Analysis 2016 AFL Trade Week Thread

[Adz2332]

Lol Barry Curtin saying Gibbs has had a medical at Alberton

lol why not... offer pick 9 make adelaide trump it

 

[Arsene Wenger]

Would you swap Gibbs for hammer straight up ?

I would

 

[Doctor Feel]

He's trolling pretty hard, said "The last time this happened was with Jared Polec" did lol.

 

[Waspy79]

Would you swap Gibbs for hammer straight up ?

I would

Yes

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Would you swap Gibbs for hammer straight up ?

I would

no.

HH is a younger Gibbs IMO

 

[Arsene Wenger]

no.

HH is a younger Gibbs IMO

Gibbs has been far more consistent and has proven he can play through the middle ... but yes I certainly see your point !

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Gibbs has been far more consistent and has proven he can play through the middle ... but yes I certainly see your point !

yeah true, but Gibbs was where HH is now about 3 years ago....

 

[Puddy]

The Crows wouldn't trade Crouch for Gibbs, let alone Crouch + 13 for Gibbs. Rightly or wrongly, they view him as their best mid for the next decade.

Still think it'll be 13 + Lyons.

Lyons is a better footballer than B Crouch imo

 

[Willsy10]

I think pick 13 and Lyons seems like a reasonable deal, Lyons is a bit of a quiet achiever, he can play. I think Brad Crouch is massively overrated at the crows so that will never happen, and honestly I reckon Lyons just about is better than Crouch. 13 and McGovern seems like overs for the crows.

 

[Arsene Wenger]

What about

Gibbs - Crows
Hartlett - Carlton
Pick 13 - Port

throw a few other picks around and all are happy

 

[Holden Hillbilly]

What about

Gibbs - Crows
Hartlett - Carlton
Pick 13 - Port

throw a few other picks around and all are happy

Hartlett doesn't want to leave. Unless he is advised he will be playing Ressies on recent form then we are stuck with him and Lobbe for years.

And no capacity to trade in a big player with our 9 players on $500k a year.

 

[Visenfest]

What about

Gibbs - Crows
Hartlett - Carlton
Pick 13 - Port

throw a few other picks around and all are happy

Would do that, but doubt Hartlett would come to the party.

 

[Ported]

Would not trade HH for Gibbs unless there are big personality/leadership conflicts going on that we're not aware of.

 

[Alyx]

A Geelong fan on Trade Radio just proposed the following scenario. Hopefully I have it correct, because it was a lot of nonsense to take in at once:

Geelong lose: Horlin-Smith, Motlop, Vardy.
Geelong gain: Deledio, Rockliff, Tuohy, second-round pick.

Port Adelaide lose: Hartlett, second-round pick.
Port Adelaide gain: Horlin-Smith, Vardy.

Carlton lose: Tuohy, second-round pick.
Carlton gain: Hartlett.

Richmond lose: Deledio.
Richmond gain: Second-round pick.

Brisbane lose: Rockliff.
Brisbane gain: Motlop.

Summary:
- Port Adelaide trade Hartlett and a second-round pick to Geelong for Horlin-Smith and Vardy.
- Hartlett is on-traded to Carlton, in breach of trade rules, for Tuohy and a second-round pick.
- Carlton's second-round pick is sent to Richmond in exchange for Deledio.
- Motlop is traded to Brisbane in exchange for Rockliff, so he can be reunited with his 'good mate' Christensen.

Words. I have none.

 

[croweyrocks]

What about

Gibbs - Crows
Hartlett - Carlton
Pick 13 - Port

throw a few other picks around and all are happy

Could have sworn Hartlett said he didn't want to leave?

 

[Portia]

lol

 

[Ash_Tray_Bon]

What do ppl think of this trade :

Trade 1

Port : Out - Hartlett | In - Pick 13 (Crows)

Crows : Out - Pick 13 | In - Gibbs

Carlton : Out - Gibbs | In - Hartlett

Trade 2

Port : Out - Pick 9 & Lobbe | In - Picks 15 (GWS), 16 (GWS) & Barrett

GWS : Out - Picks 15, 16 & Barrett | In - Pick 9 & Lobbe

____

Port in : Picks 13, 15 & 16 & Barrett
Port Out : Pick 9, Hartlett & Lobbe

 

[JimmyBeerCans]

Gibbs at Port would be good just to watch his Dad have kittens.. no chance in hell & no chance we'll be helping the Crers get a deal done either in reality.

