List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion

[stavro#4]

Would prefer Ludowyke over Walsh tbh

Your getting a first for Marshall and we have our own.

With us likely winning the next 3. You’ll get close to your dream of Pou Jnr and Ludowyke.

Steele and Macrae don’t work.

Walsh and every midfield option + Macrae would. Because he can play outside/in as a midfielder.

He doesn’t have the goal threat similar top tier mids have. But you would be nuts if you turned your nose up at the prospect of turning Steele into Walsh.

 

[Yawkey way]

When I read some of the posts on here I start to understand how some sailors mistook seacows for mermaids.

Jack was a sharp operator getting those beans for just one cow. Maybe it’s the Nas stress or a full moon or something but please no more Ryan talk.

 

[gubby88]

4x $600 is pies offer

this is where i have the issue wiuth the media speculation. Morris said the offer would trigger end of first round compo. surely 4x600 doesnt do that, it would trigger band 3 these days

and im not potting your info, youre probably spot on, im potting the media more

 

[Yawkey way]

Might just want to get used to Aleer , just saying

Oh well he’ll look good at training at least until they bring out the footballs.

 

[TheJackal]

Your getting a first for Marshall and we have our own.

With us likely winning the next 3. You’ll get close to your dream of Pou Jnr and Ludowyke.

Steele and Macrae don’t work.

Walsh and every midfield option + Macrae would. Because he can play outside/in as a midfielder.

He doesn’t have the goal threat similar top tier mids have. But you would be nuts if you turned your nose up at the prospect of turning Steele into Walsh.

I love your info but when we are basically having the same opinion, well let's just say that scares me.

 

[billings2paddy]

Hold on, so people seem happy to let Marshall go as he is 30.

But let's get Ryan? 29 contracted. That goes against what we are aiming surely?

Hoping thats all just hot air!

There's zero chance of ryan leaving WA

 

[CaptainRisky]

Oh well he’ll look good at training at least until they bring out the footballs.

Well we have had plenty of them in the past

 

[dudeintheswamp]

If I see Liam Ryan playing for the Saints at any stage I will fair dinkum eat an entire bucket of sand with a fork. Just plain yuck

Sauce?

 

[stavro#4]

I love your info but when we are basically having the same opinion, well let's just say that scares me.

Why would it scare you?

People get too caught up in romanticising players.

 

[Mowman]

this is where i have the issue wiuth the media speculation. Morris said the offer would trigger end of first round compo. surely 4x600 doesnt do that, it would trigger band 3 these days

and im not potting your info, youre probably spot on, im potting the media more

Morris on SEN today went with end of 1st round start of 2nd

 

[_Maximus_12]

Might just want to get used to Aleer , just saying

Will be a very good get for us. Don’t understand the concern

 

[Dard Ball Get]

Will be a very good get for us. Don’t understand the concern

Flying Viking
Sudanese Saint
Nasiah the Messiah
Itchytoe
Hugo
Irishes
Phillipou Flipper
TravShoe

It’s all coming together

 

[Mowman]

Family ties aside, it would make more sense than TDK, be cheaper than Aleer and cost us no picks.

I thought he was a pretty average forward but looks much more comfortable down back.

Been very good when played in the right position

 

[_Maximus_12]

JSOS is 29 next year for those interested. Doesn’t bridge the gap in list demographic.

 

[stavro#4]

Will be a very good get for us. Don’t understand the concern

Serious leap

 

[Sir Owens]

Morris also links us to Liam Ryan. (West coast)

Flying Ryan and the Flying Viking would be box office. Send Aleer forward and the gameplan is marks up.

 

[botts]

What did we do last time to convince nas to stay. Surely he couldn’t have got more home sick. Maybe Adam goods should come down and have a chat to him and help convince him

 

[stavro#4]

Flying Ryan and the Flying Viking would be box office. Send Aleer forward and the gameplan is marks up.

Thought the Viking was pretty impressive playing forward in the second half on Sunday.


He looked very natural and was incredibly team oriented

 

[SaintJunior]

Really? I

West coast also applying for Draft assistance according to Greg Swann

Disgrace they gave away their future for Tim Kelly .

 

[Yawkey way]

Will be a very good get for us. Don’t understand the concern

He’s turning 24 not 21 and has played 20 games.

Guys who only play when you have a long injury list don’t usually come with his price tag. It’s the usual story everyone in front of him is team of the century material and he’s going to break out and be a superstar.

You know what you usually find in other people’s trash ?, yep trash. If we were talking a third rounder and 3 x $500k I wouldn’t bat an eyelid, knock yourselves out give him an opportunity. You’d be surprised who we might actually be able to get for a second rounder and near enough to $900k.

Just the money alone has to be bloody insulting to quite a few currently on our list and playing every week. Do you think we’re offering that sort of money to windy and hall ?.

 

[Yawkey way]

Morris on SEN today went with end of 1st round start of 2nd

Must be more than $600 then you’d think but hey it’s the afl’s magic formula, anything could happen.

 

[PandaG]

Leek Aleer is exactly what we need with our list profile.
Caminity is not a backman and probably never will be.
I cannot understand the hesitation, its agreat get

 

[gubby88]

He’s turning 24 not 21 and has played 20 games.

Guys who only play when you have a long injury list don’t usually come with his price tag. It’s the usual story everyone in front of him is team of the century material and he’s going to break out and be a superstar.

You know what you usually find in other people’s trash ?, yep trash. If we were talking a third rounder and 3 x $500k I wouldn’t bat an eyelid, knock yourselves out give him an opportunity. You’d be surprised who we might actually be able to get for a second rounder and near enough to $900k.

Just the money alone has to be bloody insulting to quite a few currently on our list and playing every week. Do you think we’re offering that sort of money to windy and hall ?.

media reported it was 900...now reporting its 750...how do they know it really isnt 5-600?

 

[Yawkey way]

Disgrace they gave away their future for Tim Kelly .

How often does that sort of deal actually work out. Geelong are the masters of screwing over other clubs. Simple formula, pay only what you have to and ask for something stupid and wait for the counter offer.

 

[PandaG]

media reported it was 900...now reporting its 750...how do they know it really isnt 5-600?

They don't. They make things up. Usually report what the max contract is, which usually includes incentives, games played, Best and Fairest, etc. Someone here recently said, get the number and take off 20%.