List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion - part 2

[gringo2011]

Player had agreed to come and Carlton wanted a premium on his actual value.

He was a pick 17 and they moved up to get him from memory. They weren't going to throw him away and he had a pretty good season last year.

 

[stavro#4]

In the midfielder zone of the draft. In the bidding for Harry Dean part of the draft

Delicious

 

[gringo2011]

Thought Aliir looked pretty good today, can see him fitting in well if it happens.

I didn't think he looked very good. He takes a few grabs but can't defend.

 

[bird_man]

I hope you guys decide to play another young fella next year in place of Zak Jones.

Also that Travaglia kid looks like he will be a player. Onwards and upwards Sainters

Doesn't look like Zak will be offered another contract.

It's not like he was taking someone's spot though, we already had plenty of kids running around today.

 

[aidansbonor]

Man we are gonna miss windy next year. He’s definitely worth a first round pick though

Surely he's actually not going.

I'd 100% match norths contract to keep him

 

[bird_man]

Yeah nice to have a pick ahead of the Blues and not get pushed back with the TDK compo

 

[bird_man]

Surely he's actually not going.

I'd 100% match norths contract to keep him

Would seem crazy to let a young mid go when that's what we have been desperate for for years.

 

[ronnysnodgrass]

I didn't think he looked very good. He takes a few grabs but can't defend.

Yeah, he had a few changers for sure, but a few nice grabs and spoils as well. Let’s see, but excited all round to see what the team can do. Very much coming to the view we need to keep windy now, he played really well.

 

[Molly29]

Darcy Wilson played his best game for the club today, was outstanding and Max Hall must be recruit of the year

 

[Molly29]

Collard is supremely talented but just doesn't get enough of it - how do we fix it?

 

[Dard Ball Get]

Collard is supremely talented but just doesn't get enough of it - how do we fix it?

Keep playing him

 

[aidansbonor]

Would seem crazy to let a young mid go when that's what we have been desperate for for years.

Agree, would be a huge loss.

Imagine he was on another team and was linked to us this off season. We'd all be loving it that we're bringing in a young quality 2 way mid with upside.

 

[saintbill]

Yeah nice to have a pick ahead of the Blues and not get pushed back with the TDK compo

Was the perfect result.

 

[projectv]

Now we can bid on Harry Dean and easily pick up Fincher.

Perfect.

 

[Molly29]

Now we can bid on Harry Dean and easily pick up Fincher.

Perfect.

Just had a look at Harry Dean's highlights and he looks superb. A terrific intercept mark with good disposal, just what we need, a high quality tall defender

 

[saintbill]

We have to keep Windy. He is too versatile. Can play mid, wing, back.

Just get it done. We don't need Ryan, give Butler 1 more year and give Collard time.

 

[Sully111]

Anyone who thinks Windy is only worth 500k-ish is dreaming

 

[billings2paddy]

He's now our best inside mid.

We can't afford for him to leleave.

We need to re sign him
We dont have the A grade mids he nullifies one and still gets the footy
Don't need ryan
Keep Wilson in that mid/fwd role

 

[projectv]

Just had a look at Harry Dean's highlights and he looks superb. A terrific intercept mark with good disposal, just what we need, a high quality tall defender

Carlton will match, but it will eat into the TDK compo to get the points.

What a shame.

 

[SaintsofSteel]

In the midfielder zone of the draft. In the bidding for Harry Dean part of the draft

Delicious

This years draft are like watching a reserves U18 competition, compared to last years crop. All the better mids will be well gone again before our pick, we will look at positional needs the best small forward or key forward IMO.

 

[clarkie54]

Would we consider trading our first pick for the TDK and JSOS compo with the promise not to bid on Dean? Drop 2 spots and get an extra pick

 

[SainterinSydney]

We need to keep Windy. Club aren't stupid.

 

[Joffaboy]

We see Travaglia differently.

I thought he was the safest pick in the top 10. You just know pending injuries that he gets 200 AFL games.

What I can’t work out is his ceiling just yet.

Yes not a great kick. But great 1 on 1. Appears to have elite hands. Elite aerobic capacity. Versatile

I see him as a wingman who can run through the mids. Can run all day and is pretty good in open field. He and Wilson on the wings when Wood and Hill are gone.

 

[PJays]

Anyone who thinks Windy is only worth 500k-ish is dreaming

If I'm St Kilda, I put 3 offer sheets to him.

1. 4 years, 650k. 4th year games trigger- play 45 games in first 3 years

2. 4 years 600k

3. 3 years 650k

Go from there. I could be persuaded to go up a little if I honestly believed he was being offered significantly more and might leave.

Does St Kilda have the money though? Can we actually compete with North? When you pay your A graders huge coin, you have to count pennies on the B graders.

 

[billings2paddy]

I see him as a wingman who can run through the mids. Can run all day and is pretty good in open field. He and Wilson on the wings when Wood and Hill are gone.

Reid all day