Beerfish
Unscripted Hot Takes
- Joined
- Jan 20, 2008
- Posts
- 65,134
- Reaction score
- 111,062
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Nic Martin
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

BigFooty Tipping Notice Img
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 10
The Golden Ticket - Corporate tickets, functions, Open Air Boxes at the Adelaide Oval, ENGIE, Gabba, MCG, Marvel, Optus & People First Stadiums. Corporate Suites at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Soccer Notice Image
Champions League - FINAL - PSG v Arsenal ā½ FA Cup Final ā½ Europa Semis ā½ 2026 FIFA Series A - Socceroos friendlies ā½ The Matildas x 2026 Womens Asia Cup ā½ Conference League - SEMIS! ā½ Conference League - Rd of 16 ā½ Socceroos Internat'l Friendlies ā½
Fantasy Footy Notice Image Round 10
SuperCoach Rd 10 Trades - Rd 10 SuperTalk - VC/Captain ,//, AFL Fantasy Rd 10 Rd 10 Fantasy Talk - Trades! - AFLF VC / Captains
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
What were they going hard at parish over?Thomas and Riewoldt were scathing of Parish on the 7 coverage and hard to disagree with what they said. If the coach is serious about improving team defence, then Parish cannot play until he improves that part of his game. Iād rather give Setterfield a try, he is not highly skilled but he is at least hard at it.
Jogging along.What were they going hard at parish over?
What were they going hard at parish over?
A few of our players second guessed contests yesterday. Something that wasn't there in the Dees game.As bad as he was defensively at times the more shocking part was there were also times when he was putting in more effort to chase than several others.
He will never totally get defence. It is very easy to see why. You can watch him during games and see multiple times where he watches and tracks the footy and has no awareness whatsoever of players moving through his area. He watches and drifts across and the opposition just run behind him.
The more concerning thing for me was the fumbles and poor skill execution along with the habit he seems to have this year as far as short stepping a few contests. It is not something he had in his game when he was playing decent football 4 years ago. Simply cannot have any of it in his game if we have to carry the defensive issues.
Yep I was jokingTo what end?
That would be like breeding an ineffective plow horse with a donkey to get a mule.
I canāt easily recall more fumbles on a dry day than yesterday. Some of it pressure, some of it perceived pressure.A few of our players second guessed contests yesterday. Something that wasn't there in the Dees game.
Duursma in particular had a couple.
Maybe nerves on the big stage, lots of fumbles too. Pies relish the contest. It is between the ears.
It was pretty clear McCrae's plan was to scrap the ball forward and deny us possession and time to get our short kicking game going. You could see the poor quality of their i50s in the first term especially was indicative of this. And because so many of our team are young they took a while to adjust to the Pies' intensity... they didn't adjust. Couple that with seniors fumbling or squibbing, and by the second term the pressure has been totally perceived by our team and Collingwood are finding more and more time while we also start jogging.I canāt easily recall more fumbles on a dry day than yesterday. Some of it pressure, some of it perceived pressure.
Old man who is a Pies fan said the same thing. Parish is the anti Leon Baker, usually one of his diabolical efforts or turnovers triggers a wave of goals for the opposition like vs Gold Coast where he refused to go to a ball despite it being a low physical risk situation because Rowell was nearby - it was a shocking non effort that triggered a run on for them.I canāt easily recall more fumbles on a dry day than yesterday.
I am not sure I have seen worse efforts than some of the stuff he has dished up this year, the young guys can't see this stuff not punished as well. If Setters doesn't get injured training or walking the dog he can take Parish' place for the near future.should be dropped. Even with how shit the lost is, effort should be non negotiable
Iāll take fumbles and poor skill execution over someone who isnāt accountable and doesnāt run hard or put in consistent competitive efforts for his team.As bad as he was defensively at times the more shocking part was there were also times when he was putting in more effort to chase than several others.
He will never totally get defence. It is very easy to see why. You can watch him during games and see multiple times where he watches and tracks the footy and has no awareness whatsoever of players moving through his area. He watches and drifts across and the opposition just run behind him.
The more concerning thing for me was the fumbles and poor skill execution along with the habit he seems to have this year as far as short stepping a few contests. It is not something he had in his game when he was playing decent football 4 years ago. Simply cannot have any of it in his game if we have to carry the defensive issues.

