Analysis 2016 AFL Trade Week Thread

[Zombie]

I hope you're all considering the possibility that Collingwood might come to us with a decent pick/player for Jonas or O'Shea with Brown off to the Aints.

Maybe the Aish and Greenwood talk last week was for one of our backmen?

I'd be surprised if they put Aish's name up for just O'Shea or Jonas (You never know tho...) more likely to target someone like Clurey I'd say.

 

[charcolechaddy]

I thought Aishs end of the season was pritty good.

Not the type we need though

 

[Ford Fairlane]

I would say it is more than likely they bring in one of Armo/Barlow as well so there is another spot gone. I don't think you'll find they will give up a 2nd rounder because they wouldn't be able to take them though, they will be looking to trade for some future picks or maybe snag a big player if they can afford it.

They could also bring in Hanley and Witts. They're going to delist Brooksby anyway so if we want him we can get him as a DFA. Squeeze them for a better player if we want one.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

Goldstein reported to have had a medical at West Coast. That would shut the door on Vardy or maybe dislodge Giles.

 

[Pappaya]

Goldstein reported to have had a medical at West Coast. That would shut the door on Vardy or maybe dislodge Giles.

Wouldn't that be something.

 

[Far Kern]

Goldstein reported to have had a medical at West Coast. That would shut the door on Vardy or maybe dislodge Giles.

Is he worried that he caught something? Sensible move I guess.

 

[Traveling_Power]

Hopefully if Goldstein leaves we can ship lobbe off for a third rounder

I am thinking the same .. but the Roo's don't have a 3rd rounder in this draft .... they do have 2 x 2nd rounders (pick 32 and picks 33) so hopefully we could get 1 of these picks

 

[Traveling_Power]

Cam O'Shea for Greenwood. Carn CD.

+ 1

 

[Traveling_Power]

No way Amon.

Amon has said in the past that he goes missing in games ...

(this might only be because he is in experienced in game time but it might not) ..

 

[Traveling_Power]

How about Achee + 45 + 2017 2nd rounder for 26+30

That gives us a few 2nd rounders this year and Gold Coast another 2nd rounder next year for Academy prospects

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

instead of our 2017 second rounder .. I would swap it for our 2017 third rounder ..

 

[BrockBlitz]

Goldstein reported to have had a medical at West Coast. That would shut the door on Vardy or maybe dislodge Giles.

Source ?

 

[Robbie4PM]

- Lobbe to North for 33.
- Ah Chee to GC for 44
- Hartlett + 44 for Rocky
- O Shea + 33 for Greenwood

 

[It Just Is]

Goldstein reported to have had a medical at West Coast. That would shut the door on Vardy or maybe dislodge Giles.

That probably dislodges Lycett not Giles.

They surely would not go into a season with 3 ruckman taking up $2m+ in salary cap.

 

[Doctor Feel]

Source ?

fantasyfootballnuts.org

 

[Traveling_Power]

I hope you're all considering the possibility that Collingwood might come to us with a decent pick/player for Jonas or O'Shea with Brown off to the Aints.

it will depend on what they are planning to do with the 2 father son picks that they will have in this draft

 

[Visenfest]

- Lobbe to North for 33.
- Ah Chee to GC for 44
- Hartlett + 44 for Rocky
- O Shea + 33 for Greenwood

The end result of your proposed trade is basically:

Out: Ah Chee, Hartlett, Lobbe and O'Shea.
In: Greenwood and Rockliff.

Chris Davies would deserve to be sacked on the spot for even entertaining the idea.

 

[Robbie4PM]

The end result of your proposed trade is basically:

Out: Ah Chee, Hartlett, Lobbe and O'Shea.
In: Greenwood and Rockliff.

Chris Davies would deserve to be sacked on the spot for even entertaining the idea.

So replacing 4 players who probably aren't in our best 22 with 2 that would make it is bad trading.

Logic.

For the Hartlett debate, he has been told he won't be playing midfield and I'd rather play Bonner than him, so he shouldn't even get a game.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

Source ?

WAToday, reported in the afl.com.au round up.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-10-16/trade-winds-lewis-offered-three-years-by-dees

 

[King_Tredrea]

So replacing 4 players who probably aren't in our best 22 with 2 that would make it is bad trading.

Logic.

For the Hartlett debate, he has been told he won't be playing midfield and I'd rather play Bonner than him, so he shouldn't even get a game.

He has? Source?

 

[Robbie4PM]

He has? Source?

Sources from inside the walls which can't be disclosed

I don't get how that swap would be bad. Do people think Greenwood and Rockliff are bad players or something lol.

 

[Established1870]

He has? Source?

I prefer mayonnaise personally.

 

[King_Tredrea]

Sources from inside the walls which can't be disclosed

I don't get how that swap would be bad. Do people think Greenwood and Rockliff are bad players or something lol.

I would rather Hartlett than both of them, personally

 

[Ford Fairlane]

Does this mean they'll pick up Nathan's brother Mitch who is also tipped to walk out on West Coast?

They've denied they will chase Mitch.

 

[Doctor Feel]

I've rated St. Kilda and the way they've been travelling and building. I think they will be in the eight this year, but it's difficult to say who will fall out of the eight, aside from North.

 

[Nemisis]

I've rated St. Kilda and the way they've been travelling and building. I think they will be in the eight this year, but it's difficult to say who will fall out of the eight, aside from North.

Saints will definitely make top 8 - North will do 'Freo' next year.