12/10 rule for Bendigo.

[ant555]

Makes it hard to pick out the 12 guys to play. This is one rule that needs to be looked at. One area that annoys me with this rule is the fact that rookies on AFL lists count in the 12. I think Barney mentioned a good idea a few weeks ago and that is if a rookie isnt promoted to the senior list then he shoulnt count as an AFL player but as a VFL player and it is totaly correct. Where else can they play other than the VFL?
As for this weeks side , Richards, Hunt ,Watson , Monfries ,Dyson ,Widerlich ,and Cartledge all have to be in.
Thomas, Nash , Wilson and Slatts have all filled similar roles so one or two of them may miss.
Henno will more than likely play as we have missed having the talls the last 5 weeks.
As for the rest, anyone got a coin.

 

[slugger]

Hunt and Richards come back to fill KPP defence, Jobe will go to CHF/FF and with Cartledge and Beasy, there's no need for Henno.

Sheeds might be upset if Henno and Reynolds are overlooked. Most BB posters would leave them both out.

 

[ant555]

Hunt and Richards come back to fill KPP defence, Jobe will go to CHF/FF and with Cartledge and Beasy, there's no need for Henno.

Sheeds might be upset if Henno and Reynolds are overlooked. Most BB posters would leave them both out.

I dont think Reynolds will get in , i dont particulary want to see Henno in either but he has been handy at times in defence.Personally i hope that Nash,Slatts ,Thommo and Wilbur all get a run before Henno.

 

[Longy413]

Cartledge's form in the last two games has been embarrassing. I'd play Henno ahead of him. Bain will be stiff to miss out, as will Cupido, Nash and Bullen. Slattery, Johns, Connaughton injured.
Tough side to pick, not sure if I've missed someone.

My side would be as follows -
Jolley Hunt Reynolds
DOERING Richards Thomas
Winderlich BLUMFIELD ROSA
ROBINS Watson CARTER
Monfries BEASY Wilson
Henneman Dyson Alvey

RICHARDSON, VIGUS, PENDELBURY, CHILDS

 

[windyhill]

Ahhh , Cupido ?

 

[pazza]

My Bendigo side for this week would be (smile Johnny..the boy is in)

B: Wilson, Hunt, Doering
HB: Richards, Henneman, Rosa
C: Alvey, Winderlich, Dyson
HF: Blumfield, Beasy, Robins
F: Cupido, Watson, Carter
R: Cartledge, Thomas, Jolley
Int: Marsh, Childs, Vigus, Pendlebury

 

[Longy413]

Players like Monfries win you finals.
He has to play.

 

[Pevers-Legend]

Bullen, alvey and haynes - should all be no no no. no future so why play em - delist em as soon as finals are over - only back up value.

Play Gus, Ricky, Jobe, Winderdud, and guys liek that. The ones we are going to build our future around. Let em have a taste of finals. Hopefully we might just be able to go somewhere this year.

 

[Longy413]

The Official Side (Essendon players in Bold)


B Wilson Henneman Reynolds
HB Dyson Pendlebury Thomas
C Hunt Bullen Winderlich
HF Rosa Robins Doering
F Blumfield Richards Carter
R Beasy Watson Vigus
Int Slattery Connaughton Nash
** Cupido Childs Monfries
** Alvey Jolley

Only two of those on the bench can play and I think it might be Monfries and either Jolley or Cupido.

No Cartledge.

 

[Darealrath]

That's a fair VFL side named. Are they strong favourites ?

 

[alex1fun]

That's a fair VFL side named. Are they strong favourites ?

is it tomorrow one o'clock in Port Melbourne, TEAC OVAL?

 

[pazza]

Given it's against Port, at Port, it would be very close to even money.