 

[mic59]

A Geelong fan on Trade Radio just proposed the following scenario. Hopefully I have it correct, because it was a lot of nonsense to take in at once:

Geelong lose: Horlin-Smith, Motlop, Vardy.
Geelong gain: Deledio, Deledio, Rockliff, second-round pick.

Port Adelaide lose: Hartlett, second-round pick.
Port Adelaide gain: Horlin-Smith, Vardy.

Carlton lose: Tuohy, second-round pick.
Carlton gain: Hartlett.

Richmond lose: Deledio.
Richmond gain: Second-round pick.

Brisbane lose: Rockliff.
Brisbane gain: Motlop.

Summary:
- Port Adelaide trade Hartlett and a second-round pick to Geelong for Horlin-Smith and Vardy.
- Hartlett is on-traded to Carlton, in breach of trade rules, for Tuohy and a second-round pick.
- Carlton's second-round pick is sent to Richmond in exchange for Deledio.
- Motlop is traded to Brisbane in exchange for Rockliff, so he can be reunited with his 'good mate' Christensen.

Words. I have none.

Sounds to be a Geelong fan based in reality. Don't think this guy has any idea that Geelong have their own salary cap problems as well and may not be able to do anything about their favoured trades i Deledio and Tuohy.

 

[Arsene Wenger]

Could have sworn Hartlett said he didn't want to leave?

Could have sworn Davies said yesterday everything is still on the table. It's a hypothetical champ.

 

[rumoursofwinter]

Port Adelaide lose: Hartlett, second-round pick.
Port Adelaide gain: Horlin-Smith, Vardy.

That is brilliant. If only we had a second round pick.

Hartlett and a second rounder for two players ready to be delisted in a side with no depth. Woot.

 

[Jonts]

I'd actually take Hartlett for 13

But won't happen
Trade radio is sen and fiveaa home schooled child

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

A Geelong fan on Trade Radio just proposed the following scenario. Hopefully I have it correct, because it was a lot of nonsense to take in at once:

Geelong lose: Horlin-Smith, Motlop, Vardy.
Geelong gain: Deledio, Rockliff, Tuohy, second-round pick.

Port Adelaide lose: Hartlett, second-round pick.
Port Adelaide gain: Horlin-Smith, Vardy.

Carlton lose: Tuohy, second-round pick.
Carlton gain: Hartlett.

Richmond lose: Deledio.
Richmond gain: Second-round pick.

Brisbane lose: Rockliff.
Brisbane gain: Motlop.

Summary:
- Port Adelaide trade Hartlett and a second-round pick to Geelong for Horlin-Smith and Vardy.
- Hartlett is on-traded to Carlton, in breach of trade rules, for Tuohy and a second-round pick.
- Carlton's second-round pick is sent to Richmond in exchange for Deledio.
- Motlop is traded to Brisbane in exchange for Rockliff, so he can be reunited with his 'good mate' Christensen.

Words. I have none.

can i post this in the 'trade radio 2016' thread on the D/T board?
cos this is gold!

 

[Visenfest]

A Geelong fan on Trade Radio just proposed the following scenario. Hopefully I have it correct, because it was a lot of nonsense to take in at once:

Geelong lose: Horlin-Smith, Motlop, Vardy.
Geelong gain: Deledio, Rockliff, Tuohy, second-round pick.

Port Adelaide lose: Hartlett, second-round pick.
Port Adelaide gain: Horlin-Smith, Vardy.

Carlton lose: Tuohy, second-round pick.
Carlton gain: Hartlett.

Richmond lose: Deledio.
Richmond gain: Second-round pick.

Brisbane lose: Rockliff.
Brisbane gain: Motlop.

Summary:
- Port Adelaide trade Hartlett and a second-round pick to Geelong for Horlin-Smith and Vardy.
- Hartlett is on-traded to Carlton, in breach of trade rules, for Tuohy and a second-round pick.
- Carlton's second-round pick is sent to Richmond in exchange for Deledio.
- Motlop is traded to Brisbane in exchange for Rockliff, so he can be reunited with his 'good mate' Christensen.

Words. I have none.

Must be something funny in the water over in Geelong. What a bizarro trade.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Must be something funny in the water over in Geelong. What a bizarro trade.

Can vouch for that! haha

our main river has been overflowing for a good month now...