List Mgmt. Draftee, NGA and Father/Son Discussion - 2025

[eaglespremiers]

An A grader is Chris Judd at his peak.

Good to see the best midfielder this century at his peak makes A grade in your books.

 

[Donkers]

Good to see the best midfielder this century at his peak makes A grade in your books.

And there were games where Cousins still made him look ordinary. People seriously underrate just how good Cuz was. His absolute peak and best year in my min was 2001 before we even got Judd.

 

[Wooshaaaa]

Robinson, Cochrane and Walker. Would be a massive win if these new rules get over the line

Take the local boy

 

[Wooshaaaa]

I honestly believe Sharp will be there at Ports (suns) pick, Bitchmond don't need him either do Essendon, the priority would be to secure that pick from the Suns, so we could have all of Duursma, CDT and Sharp

Even if we do get that pick and have that belief I would be taking

Duusma cumming sharp. 3 very different types to round out our midfield. Along with Harley Hewett gross Kelly Tmac, hall, Allen and even the boy we have some defensive mids, offensive mids, clearance specialists, outside run and skill.

We don't need an oversized Brander, who can't ruck.

 

[Gittos16]

Even if we do get that pick and have that belief I would be taking

Duusma cumming sharp. 3 very different types to round out our midfield. Along with Harley Hewett gross Kelly Tmac, hall, Allen and even the boy we have some defensive mids, offensive mids, clearance specialists, outside run and skill.

We don't need an oversized Brander, who can't ruck.

Have you seen him play? The guy isn't Brander, he's a massive unit with a huge tank, with those ruck rules changing he will be a massive Weapon for us and a point of difference against other teams, definitely worth a shot.

 

[txbyhull]

Have you seen him play? The guy isn't Brander, he's a massive unit with a huge tank, with those ruck rules changing he will be a massive Weapon for us and a point of difference against other teams, definitely worth a shot.

Except he can’t ruck. Barely beats guys his own age or outright loses the contest

 

[Wooshaaaa]

Have you seen him play? The guy isn't Brander, he's a massive unit with a huge tank, with those ruck rules changing he will be a massive Weapon for us and a point of difference against other teams, definitely worth a shot.

He can't ruck. Barely gets off the ground when he jumps. Beaten by his ruck peers at all levels this year, so how is he going to compete with the likes of gawn meek Briggs

Everyone needs to stop thinking this guy is some unicorn. He may well be a decent footballer in 5yrs, but as a forward/ruck, not a ruck.

He wouldn't be in our best 23 for the next few years, unless, he could play key defender? But where the evidence we take a kid at pick 2 as a defender, who isn't a ruck, hasn't played defender.

We needs mids. He's not a mid.

 

[Kegs15]

C’mon mate Hewett, Gross, and Allan would at this stage all be C or D grade players based on output.
An A grader is Chris Judd at his peak.
I wish you were my teacher at school I would have killed it

Still think there needs to be an S tier for utterly exceptional players (my nitpicking two cents). Give a grade for special players whilst still letting deserved A's be A's.

Judd, GAJ, Martin, Buddy, Bont at peak = S tier

A tier feels like say Yeo at his peak.

 

[PremiershipNo4]

Still think there needs to be an S tier for utterly exceptional players (my nitpicking two cents). Give a grade for special players whilst still letting deserved A's be A's.

Judd, GAJ, Martin, Buddy, Bont at peak = S tier

A tier feels like say Yeo at his peak.

Why make it more complicated than it needs to be.
A grade is reserved for the best of the best.

 

[BSD]

Freddy Rodriguez with 1.1 and only 11 disposals close to 3/4 time in the Colts final against East Freo. Seems to have really fallen off the pace after a suboptimal champs.

Meanwhile Freo’s underage NGA Lucas Robinson has 28 disposals 7 tackles and 0.2. They’d be spewing if they change the NGA/father son rules next year. What a shame…

I would hardly call being really of the pace after a suboptimal champs someone who was 1 of only 3 west australians selected as A/A Fred was also voted as West Australia's MVP at the championships.

 

[random260]

Duff-Tytler - 12 disposals (7k 5hb) 4 marks 2 tackles 14 hitouts 1.1

In Coates basically U18 mmmk

 

[Elite Pete]

The draft bolter? Has done it again.

Sullivan Robey BOG 27d 2.0 4t

 

[Ambrose Burnside]

Duff-Tytler - 12 disposals (7k 5hb) 4 marks 2 tackles 14 hitouts 1.1

In Coates basically U18 mmmk

Pick 1 worthy

 

[eaglespremiers]

Duff-Tytler - 12 disposals (7k 5hb) 4 marks 2 tackles 14 hitouts 1.1

In Coates basically U18 mmmk

He's no Zaydyn Lockwood.

 

[eaglevision]

Freddy Rodriguez with 1.1 and only 11 disposals close to 3/4 time in the Colts final against East Freo. Seems to have really fallen off the pace after a suboptimal champs.

Meanwhile Freo’s underage NGA Lucas Robinson has 28 disposals 7 tackles and 0.2. They’d be spewing if they change the NGA/father son rules next year. What a shame…

Wouldn’t read too much into this game for Fred, he’s playing injured. Robinson is a gun, I have him ranked #5 in next year’s cohort.

 

[Mulldogg]

Wouldn’t read too much into this game for Fred, he’s playing injured. Robinson is a gun, I have him ranked #5 in next year’s cohort.

Which is a great result…

 

[BSD]

Which is a great result…

W.A"s next 3 AFL stars will all come from that S.F. colts team Freddy, Toby Whan and Lucas Robinson

 

[maverick001]

Freddy Rodriguez with 1.1 and only 11 disposals close to 3/4 time in the Colts final against East Freo. Seems to have really fallen off the pace after a suboptimal champs.

Meanwhile Freo’s underage NGA Lucas Robinson has 28 disposals 7 tackles and 0.2. They’d be spewing if they change the NGA/father son rules next year. What a shame…

don't know the first thing abour Robinson, but if there's one thing I've learned about the draft over the last # of years, it's that the WA bloke everyone thinks will be a top 3 lock 12 months ahead of the draft rarely turns out to be that.

 

[maverick001]

And there were games where Cousins still made him look ordinary. People seriously underrate just how good Cuz was. His absolute peak and best year in my min was 2001 before we even got Judd.

I don't recall anyone ever making Judd look ordinary. Certainly not while he was at the Eagles.
I do agree with you though, people forget how good Cousins was. Certainly his off field exploits have taken the shine off.

 

[maverick001]

The draft bolter? Has done it again.

Sullivan Robey BOG 27d 2.0 4t

Is he the bloke who had 40 & kicked 3 last week?

 

[maverick001]

Wouldn’t read too much into this game for Fred, he’s playing injured. Robinson is a gun, I have him ranked #5 in next year’s cohort.

Will be intriguing to see where F-Rod goes in the draft.

 

[Elite Pete]

Is he the bloke who had 40 & kicked 3 last week?

Yeah that’s him.

 

[Eastern Rangers]

Wouldn’t read too much into this game for Fred, he’s playing injured. Robinson is a gun, I have him ranked #5 in next year’s cohort.

Fred was tagged. Robinson is a bit of a blunt instrument.

 

[Wce17]

Both Banfields look like they are having good games stats wise for claremont at the moment.

 

[Eastern Rangers]

Both Banfields look like they are having good games stats wise for Claremont at the moment.

Harper suited the conditions. Charlie is just a gun and on field leader. Benji and Curtin having great games in the conditions.

Farrow isn't a midfielder, not sure why he's talked of as a top 10 pick.