isn't, they're talking/no they're not, Gibbs wants to come home/no they're happy in Melbourne, they're not handing over two 1st rounders/yes they are's.

 

[baldandbroke]

FFS GIBBS IS 29 in R1 next year.

He is worth a first at best. Ie. Pick 16. Please don't pay overs for him,

Please do.

 

[GROTTO]

It's over?

I don't think it ever started this year did it?

+1

It would appear there was a lot of bs about inside info that Gibbs was coming home.

 

[dogs105]

Please do.

Please don't

 

[Deaneus!]

There is not a shred of evidence that Adelaide and Carlton are talking.

Not one. No solid media sources. Nothing.

that's how you know it's true

 

[mattymac]

There is always a slider or two in the top 10. Which is why picks 10 and 12 are so massive.

Crows would know this, similarly so too does Carlton.

We are potentially giving up a 200+ gamer for a 29 year old guy who may have at best ~50 games left in him.

200 games of which 190 will be after our current flag window closes

 

[GROTTO]

We had our chance this year to win the flag, with picks 10,12 and 16 in 2017 plus two 1sts next year we can rebuild a powerful list.

Its a shame really that we didnt go after Rocky, would have been a massive trade win having Rocky and all those 1st rounders.

We would have been improving our midfield, thereby keeping our premiership window wide open and building a strong future simultaneously. Lever and Cameron are replaceable.

I genuinely believe we missed a trick in the trade period in 2017.

 

[GROTTO]

200 games of which 190 will be after our current flag window closes

Gibbs would not have won us the flag this year. Make no mistake about that.

 

[Bicks]

Poor old Carlton so many players they want and little collateral..

 

[GrommoT]

It's over

Can live with that.




Wait... a minute ..... that's not a Corgi, is it?

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

Poor old Carlton so many players they want and little collateral..

That causes some grief for the proposed Ablett deal

 

[dogs105]

That causes some grief for the proposed Ablett deal

Lang is a good player. Was he a first round pick too? What would Geelong expect in a trade?