Strategy Trade and List management Thread Part 2 (opposition supporters - READ posting rules before posting)

[House_of_Dahl]

Not only did we miss out on Wingard but I just got sacked for drinking beers at my desk. Janet from HR not impressed!

 

[Scary_Foot_9]

Why can’t we ask for Burton and keep a first.

Pick 7 plus WB third round pick - Burton and 15.

We can then trade pick 15 for a 2019 first and use the Dahl and Adams picks for West.

We then have 2 firsts for Kelly next year and bulk cap room.

Dear god no.

Have you seen Ryan Burton play????????? He's not worth it (PORT ARE GETTING SO SHAFTED IT"S NOT FUNNY!)

Take pick 7 to the the draft, select another good player.

Let's not panic just cause we feel like the kid at the dance no one wants to go with.

 

[ossie_21]

Please tell me you're not basing this on half a trade period. I know we've been in full throwing the toys out of the cot mode, but seriously.

To be fair, a whole trade period & a half. Last year we didn’t do much to rectify the gaps in our list, a few days in & we still haven’t done anything

 

[GetDimmaBack]

The sky just fell on my head.

Ouch!!

 

[Northernsoul74]

Dear god no.

Have you seen Ryan Burton play????????? He's not worth it (PORT ARE GETTING SO SHAFTED IT"S NOT FUNNY!)

Take pick 7 to the the draft, select another good player.

Let's not panic just cause we feel like the kid at the dance no one wants to go with.

Got to stay in the top 7 of this draft now. If anything try and move up but I certainly wouldn’t be diluting a top 7 pick.

 

[Bodicifer]

Not only did we miss out on Wingard but I just got sacked for drinking beers at my desk. Janet from HR not impressed!

Tell Janet she needs to loosen up a bit and hand her one of your hash cookies for morning tea

 

[Northernsoul74]

The sky just fell on my head.

Ouch!!

Could be worse, could be a Port fan.

 

[footscray1973]

Where is Scrag City saying Roughead/Burton/Liber/Scully/May/Hogan/Kelly/Martin will nominate us today/tomorrow/the day after? Come on SCrag, we need something to hang off, even if it's utter bullsh1t!!!

 

[Norm De Guerre]

I think we've almost reached the stage where if the players and AFLPA want clubs to be mature enough to be ok with free agency and player movement, then they in turn have to be mature enough to accept that the club can trade you to whoever offers them the best deal. If contracts mean nothing to players, why should they mean anything to clubs.

This would need the AFL to invest a lot more money investigating salary cap breaches, and strengthening those rules.

Then the AFLPA play their trump card and the AFL will end up before the high court of Australia defending a restraint of trade case and their whole rotten house of sham contracts comes tumbling down.

It’s s prospect that absolutely terrifies them and it’s why they turn a blind eye when players walk out on what are in effect worthless contracts and why clubs end up being bent over when negotiating a trade. As we will be when we inevitably release Marcus Adams for peanuts and thins board melts down like Chernobyl.

 

[Riggo3]

It depends what becomes available or what the club has up its sleeve - if anything at all. I stand by the fact we need experience, but only if the right player is available, otherwise I am with you we head to the draft.

Got to stay in the top 7 of this draft now. If anything try and move up but I certainly wouldn’t be diluting a top 7 pick.

 

[F3000]

 

[TimlinOfficial]

How the fire truck do the Hawks get these deals done? I cannot see it. I just can’t.

15 + Burton for Wingard
2019 1st + 35 for Scully + 25
25 for Scrimshaw

 

[Nath09]

15 + Burton for Wingard
2019 1st + 35 for Scully + 25
25 for Scrimshaw

Can’t trade first rounders in consecutive years though, right?

 

[compact72]

15 + Burton for Wingard
2019 1st + 35 for Scully + 25
25 for Scrimshaw

Would make it hard for port to get pick 2 and 3 which is what they're after

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

 

[The Inbetweener]

Can’t trade first rounders in consecutive years though, right?

AFL bend the rules on that

 

[Snarls Barkley]

15 + Burton for Wingard
2019 1st + 35 for Scully + 25
25 for Scrimshaw

Surely Scully is worth more than a future first round pick not the other way round.

 

[compact72]

Let's just get Kelly

Salary dump for gws, keep Scully. Let hawthorn focus more on wingard

 

[BallaratBulldog]

I think we should just focus on Townshead, Duryea and Lloyd.

Players are we are capable of getting. Otherwise draft.

 

[Bemoreboyddog]

Please tell me you're not basing this on half a trade period. I know we've been in full throwing the toys out of the cot mode, but seriously.

I did say as of right now. You even bolded it.

 

[BrunswickDog]

Gws have dumped/will dump massive salary this year.

They are stockpiling cap space for kelly themselves.

 

[charcoalchicken]

How did we miss on wingard??

Not good enough honestly, sam power and the others who handle these matters should be shipped out, that's a massive failure.

I don't buy into all that destination club bullshit, just get the deal done we were in a great position to do it and failed

 

[compact72]

I think we should just focus on Townshead, Duryea and Lloyd.

Players are we are capable of getting. Otherwise draft.

No way, we shouldn't give up and keep trying to hit above our weight.

 

[Doggies7]

Ricky Nixon just tweeted Steven May looking at alternatives if Dees fall through and mentions the Dogs as his alternative.

 

[topdog]

Gws have dumped/will dump massive salary this year.

They are stockpiling cap space for kelly themselves.

Or they poach the Bont from us!

 

[Scary_Foot_9]

Let's just get Kelly

Salary dump for gws, keep Scully. Let hawthorn focus more on wingard

I mean I want to marry Margot Robbie and own a Ferrari 488 as well, but some things just aren't meant to be.