Recommitted Zach Merrett [UFA 2027] - Wanted a trade to Hawthorn, but it didn't get done

[Lore]

There we go, that's the clip:

 

[CaptainWorpedo]

Think I’ll go back to lurking, there is no reasoning with a few here.

Hawks hurt em real good…. Won a 3peat, fell to the bottom of the ladder…. and now back in a prelim whilst they remain at the bottom.

 

[Coasters7]

Are you against living in reality?

I gave clear evidence to support my claims. The advanced stats back me up too. This is one of his poorer years and it’s only downhill from here

 

[BIGHAWK23]

apparently Weddle is better than Nic Martin BIGHAWK23

Multiple quotes

Take a nap

 

[BIGHAWK23]

I gave clear evidence to support my claims. The advanced stats back me up too. This is one of his poorer years and it’s only downhill from here

You said poorest

Which one is it

Take the L

You chose the wrong horse

 

[dmark]

Just to clarify. Are you saying the O'Meara trade was unbalanced in favour of Freo or Hawks?

Just glad to see the back of him, was a gun junior, then didn’t make the grade.

He was just a bad trade, we traded for him as most clubs do on potential, and he has turned out to be a C grade player .

Lots and lots of them over the journey for all clubs.

 

[Yoda_]

Because he is. It’s not that hard.

I’ve never seen anyone in the media declare Martin could be the best player in the comp. Have you?

why are we trying to shift the goal posts?

 

[Yoda_]

Multiple quotes

Take a nap

more evidence which you and your mates seem to dismiss despite facts

 

[BIGHAWK23]

more evidence which you and your mates seem to dismiss despite facts

I provided you evidence surrounding defensive stats and score launches which are rated higher than anything you provided

But you can’t cope

 

[Yoda_]

I provided you evidence surrounding defensive stats and score launches which are rated higher than anything you provided

But you can’t cope

you made suggestions, not evidence

for the record, this season, Weddle versus Martin according to footy wire

 

[dmark]

Stat padding but here’s some for you

Weddle (as a defender)
More
Contested Possesions
Contested Marks
Intercepts
Score Launches (higher CD ranking)

Martin would struggle to a game for box hill, he is the king of the soft ball gets, he loves a little one two to het the stats up

 

[BIGHAWK23]

you made suggestions, not evidence

for the record, this season, Weddle versus Martin according to footy wire

That wasn’t suggestions

They were stats

 

[Yoda_]

That wasn’t suggestions

They were stats

could you pleaase provide the link of said stats? until then, mere here say from someone who has provided very little in the way of debate other than an argument of "because I said so"

 

[dmark]

Gets Hawks fans fired up. I know plenty in person and they’re all the same insecure types desperate to be seen as the best whilst no one really gives a shit

Interesting take, why are you in this tread ?

Mad monday over already for you, WC lads over seas again, and so early Again.

 

[BIGHAWK23]

could you pleaase provide the link of said stats? until then, mere here say from someone who has provided very little in the way of debate other than an argument of "because I said so"

AFL APP champ

Only verified form of statistics as it’s CD

Footy Wire done via a 3rd party analysis viewing platform

 

[CaptainWorpedo]

Just glad to see the back of him, was a gun junior, then didn’t make the grade.

He was just a bad trade, we traded for him as most clubs do on potential, and he has turned out to be a C grade player .

Lots and lots of them over the journey for all clubs.

To be fair, his chronic knee injury ruined his dynamic midfield field JNR days!

 

[Yoda_]

AFL APP champ

Only verified form of statistics as it’s CD

Footy Wire done via a 3rd party analysis viewing platform

I cant seem to break down where it stipulates position, can you elaborate or we cherry picking again ?

I see Weddle is average or above average for a large chunk of basic stats, Martin seems to be above average if not elite in many.

 

[BIGHAWK23]

The coping from Yoda_ to just not have to deal with the fact that their best player next year will be a stat padding hbf is hilarious to see

All this to project

 

[BIGHAWK23]

I cant seem to break down where it stipulates position, can you elaborate or we cherry picking again ?

I see Weddle is average or above average for a large chunk of basic stats, Martin seems to be above average if not elite in many.

Cherry picking?

You only mentioned 2 stats

Again, FootyWire isn’t a verified statistical site, you can edit it like Wikipedia

Won’t be trusting that thanks

Use the compare function, it might help

 

[Yoda_]

The coping from Yoda_ to just not have to deal with the fact that their best player next year will be a stat padding hbf is hilarious to see

All this to project

no coping, just facts. Martin plays wing. midfield so once again, proves another inaccuracy by you.

 

[BIGHAWK23]

no coping, just facts. Martin plays wing. midfield so once again, proves another inaccuracy by you.

You really are struggling today

You’ve derailed a whole thread just so you don’t have to live with the fact that Merrett is leaving

You said where hasn’t Martin been played, so? Which one is it

 

[Leather Poisoning]

Mate, he has handled it as piss poor as it comes. It’s terrible leadership.

That's my point.
You can't say it's terrible leadership AND say that he commands a higher price on account of being captain. The two things are opposite

 

[WilloTree]

Just glad to see the back of him, was a gun junior, then didn’t make the grade.

He was just a bad trade, we traded for him as most clubs do on potential, and he has turned out to be a C grade player .

Lots and lots of them over the journey for all clubs.

Yeah. He genuinly could have been anything pre-injury.

Hawks got a great deal when they sold him (broken and 29) for a 2nd rounder and Lloyd Meek. One of those trades that went down in the last minites of the last day and Freo got completely screwed.

 

[Yoda_]

That's my point.
You can't say it's terrible leaders AND say that he commands a higher price on account of being captain. The two things are opposite

the club is the one doing the trade, they should absolutely have the right to say "give us more, he is captain".

 

[BIGHAWK23]

Yeah. He genuinly could have been anything pre-injury.

Hawks got a great deal when they sold him (broken and 29) for a 2nd rounder and Lloyd Meek. One of those trades that went down in the last minites of the last day and Freo got completely screwed.

Do you think Hawthorn”screwed” freo, or was just a bad deal?

 

[dmark]

no coping, just facts. Martin plays wing. midfield so once again, proves another inaccuracy by you.

You just contradicted your self, - “what position wasn’t martin played in”
Well i would say all bar wing and midfeild - Weddle and Hawthorn win again