Remove this Banner Ad

Toast Welcome to Freo Murphy Reid - pick 17 of the 2024 Draft

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Im going to get hate again but the truth of the matter is Curtin has traits that give him a generally higher ceiling. In the AFL era, The generational players are generally close to or 190cm + (Fyfe, Danger, Franklin, Pav, Cripps Pendles, Judd, Darcy) with the smaller top 5 player types rarer (Naicos, Gablett, Neale).

Thats not to say he cant be something incredible juat that the path is easier for Curtin.

Honestly, id prioritise Curtin over anyone else for the foreseeable future, he is the closest thing to Pav we've seen and a Freo die hard.
While this is true maybe your reasons actually make it lean the other way …. true magicians are harder to find
 
Someone mentioned Steele Sidebottom and I see it.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Reid is one of the smartest young football players I've seen in quite some time, he has a real nous for the game, so glad we picked him up.

Whether or not he wins the award, he's the Rising Star in my heart, and that's all that matters.


For those that took the $15 for him to win the award the actual result matters. :p

Another 4 goal haul would be helpful.
 

Just catching up on First Crack now and Montagna gave him a big pump up and said he should be in front of Curtin. Said that SI of 15 is the 2nd highest game for the season in whole competition. Highest was Tim English with 17, and half were hitouts to advantage.

Also brought up that a 20 goal and 30 score assist season has only been done once before by a rookie. Cyril Rioli. Reid is on 30 score assists (8th in comp) and one goal short. I don't see this score assist stats on the websites I look at. Just score involvements and goal assists. So interesting to see some numbers.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Just catching up on First Crack now and Montagna gave him a big pump up and said he should be in front of Curtin. Said that SI of 15 is the 2nd highest game for the season in whole competition. Highest was Tim English with 17, and half were hitouts to advantage.

Also brought up that a 20 goal and 30 score assist season has only been done once before by a rookie. Cyril Rioli. Reid is on 30 score assists (8th in comp) and one goal short. I don't see this score assist stats on the websites I look at. Just score involvements and goal assists. So interesting to see some numbers.
And then King said yeah nah it’s over, Curtin is already past the post.
 
WC fans justifying it are just showing how far the club has fallen. It should be universal diagust at even considering. Tell him no thanks, if 1m a year isn't enough till you've actually proved yourself we'll go back to the draft
How bad was his body language in the derby particularly when he shoooshed the crowd after his 2nd goal with his finger on his lips gesture despite being 40 points down and the game already over. Even a West Coast supporter sitting near me was outraged by his lack of care for how his team was going.
 
How bad was his body language in the derby particularly when he shoooshed the crowd after his 2nd goal with his finger on his lips gesture despite being 40 points down and the game already over. Even a West Coast supporter sitting near me was outraged by his lack of care for how his team was going.
Was that a shoosh? I thought he was telling everyone how many games he's won this year.
 
Murphy Reid is all the good stuff of Sidebottom, Pendles, Toby Green and even a smidge Jeffrey Farmer with his taps to space and awareness around him.

It’s so good ‘knowing’ you have one as opposed to hoping one develops.

We just hope he develops into a superstar. If he remains as is for 10 years he’s still a gun.

Not just fortunate slider, but in an area we desperately needed.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Just catching up on First Crack now and Montagna gave him a big pump up and said he should be in front of Curtin. Said that SI of 15 is the 2nd highest game for the season in whole competition. Highest was Tim English with 17, and half were hitouts to advantage.

Also brought up that a 20 goal and 30 score assist season has only been done once before by a rookie. Cyril Rioli. Reid is on 30 score assists (8th in comp) and one goal short. I don't see this score assist stats on the websites I look at. Just score involvements and goal assists. So interesting to see some numbers.

I see the comparisons to other players, but Reid plays more like Cyril Rioli as his stats indicate too - he’s just a tad slower. The deft touches, vision, contested ball wins when seemingly out of position or outnumbered, ability to create space where there shouldn’t be any or hit targets that even the crowd watching don’t see.

All of these things caused nightmares to us when we played Hawthorn in that 2012-2015 period and there was simply nothing the team could do about it. Stoked we now get to enjoy watching Reid (and Bolton) do this to other teams.

The next step is getting him some midfield rotations.

A center bounce featuring all our part time mids in Jackson, Bolton and Reid would be very fun to watch!
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Toast Welcome to Freo Murphy Reid - pick 17 of the 2024 Draft

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top