List Mgmt. 2014 Draft Trade FA Megathread

[Manimal_Dunstan]

Kyle Martin is another TDL way to good for VFL not so good at AFL.. Wouldn't touch we need elite talent not average players.

carlton just delisted tom temay. was he the saints supporter alot of people wanted us to draft a couple years back?

His father played for us.

 

[Half Back Pocket]

It is morally reprehensible to send any of our beloved players - or for that matter innocent young kids in the draft - to hell. Melbourne are called the Demons for a reason.

No trading with them. No priority picks. To go to the Melbourne Football Club is to destroy a person's career before they've even started it.

Agree...Pick 1 = Pick 2 & 3 or GTFO!

 

[Defacto]

Kyle Martin is another TDL way to good for VFL not so good at AFL.. Wouldn't touch we need elite talent not average players.

His father played for us.

thats the one!!! thank christ we arent the list managers then. sounds like we dodged a bullet there. that or carlton is shite. probably a bit of column a and bit from column b

 

[Barrels]

carlton just delisted tom temay. was he the saints supporter alot of people wanted us to draft a couple years back?

Brions just delisted Isaac Conway after only a year too; there's a premium on kicking skills these days methinks.

 

[VDS66]

Come on folks...

If the mods came in and deleted all the silly ideas, this thread would still be on page 1.

 

[VDS66]

thats the one!!! thank christ we arent the list managers then. sounds like we dodged a bullet there. that or carlton is shite. probably a bit of column a and bit from column b

I think we also dodged a bullet with Dustin Martin.

 

[Barrels]

Come on folks...

If the mods came in and deleted all the silly ideas, this thread would still be on page 1.

Pick 1 for Casboult and pick 5!

 

[VDS66]

Pick 1 for Casboult and pick 5!

Only if we throw in Jack and Dave as steak knives.

 

[God Save Max King]

Until Lever does his knee again.

Extremely pessimistic way at looking at it, do you think Essendon are unhappy with Heppell? I would do Pick 1 for Lever and Weller, would be a fair deal for all parties, although I'd love to grab someone in the top 4 this year.

 

[dewah07]

Extremely pessimistic way at looking at it, do you think Essendon are unhappy with Heppell? I would do Pick 1 for Lever and Weller, would be a fair deal for all parties, although I'd love to grab someone in the top 4 this year.

To be fair a player who has done his acl before is 30% more likely to do it again compared to someone who hasent done it

 

[Barrels]

Extremely pessimistic way at looking at it, do you think Essendon are unhappy with Heppell? I would do Pick 1 for Lever and Weller, would be a fair deal for all parties, although I'd love to grab someone in the top 4 this year.

TBF, Big R, Lever's knee worries me a bit too.

That being said, I'd be delighted to snare him, but I do think that Marchbank is on a similar level as far as talent goes, and that both Durdin and Goddard get extra points for their versatility.

Even drafts create tough calls.

 

[God Save Max King]

TBF, Big R, Lever's knee worries me a bit too.

That being said, I'd be delighted to snare him, but I do think that Marchbank is on a similar level as far as talent goes, and that both Durdin and Goddard get extra points for their versatility.

Even drafts create tough calls.

Disagree that they are on similar levels talent wise. Marchbank is an elite mark and not much else, while Lever has better intangibles and offers more rebound. He's also a centimetre or two taller. Durdin has failed to perform this year while Goddard is really not too flash at all up forward.

 

[Periphery]

Extremely pessimistic way at looking at it, do you think Essendon are unhappy with Heppell? I would do Pick 1 for Lever and Weller, would be a fair deal for all parties, although I'd love to grab someone in the top 4 this year.

Maybe, but it is still a big risk. I'm not sure it would be worth it to pick him up at the expense of one of the top 4 in this draft. More so when we consider our need for a froward like McCartin.

In a few years time when our first pick is number 8 and we are climbing back up the ladder we might be in a position to take that chance but I don't think we can just yet.

However, if pick 1 turned into picks that got us Lever, Duggan and Weller I might be tempted to change my mind.

 

[Jezzarayman]

I also see us making a play for Melbourne's pick 2...and the only guys that can net us that are Steven and Armo...so maybe something like

Steven and Curren for Pick 2 & 22
Armo and our second for Pick 2
Steven for Pick 2

We get Pick 1 & 2 GWS can go and stuff themselves:

Saints get Petracca and Mccartin..Thx Melb

This is the trade we have to do and take the best U18 midfielder and forward in the country. Although I'm still a Peter Wright fan.

 

[FlyingSledghamer]

I dont think its so straight forward that melbourne have pick 3.
Firstly JF might only bring band 2. Dont forget its up to the afl commision and the priority pick might only be band 2 if anything also.
They have to consider all things including how the club only restructured 1 season ago. Also despite what hes going to be paid which isnt going to be 700k anyway i think they have the discretion to only give them band 2. I could see them getting picks 20 + 21 possibly.
Its not certain yet.
Did they change the rules this year so that clubs know what their getting at the start of the period so they have time to use those picks in trade?

 

[Manimal_Dunstan]

Sam Maclure on 3AW just said St Kilda are working on a package with GWS involving pick 1 one of the players is Kristian Jaksch.

 

[FlyingSledghamer]

Sam Maclure on 3AW just said St Kilda are working on a package with GWS involving pick 1 one of the players is Kristian Jaksch.

Please be devon smith. Please be devon smith

 

[God Save Max King]

I think Frawley will fetch Band 1, he'll reportedly be on a $2.5m deal, which I think is the same as Daisy's (4x625k). Regardless, I would prefer to have Pick 4, Jaksch and 20 than Pick 3 and 20.

 

[sammm]

carlton just delisted tom temay. was he the saints supporter alot of people wanted us to draft a couple years back?

didn't his father Paul play for the saints.

 

[Periphery]

I think Frawley will fetch Band 1, he'll reportedly be on a $2.5m deal, which I think is the same as Daisy's (4x625k). Regardless, I would prefer to have Pick 4, Jaksch and 20 than Pick 3 and 20.

I think Frawley is reportedly on $2.5m over 5 years so I'm not sure how that effects it.

 

[Barrels]

I think Frawley will fetch Band 1, he'll reportedly be on a $2.5m deal, which I think is the same as Daisy's (4x625k). Regardless, I would prefer to have Pick 4, Jaksch and 20 than Pick 3 and 20.

IF Jaksch comes to us, where does he play? ATM, Delaney will be at FB, Bruce would/should be at CHB, Roo will remain at CHF and Spencer has done himself no harm in staking his claim for FF...

 

[TheLastEmperor]

Dunell and TDL delisted today

http://www.saints.com.au/news/2014-09-02/st-kilda-list-changes

 

[TheLastEmperor]

Sam Maclure on 3AW just said St Kilda are working on a package with GWS involving pick 1 one of the players is Kristian Jaksch.

Interesting.

 

[hayes]

No surprises there. Shame about Dunell, don't know where his foot skills disappeared to.

 

[12Chill]

IF Jaksch comes to us, where does he play? ATM, Delaney will be at FB, Bruce would/should be at CHB, Roo will remain at CHF and Spencer has done himself no harm in staking his claim for FF...

Back pocket to play on the third tall?? Not sure.