SFNL Division 1 2023 discussion

[Wild Thing]

I'll say it again , Football Southern Bayside , teams unhappy in ammos as well

Please do up a revised divisions based on current performances Bedford.
Last year also had Old Mentone…..no longer will be around.
Be interesting where you put some teams

 

[Wild Thing]

Is Narre Warren still rumoured of coming in?

Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

If Narre Warren and Cranbourne don’t get to their desired destinations they will both be in the Southern League next year.
Still a lot to play out and many hurdles to cross for them to get where they want.

 

[bedford]

Please do up a revised divisions based on current performances Bedford.
Last year also had Old Mentone…..no longer will be around.
Be interesting where you put some teams

Will do have a weekend off next week

 

[Wild Thing]

Will do have a weekend off next week

Cheers mate.
Curious how far out you go eg: Dingley / Keysy / Dandy / Hampton Park way

 

[bedford]

Cheers mate.
Curious how far out you go eg: Dingley / Keysy / Dandy / Hampton Park way

I'll look it up and see how it works out , people got offended where i put them , but that's not what it was about, it's the concept

 

[whowantstoknow]

Whats happening with dingley they were looking so good

 

[sammelb80]

Whats happening with dingley they were looking so good

Half their 1s are in Europe.

 

[Yabblettt]

Is Narre Warren still rumoured of coming in?

If Narre Warren and Cranbourne don’t get to their desired destinations they will both be in the Southern League next year.
Still a lot to play out and many hurdles to cross for them to get where they want.

Both will get accepted to the mpfnl starting in Div 2.




Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[#thebont4]

Port recruited alot of StKCity's kids that are currently playing in their two's

Port have a very strong list and have the ability to go deep, if they stay healthy.

Justin Taylor is a great leader of men, Smedts DeLuca & Caddy are the obvious standouts on their list, but look out for Soylemez who is a massive talent, and has a massive future most likely at a higher level

What is wrong with caddy? He’s only played 2 or so games this year.

 

[sammelb80]

What is wrong with caddy? He’s only played 2 or so games this year.

His body is cooked from AFL….
He’s playing his 5 games to qualify for finals I’ve heard and that’s it

If Cranbourne leave how will Div 1 look next year? Two grand finalists from Div 2 come up? Or should Last place stay up?

 

[Bunk Moreland]

Here is what I put on the Outer East board

- Clubs on the peninsula want to play locally, they don’t want more far away suburban clubs.

- Outer East has been a farce, return the YVMDFL

- The outer south-east suburbs are still growing and there may be new senior clubs to come over the next decade or so

- The EFNL is too big, get it back to four divisions

MPFL (12 clubs, one division, country league)

Crib Point
Dromana
Hastings
Mornington
Mount Eliza
Pearcedale
Red Hill
Rosebud
Rye
Somerville
Sorrento
Tyabb

SEFL (24 clubs, metro league, two divisions, can grow to three divisions)

SEFL D1
Beaconsfield (EFNL)
Berwick (EFNL)
Bonbeach (MPFNL)
Cranbourne (SFNL)
Devon Meadows (MPFNL)
Edi Asp (MPFNL)
Frankston Bombers (MPFNL)
Frankston YCW (MPFNL)
Karingal (MPFNL)
Langwarrin (MPFNL)
Narre Warren (OEFNL)
Pines (MPFNL)

SEFL D2
Berwick Springs (OEFNL)
Cerberus (SFNL)
Chelsea (MPFNL)
Frankston Dolphins (SFNL)
Hallam (OEFNL)
Lyndhurst (SFNL)
Narre South (SFNL)
Seaford (MPFNL)
Officer (OEFNL)
Pakenham (OEFNL)
Skye (MPFNL)
South Mornington (SFNL)

SFNL (30 clubs, 3 divisions)

SFNL D1
Bentleigh
Chelsea Heights
Cheltenham
Dingley
East Brighton
Mordialloc
Port Colts
Springvale Districts
St Kilda City
St Pauls

SFNL D2
Black Rock
Caulfield
Doveton
East Malvern
Endeavour Hills
Hampton Park
Highett
Keysborough
Murrumbeena
Oakleigh District

SFNL D3
Ashwood
Carrum Patterson Lakes
Clayton
Dandenong
Doveton Eagles
Hampton
Heatherton
Lyndale
Moorabbin
South Yarra

Play around at the margins as you wish.

 

[gelder01]

Both will get accepted to the mpfnl starting in Div 2.




Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Very good info, i know Narre Warren have been playing Red Hill in practice matches the last few years, alternating venues, and believed to have a good relationship with them.

I am not convinced though that they will get any other negative clubs to change their vote. it only takes 5 "no's" out of 22 votes to not be voted in! Which to me seems like the tail wagging the dog!

I like Bunks thoughts, although you rule out Cerberus (numbers & strength vary from year to year) and Berwick & Beaconsfield.

 

[Perty4]

I

Here is what I put on the Outer East board

- Clubs on the peninsula want to play locally, they don’t want more far away suburban clubs.

