List Mgmt. 2025 List Management II 📃

[Aphrodite]

 

[The Bighouse]

Not really the biggest fan of aleer dosnt look the best and would be demanding 700 -800k think there are better options out there and wouldn't have to break the bank

Same as we had allocated for JSOS, or thereabouts but we have youngsters earmarked for KPD posts.
L/T contract prob not our strong suit.

 

[The Bighouse]

Rather pick up Butts to free up Weitering to drop a few kgs and play CHB.

If we're looking for an athletic type Gray from the Tigs shows a bit and is up against about 10 other blokes for a spot down back. Looked good in his games this season though.

What about Blight?

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

What about Blight?

Could do worse but I think they're quite bullish on him long term from what I read so not sure they'd give him up easily

 

[The Bighouse]

Could do worse but I think they're quite bullish on him long term from what I read so not sure they'd give him up easily

Had a trigger which they didn’t invoke with selection, so could be on the outer vs others on the list. Could be ripe.

 

[Carltonfc9]

Same as we had allocated for JSOS, or thereabouts but we have youngsters earmarked for KPD posts.
L/T contract prob not our strong suit.

Alot of cheaper options i feel that could have the same if not bigger impact + think we should be saving coin to throw it at 2 xfactor mid / small forward/ running half back

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Getting band 1 for JSOS as well would be seriously good news for us. Would open the door to a lot of different options.

 

[We may never win again]

Had a trigger which they didn’t invoke with selection, so could be on the outer vs others on the list. Could be ripe.

Reckon there’s a slight chance he’s on the market as a DFA in a month or two

 

[mrb1]

Tom Morris reporting on footy furnace st kilda offering jsos 5 years 800-850k band 1 compo. Good chance pick 9 and 10 West coast keen to trade one of there top picks for multiple picks, surely pick 2 would make port seriously consider for butters. Either way get to work austin

If you trade away both compo picks how are you getting Dean, remembering we need next year's picks for Cody?

 

[Carltonfc9]

If you trade away both compo picks how are you getting Dean, remembering we need next year's picks for Cody?

Trade a future 2nd then so on the following year, the club need to start making things happen still have a team that could steal a flag if they are brave enough

 

[ITCHY EYEBALLS]

A player with good footskills can more than make up for a lack of leg speed….. just sayin

 

[The Blueseum]

A player with good footskills can more than make up for a lack of leg speed….. just sayin

Great decision making on the fly (in terms of dodging and giving off) and decent skills outweigh speed by a mile. See Greg Williams and Pendlebury.

 

[Red_man2008]

Tom Morris reporting on footy furnace st kilda offering jsos 5 years 800-850k band 1 compo. Good chance pick 9 and 10 West coast keen to trade one of there top picks for multiple picks, surely pick 2 would make port seriously consider for butters. Either way get to work austin

Be too hard to get Dean and ison without at least one of these picks. We very well may need to trade back into the early 20s ourselves to have the points.

 

[CJMB]

If you trade away both compo picks how are you getting Dean, remembering we need next year's picks for Cody?

Next year we probably need a top 5 pick for Cody to draft him outright.

 

[Moon]

Great decision making on the fly (in terms of dodging and giving off) and decent skills outweigh speed by a mile. See Greg Williams and Pendlebury.

Good examples and fair call ... although if speed is average you'd need X-factor like those two have/had.
Players like Cerra, Motlop, Crippa (who tries to bully his way out) and get caught don't have that X-factor.

Nothing impresses me more than a Grundy tap to Warner bursting towards the Goal at Warp speed and then launches a drop punt from the 50m line that flies through for a Goal at around the same time it took Usain Bolt to run 100 metres.

A fast break out of centre hardly allows other mids any time to react... it is footy poetry at its best imo.

 

[CJMB]

Speed’s pretty bloody handy when you don’t have the ball.

 

[Foucault1989]

What is the point if he continually butchers the ball?

We are trying to get decent ball users into the club, let alone deal with the player we currently have with poor disposal, and the players with good disposal that are departing.

Why in the absolute sweet living bejesus would we want to recruit a 32yo, that already shafted us despite rolling out the red carpet for him, who will not improve us 1 iota?

Year in, year out we draft in kids who play less than 20 games over their career and get delisted while we watch the successful teams bring it obviously good players who can make an impact.

I'm all about targeting proven afl quality who can improve us next year while the kids are developing. He was all Australian a year ago, he is a high quality afl player, better than 80% of our list. Let's win some games mate, sick of losing

 

[Ninja Worrier]

I don't think the lockout will come in until 2027 if at all

 

[Coona Blues]

I don't think the lockout will come in until 2027 if at all

If logic and equity are considerations it will never come in.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

A player with good footskills can more than make up for a lack of leg speed….. just sayin

With the ball, yes.

Without it, no.

Watching players like Hewett, Cripps and Cerra get burnt in open transition play by better runners on the oppo team will continue eternally until we get get some players on the outside who can close space using their leg speed effectively.

 

[Lukeblueboy]

With the ball, yes.

Without it, no.

Watching players like Hewett, Cripps and Cerra get burnt in open transition play by better runners on the oppo team will continue eternally until we get get some players on the outside who can close space using their leg speed effectively.

This!
It hurts us big time imo

 

[bradfisher14]

Getting band 1 for JSOS as well would be seriously good news for us. Would open the door to a lot of different options.

Maybe we need to have some gratitude for JSOS. He is sacrificing himself for the greater good of the club.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Maybe we need to have some gratitude for JSOS. He is sacrificing himself for the greater good of the club.

I'll still boo the crap out of him next year no matter what compo he gets us.

 

[Carltonfc9]

Be too hard to get Dean and ison without at least one of these picks. We very well may need to trade back into the early 20s ourselves to have the points.

I know it won't be easy but can be done trade a couple of future picks then do the same the following year for walker, I think we have to go all in with the playing list we have and just have a decent crack got enough young talent in at the moment it won't back fire to much

 

[sweethoney]

Won’t listen to offers: Carlton’s Curnow stance made clear

EXCLUSIVE | The Blues coach has spoken.

www.sen.com.au

 

[4flagsin5yrs]

Good examples and fair call ... although if speed is average you'd need X-factor like those two have/had.
Players like Cerra, Motlop, Crippa (who tries to bully his way out) and get caught don't have that X-factor.

Nothing impresses me more than a Grundy tap to Warner bursting towards the Goal at Warp speed and then launches a drop punt from the 50m line that flies through for a Goal at around the same time it took Usain Bolt to run 100 metres.

A fast break out of centre hardly allows other mids any time to react... it is footy poetry at its best imo.

When Cerra left Freo he was playing like an elite A grader.

We have all but destroyed him, it appears....

(a familiar tale sadly)