List Mgmt. 2017 Rookie Draft

[marty36]

Haven't you worked out yet it's the SA Proud thread?

Can see why, who are the players leaving on the annual exodus of go home factor

 

[Bicks]

Can see why, who are the players leaving on the annual exodus of go home factor

 

[marty36]

I forgot you are in the get Vic players band wagon so they can piss off home before they reach their full potential

 

[Bicks]

I forgot you are in the get Vic players band wagon so they can piss off home before they reach their full potential

 

[marty36]

On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[MRB37]

So do you think Doedee, Galluci and Pohokle will play more than 50 games?

Gooch will, but it probably won't be for us.

 

[Mego Red]

Honestly, Marty should just have this auto reply to each of his posts.

 

[Mego Red]

Yeah he would. Hes performed.

No he wouldn't. Four good games doesn't vastly change how players are rated. He's still the same guy. Good disciplined role player in a side that needs them.

 

[Mego Red]

Should we go back to your original post:

“He was in the twos for most of the year and played a couple of finals, doesn’t mean anything”.

Nothing about roles, etc etc.

Face it, if Graham was a Crow you would have locked him in for 200 games.

No, I'd think he was a great role player type who may or may not be there long term. He'd be Riley Knight, maybe.

 

[Mego Red]

And if Gallucci had wheels he would be a bike.

And if he played for Richmond he'd have a medallion.

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Marty - for the millionth time

Durdin , Sharenberg ( senior and junior ) , Aish , Wigg , Mayes , Dunstan ( not a bad player but not a top 25er )

Which one of that list above were worth Pick taken at ?

For any Burton you name there are a whole bunch of SA failures that I'm glad aren't on our list

When it comes to key position players - forget about SA until finally Lukoscious who will be a star

Next draft I'm all for it , over last 10 years disappointing

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Re Jack Graham - would have been him or Greenwood . Who would most of us chosen GF day ? Probably Greenwood

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Aaron Francis another one !!! Pick 6

Milera I think will be good but no guarantee either

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Well it does. Your earlier post said he was playing reserves for the year and only played 5 games, implying he wasn’t that good and would be lucky to play 50 games.

Well Galluci 1 game and Doedee 0 games in 2 years, but yet they will play 50 games. Do you see the conflicting message there?

Why do our supporters rate our players so highly and can’t acknowledge opposition players?

You're not projecting though

Dunstan had a great first season at saints but moving forward he's a 50-50 selection for saints each week

Graham could be similar but I'll admit I like him more

Luke Hodge looked a dud pick 1 v Judd etc in his first 3 seasons and look how that turned out

 

[GreyCrow]

If Adelaide in the flag Graham is another 50-50 candidate for Richmond next year

Not sure why there is this mystique around a flag. If Adelaide had won David Mackay would have one

 

[WaynesWorld19]

If Adelaide in the flag Graham is another 50-50 candidate for Richmond next year

Not sure why there is this mystique around a flag. If Adelaide had won David Mackay would have one

Bring back memories of a career ......if you can call how many games he played, a career

 

[GreyCrow]

Bring back memories of a career ......if you can call how many games he played, a career

Number 20 Aaron Keating. Played at least 2 games. Less than 10 is my guess

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Number 20 Aaron Keating. Played at least 2 games. Less than 10 is my guess

Apparently if he had worn a Richmond Guernsey, those 2 games would have qualified him for club Life Membership

 

[GreyCrow]

Apparently if he had worn a Richmond Guernsey, those 2 games would have qualified him for club Life Membership

Surprised Marty isnt all over him as one of our greatest ever players

I mean he has Jack Graham heading to Sainthood

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Surprised Marty isnt all over him as one of our greatest ever players

I mean he has Jack Graham heading to Sainthood

 

[Cleric]

Marty - for the millionth time

Durdin , Sharenberg ( senior and junior ) , Aish , Wigg , Mayes , Dunstan ( not a bad player but not a top 25er )

Which one of that list above were worth Pick taken at ?

For any Burton you name there are a whole bunch of SA failures that I'm glad aren't on our list

When it comes to key position players - forget about SA until finally Lukoscious who will be a star

Next draft I'm all for it , over last 10 years disappointing

Scharenberg without 2 knee recons would not make a dud list. Would you have Burton, Hayward, Wingard, Grundy, Daniel, Fantasia?
Cherry picking is cherry picking.

 

[Elite Crow]

You're not projecting though

Dunstan had a great first season at saints but moving forward he's a 50-50 selection for saints each week

Graham could be similar but I'll admit I like him more

Luke Hodge looked a dud pick 1 v Judd etc in his first 3 seasons and look how that turned out

Sorry I don’t get your post.

 

[Bicks]

Sorry I don’t get your post.

Into the future=Projecting

I.e. Dunstan's first season was quite good for a 1st year player, after that not so much.

 

[Elite Crow]

Into the future=Projecting

I.e. Dunstan's first season was quite good for a 1st year player, after that not so much.

I get that part. Not sure he gave any evidence why Doedee and Galluci will be 50 game players and Graham won’t be.

 

[Next Gen Rookie]

Into the future=Projecting

I.e. Dunstan's first season was quite good for a 1st year player, after that not so much.

Dunstan's last 6 weeks of the 2017 was excellent. There's no way he's a 50/50 proposition at Saints anymore (to address another previous poster).