- Outer East has been a farce, return the YVMDFL

- The outer south-east suburbs are still growing and there may be new senior clubs to come over the next decade or so

- The EFNL is too big, get it back to four divisions

MPFL (12 clubs, one division, country league)

Crib Point
Dromana
Hastings
Mornington
Mount Eliza
Pearcedale
Red Hill
Rosebud
Rye
Somerville
Sorrento
Tyabb

SEFL (24 clubs, metro league, two divisions, can grow to three divisions)

Bonbeach (MPFNL)
Chelsea (MPFNL)
Devon Meadows (MPFNL)
Edi Asp (MPFNL)
Frankston Bombers (MPFNL)
Frankston YCW (MPFNL)
Karingal (MPFNL)
Langwarrin (MPFNL)
Pines (MPFNL)
Seaford (MPFNL)
Skye (MPFNL)
Cerberus (SFNL)
Cranbourne (SFNL)
Frankston Dolphins (SFNL)
Lyndhurst (SFNL)
Narre South (SFNL)
South Mornington (SFNL)
Berwick Springs (OEFNL)
Hallam (OEFNL)
Officer (OEFNL)
Narre Warren (OEFNL)
Pakenham (OEFNL)
Berwick (EFNL)
Beaconsfield (EFNL)

SFNL (30 clubs, 3 divisions)

Bentleigh
Chelsea Heights
Cheltenham
Dingley
East Brighton
Mordialloc
Port Colts
Springvale Districts
St Kilda City
St Pauls

Black Rock
Caulfield
Doveton
East Malvern
Endeavour Hills
Hampton Park
Highett
Keysborough
Murrumbeena
Oakleigh District

Ashwood
Carrum Patterson Lakes
Clayton
Dandenong
Doveton Eagles
Hampton
Heatherton
Lyndale
Moorabbin
South Yarra

Play around at the margins as you wish.

Insular Peninsula

 

[Bunk Moreland]

I

Insular Peninsula

Well, perhaps. But if they want their own local country league, who is anybody else to argue? They know what’s best for them.

The only hang up I can see for them is if they can’t raise enough clubs for a peninsula league. You really want 9 at an absolute minimum. Others may prefer to play in a suburban league. Or some of the Frankston clubs may prefer the country league.

 

[Bunk Moreland]

Very good info, i know Narre Warren have been playing Red Hill in practice matches the last few years, alternating venues, and believed to have a good relationship with them.

I am not convinced though that they will get any other negative clubs to change their vote. it only takes 5 "no's" out of 22 votes to not be voted in! Which to me seems like the tail wagging the dog!

I like Bunks thoughts, although you rule out Cerberus (numbers & strength vary from year to year) and Berwick & Beaconsfield.

Probably right. If it could happen, however, I’d say B & B would be mad not to seek entry as it’d be a high quality league on their doorstep, without the need to travel to the EFNL.

 

[magpies2013]

Probably right. If it could happen, however, I’d say B & B would be mad not to seek entry as it’d be a high quality league on their doorstep, without the need to travel to the EFNL.

My understanding is that Berwick and Beacy are quite happy in eastern. Yes they have had some teething issues and crowds are down and not what they expected but they are happy and are in for the long haul. To their advantage Berwick has 2 u19s teams and Beacy u19s are sitting on top. With that much youth coming through it won’t be long before they are strong clubs in the Efnl

 

[bedford]

Took in the 1st half at Bentleigh and Colts looked a 10 goal better side , couldn't believe it when i saw the final result , credit to Bentleigh .

 

[sammelb80]

Took in the 1st half at Bentleigh and Colts looked a 10 goal better side , couldn't believe it when i saw the final result , credit to Bentleigh .

Been told there was a huge all in brawl when Bentleigh were 8 goals down that started the momentum change… will have to watch the footage

 

[sainter01]

Been told there was a huge all in brawl when Bentleigh were 8 goals down that started the momentum change… will have to watch the footage

Footage is going around, spectators involved, pretty full on, League will have to investigate

 

[bedford]

Footage is going around, spectators involved, pretty full on, League will have to investigate

Wish i hadn't gone in to RSL lol

 

[Blood Stained Angels]

Footage is going around, spectators involved, pretty full on, League will have to investigate

Port Colts involved again, the last time Bentleigh went to their ground it was a farce as well. Umpires abused , a muppet supporter verbally and intimidating umpires as they walked off the ground, players insulted and some of the comments were horrific , police called.

 

[batfink]

Port Colts involved again, the last time Bentleigh went to their ground it was a farce as well. Umpires abused , a muppet supporter verbally and intimidating umpires as they walked off the ground, players insulted and some of the comments were horrific , police called.

Going by the footage not much in it
Noticed the umpire in charge is the umpires advisor
He is the worst umpire in the league
Full of himself but he’s well past it

 

[Parkf00ty]

Going by the footage not much in it
Noticed the umpire in charge is the umpires advisor
He is the worst umpire in the league
Full of himself but he’s well past it

The standard hasn’t been the best in the ump ranks Fail to control the fame Few late shots that are going to take their toll Get the cards out earlier maybe



Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Parkf00ty]

Port Colts involved again, the last time Bentleigh went to their ground it was a farce as well. Umpires abused , a muppet supporter verbally and intimidating umpires as they walked off the ground, players insulted and some of the comments were horrific , police called.

Blood stained think you need to have a look at the vision Crowd was a joke down there
Glass houses Bentliegh
[emoji23][emoji23]


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[bedford]

Blood stained think you need to have a look at the vision Crowd was a joke down there
Glass houses Bentliegh
[emoji23][emoji23]


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

It was all very quiet in the 1st half