Remove this Banner Ad

Player Watch Reilly O'Brien - Re-Signed to End of 2028

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

He’s played 37 games. He has not even come close to establishing himself as a quality AFL ruck man. He was completely dominated by Nic Naitanui and Scott Lycett.

Would he be in the top 10 AFL ruck man right now?

As I said, give him 2 years and then reevaluate him position in the game.
He's probably top 3
 
He's not elite, and will likely never be, but he's still a fine player. McEvoy probably a good comparison. Fitness is never a worry with him, and he doesn't seem the type to get complacent (a rarity amongst AFC players).
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Elite?

I would say he is trending towards being a good ruckman, but tags like "elite" should only be given to guys like Brodie Grundy and Max Gawn etc.

no Relapse, everyone on our list is elite, we only came last because Brad Crouch is evil
 
If Will goes top 5 I hope we don't get him.
Next year I'd like to see us be in that 10-12 finish range
Taking a ruck with a top 5 pick given the state of our midfield (and list in general) would be a travesty
 
That is all you need.

Scott Lycett and Nankervis are Premiership players.

Max Gawn and Brody Grundy never will be.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
100% correct, we need elite players at ROB's feet, he is serviceable enough for us at the moment.
 
Elite?

Settle down.

He's a very good honest, tenacious Ruckman. Elite he is not.

no Bicks, everyone on our list is elite, everyone

What are you on about? Who said he was magically leading us to a flag? Do you not see this as an important signing?

What are *you* on about? Does the club direct deposit, or do they give you vouchers?

A good signing. Only important because we’ve ****ed up everything else we’ve touched for the last decade.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Love this place. Our b&f from Vic Metro about to enter his prime career age commits for 4 years and people still find something to complain about.

Never change
If only he'd ever made the Vic Metro squad....;)

Only one bloke complaining from what I can see, to re-sign him was a no brainer and the contract term looks about right.
 
Would have preferred a 3.5 year deal.

Imagine the excitement on this board in the lead up to the end of his contract mid-season.
Monthly.....think of the website hits each time he re-signs.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
 
Fewest games to clock up 1,000 career hitouts

34 - REILLY O'BRIEN
35 - Sean Darcy
38 - Billy Longer, Sam Jacobs
40 - Justin Madden
41 - Dawson Simpson
42 - Max Gawn
...
47 - Brodie Grundy

1615426801309.png
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

This is a good signing. ROB is in the top 5 in the AFL in his position - not many of our players can say that. It takes him to 29, which is the perfect age for someone like him to re-evaluate.

More importantly, you can feel a shift in culture happening among the group. This is not a group of guys looking to get games and then get out to a new club. This is a young group of guys that are committing to each other and to building something together. I like it.
 
This is a good signing. ROB is in the top 5 in the AFL in his position - not many of our players can say that. It takes him to 29, which is the perfect age for someone like him to re-evaluate.

More importantly, you can feel a shift in culture happening among the group. This is not a group of guys looking to get games and then get out to a new club. This is a young group of guys that are committing to each other and to building something together. I like it.
Yep I agree. They know that there will be some pain to come but are prepared to lock in and stay. ROB is a good signing. I also think that Strachan has upped his game a bit over the off season so might end up being a capable back up if needed and there is the break glass of Frampton / Himmelberg as a short term. - Not all doom and gloom
 
Well, we locked down another B grader, and we know our lead ruck for the next 4 years

...who the hell is our 2nd ruck?
Did you forget your anti-cranky pills today, or are you trying to outSpackler, Spackler?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Player Watch Reilly O'Brien - Re-Signed to End of 2028

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top