List Mgmt. 2018 Trade/Draft/FA SuperMegaUltra Thread - The Early Edition

[Avalor]

Prior to that his dad came from Busselton and played for EP. In fact his dad won 2 Sandover medals. Let's get all the facts out there.

Yep his dad, Phil Kelly, was one of the best I've seen.

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

Why would Josh Kelly go to WC? He is from Victoria isn't he?

Josh kelly was born in wa his dad is a east perth legend.
He played for North then settled in Vic.
Both his grand parents from each side live in wa

 

[flamingEMBERS]

ahhhh i assumed the wrong kelly.

 

[flamingEMBERS]

Josh kelly was born in wa his dad is a east perth legend.
He played for North then settled in Vic.
Both his grand parents from each side live in wa

so he want's to play with McGinnity at EP? Does he not know the alignment is over?

 

[flamingEMBERS]

From what I've heard they'd certainly entertain it. It would be SPP or a first rounder because we'll be matching.

surely they aren't ready to get rid of SPP.

 

[flamingEMBERS]

If we legit got Josh Kelly that would be incredible. Was his favourite player Simpson/Rawlings/Petrie/Pratt?

 

[avishka5]

Josh Kelly at West Coast would be incredible. Bloke has a tank like Gaff but is a much more well rounded.


Honestly wouldn't mind targeting Scully if Gaff left.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Is this talk of Josh Kelly all coming just because someone misinterpreted a reference to Tim Kelly?

 

[flamingEMBERS]

Is this talk of Josh Kelly all coming just because someone misinterpreted a reference to Tim Kelly?

who knows man

 

[twce13]

Legit, I'll run naked onto Optus and fly kick Ballantyne at the next derby if we get J.kelly.

Never going to happen.

 

[avishka5]

Keep up the J.Kelly talk, i want to see this shit on the news tomorrow.

 

[Chris_6678]

Micheal Johnson to west coast is happening.

 

[eagle dtrain]

Our dream scenario if Gaff and Lycett leave.
Gaff chooses North we match and North trade pick 10 and Preuss for him.
Lycett chooses Saints but Eagles choose not to match and gain pick 20 compo pick. The Eagles then trade pick 10 and pick 38 for Saints pick 4. (Saints give us a leg up because of not bidding on Lycett)
Eagles trade pick 4 for Coniglio.
Eagles trade pick 20 for Kelly.
Eagles lose Gaff Lycett and pick 38.
Eagles gain Coniglio Kelly and Preuss.
We can only dream

 

[The Falcon Strike]

Our dream scenario if Gaff and Lycett leave.
Gaff chooses North we match and North trade pick 10 and Preuss for him.
Lycett chooses Saints but Eagles choose not to match and gain pick 20 compo pick. The Eagles then trade pick 10 and pick 38 for Saints pick 4. (Saints give us a leg up because of not bidding on Lycett)
Eagles trade pick 4 for Coniglio.
Eagles trade pick 20 for Kelly.
Eagles lose Gaff Lycett and pick 38.
Eagles gain Coniglio Kelly and Preuss.
We can only dream

And I’m getting blown by Russian twins

 

[Candiru]

nor should we. That's overpaying for Gaff

If he leaves for a ridiculous payday, I can wear it. You probably can't ask a guy to leave $2 million on the table between now and the end of his career. What would annoy me is if he left for similar money to our offer just because he's "homesick" or something wet like that. He can be a mercenary for that kind of big money. I can accept that. But don't be a pussy and go to a shit club just because you want to go "home". I can handle it if the money talks.

 

[Trebor57]

Hmm interesting, so what your saying is if he doesn’t leave then he will stay ..


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

There has to be an alternative, there just has to be.

 

[sey666]

Our dream scenario if Gaff and Lycett leave.
Gaff chooses North we match and North trade pick 10 and Preuss for him.
Lycett chooses Saints but Eagles choose not to match and gain pick 20 compo pick. The Eagles then trade pick 10 and pick 38 for Saints pick 4. (Saints give us a leg up because of not bidding on Lycett)
Eagles trade pick 4 for Coniglio.
Eagles trade pick 20 for Kelly.
Eagles lose Gaff Lycett and pick 38.
Eagles gain Coniglio Kelly and Preuss.
We can only dream

Which Kelly? Tim, Josh or Ned?

 

[pantskyle]

surely they aren't ready to get rid of SPP.

They haven't had a great year together.

 

[Stan8888]

Which Kelly? Tim, Josh or Ned?

More chance of Ned than Josh.

 

[LittleGreekGod]

Which Kelly? Tim, Josh or Ned?

Wanted Posters out on all Three!

 

[Freeballing]

Let's just say Gaff wants to stay at West Coast for 4.5 million over five years. The Eagles politely decline, and tell him they can't afford it. Their best offer to him is 4 mil over five years, like it or lump it they tell him...

Now, let's just say North come in and offer the 4.5 million over five Gaffy wants.

Do the Eags decide that a compo pick in the teens is just not up to scratch for Gaff, and match his deal to force a trade? If that's the case, could Gaff just not turn around and say cool Eags, you're paying me what I want, I'm staying because this is the best f'n club in the world with the best supporters in the land and I don't want to play anywhere else...

But in reality, West Coast can't afford Gaff, they don't have enough money to sign a new player and are now royally f'd? Or if say we do match an offer from another club, would there be an agreement in place that he wouldn't re-sign on that, just help the club get a decent trade deal from North?

 

[flamingEMBERS]

They haven't had a great year together.

is there more to it than the incident? Or just second year blues?

 

[DanWCE]

incorrect. But i wont give out any information on here any more. Obvious that this site isnt interested in facts.

Whoa did you just cancel your account over this? Extreme.

 

[Godfather32]

Whoa did you just cancel your account over this? Extreme.

 

[Boohemian]

Whoa did you just cancel your account over this? Extreme.

He should have changed his username to former poster before he left.