Preview Geelong vs Richmond, round 15, MCG Saturday June 25, 4.35pm

[Area51]

Soldo a necessary in. We need to win the midfield/clearance battle and the only time we consistently lost this against Carlton is after Balta got injured and Nank was off the ground. Nank can't ruck all game so Soldo for a chopout and can also stand in the hole in front of eyes-too-close-together porkins.

 

[Jono_Hain97]

Lambert out? Another injury we kept quiet and lied about

 

[Crumpet_avenger]

Lambert out? Another injury we kept quiet and lied about

Not really
Everyone knows his hip is ****ed

Hardwick almost let it slip at his presser today about lambert

 

[Wooden Robot]

Ross was a no brainer as there really isn't any other inside mid in the VFL that is as good as him. Stack was awful in his last AFL game against the wingless Eagles. He still needs to show more at VFL and not only against the Coburg Lions. He's the most over rated player on our list as he's been playing with us more than actually playing on the field . Agree on Edwards as he's dead wood.

A bit of respect for your Coburg Lions, please

 

[_RT_]

Lambert out? Another injury we kept quiet and lied about

Everyone knows his hip is stuffed and he is a week to week proposition.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Soldo absolute dinasoar spud
Ross the turnover king
Thank god the goat is back.

George is back?
Inside info?

 

[Vassp]

Lol because Stacks one performance this year in the AFL was good was it? He played in a 100pt thumping and couldn’t get near it

well, you want to mention ONE GAME? how about his 2019 season? and his late 2021 season ? much better than ross will ever be. you can stick to your one game-------in which he still set up two or three goals while admittedly looking lost, imagine what he would do when he isn't looking lost?

 

[DontArgue4]

Lambert out? Another injury we kept quiet and lied about

Quiet?

You been living under Patricks rock?

 

[Vassp]

Ross was a no brainer as there really isn't any other inside mid in the VFL that is as good as him. Stack was awful in his last AFL game against the wingless Eagles. He still needs to show more at VFL and not only against the Coburg Lions. He's the most over rated player on our list as he's been playing with us more than actually playing on the field . Agree on Edwards as he's dead wood.

Stack is over rated? didnt expect that from you TI, stack is one of our most gifted players. He needs development or get rid of him. HE cant play as good in the VFL, he needs AFL time, some players suffocate in the VFL.

 

[biaseddustyfan]

Lambert out? Another injury we kept quiet and lied about

he has arthritis as bad as an old man it's no secret

 

[TigerImposter]

Stack is over rated? didnt expect that from you TI, stack is one of our most gifted players. He needs development or get rid of him. HE cant play as good in the VFL, he needs AFL time, some players suffocate in the VFL.

Cmon Vassp how long can you develop a negative film? Seriously he's an over rated potato and he reminds me of that hot blonde I liked when i was 17yo. A utensil teaser

 

[Thesharks]

Is Ralphsmith unlucky do you think?

 

[_RT_]

well, you want to mention ONE GAME? how about his 2019 season? and his late 2021 season ? much better than ross will ever be. you can stick to your one game-------in which he still set up two or three goals while admittedly looking lost, imagine what he would do when he isn't looking lost?

How many times are people going to go back to how Stack looked in 2019? It's 3 years ago and Stack despite all his talent had continually failed to deliver on a consistent level at either VFL or AFL level, one thing he consistently does is show up to preseason unfit and putting himself behind the pack from the get go. Maybe it's time people eased up on hyping up Stack and actually let his performances do the talking.

 

[sante]

Is Ralphsmith unlucky do you think?

Sub

 

[Wooden Robot]

How many times are people going to go back to how Stack looked in 2019? It's 3 years ago and Stack despite all his talent had continually failed to deliver on a consistent level at either VFL or AFL level, one thing he consistently does is show up to preseason unfit and putting himself behind the pack from the get go. Maybe it's time people eased up on hyping up Stack and actually let his performances do the talking.

Well ... we do have the Castagna brigade still living off his 2017 season

Point well taken though. We have a group of players living off past glories in the eyes of posters.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Is Ralphsmith unlucky do you think?

Nope.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Well ... we do have the Castagna brigade still living off his 2017 season

Point well taken though. We have a group of players living off past glories in the eyes of posters.

19.
5 in the GF.

 

[Punt rd end]

 

[_RT_]

Well ... we do have the Castagna brigade still living off his 2017 season

Point well taken though. We have a group of players living off past glories in the eyes of posters.

I'm definitely not one of the Castagna brigade. He's our Paul Puopolo IMO, effort and intensity earned him premiership accolades but once that dropped away past glories got him another 5 years. Reckon the same happens with George, and that's not shitting on a premiership hero, but IMO if we never won those flags I doubt George would still be on a list.

 

[Wooden Robot]

I'm definitely not one of the Castagna brigade. He's our Paul Puopolo IMO, effort and intensity earned him premiership accolades but once that dropped away past glories got him another 5 years. Reckon the same happens with George, and that's not shitting on a premiership hero, but IMO if we never won those flags I doubt George would still be on a list.

Great post

 

[Punt rd end]

Anyone know who these are

Umpires
Justin Power (4), Andrew Stephens (12), Hayden Gavine (14)

 

[db26]

Is Ralphsmith unlucky do you think?

Needs to tidy up his kicking for me.

 

[db26]

Swap you Soldo for Stanley any day.

His never dominated Nank and Soldo.

 

[db26]

Could not agree more what do we see in him

Reward form simple as that he goes back and performs in vfl I'll give him that and some others don't.

 

[Vassp]

How many times are people going to go back to how Stack looked in 2019? It's 3 years ago and Stack despite all his talent had continually failed to deliver on a consistent level at either VFL or AFL level, one thing he consistently does is show up to preseason unfit and putting himself behind the pack from the get go. Maybe it's time people eased up on hyping up Stack and actually let his performances do the talking.

You conveniently left out back end of 2021?

He had a massive one game to show his wares?

How many has Edwards had this year?