Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2016 List Management: Contracts, Trading, Drafting, Academy

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Bad trade period IMO. I miss Gubby

The moment we were brought back to the normal list size ahead of schedule this was going to happen. :(
 
Glad we've got something in for next year anyway, I wouldn't imagine Collingwood's second being in the 30's next year, hell could be as low as 19 or 20. You'd have to say clearing the space and the potential pick that we may get, we've done pretty well out of it.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

3 players out in quick succession, hopefully this is just a sign that we are getting deals done today. Should bode well for getting Marchbank, Pickett, Deledio etc. deals done.
With the flurry of activity in the last hour, why don't we just have a 3 day trade period? Far more exciting than the arduous process we have now.
 
so Stewart for a Mars bar and WHE for a 2nd rounder.

The consensus on the Pies board is that we have been walked all over , even with the Gubbinator around.

How do you guys reconcile those results (Stewart vs WHE).........fair representation of their relative worth or not?
 
so Stewart for a Mars bar and WHE for a 2nd rounder.

The consensus on the Pies board is that we have been walked all over , even with the Gubbinator around.

How do you guys reconcile those results (Stewart vs WHE).........fair representation of their relative worth or not?

WHE was fairish, though more than I expected given the trades to date.
Stewart was a bargain. Two rounds below what I thought he should be.
 
so Stewart for a Mars bar and WHE for a 2nd rounder.

The consensus on the Pies board is that we have been walked all over , even with the Gubbinator around.

How do you guys reconcile those results (Stewart vs WHE).........fair representation of their relative worth or not?

With his body the way it has been this year, overs.
If his body gets right, far and away unders.
It's a big question mark to be honest.
 
so Stewart for a Mars bar and WHE for a 2nd rounder.

The consensus on the Pies board is that we have been walked all over , even with the Gubbinator around.

How do you guys reconcile those results (Stewart vs WHE).........fair representation of their relative worth or not?
WHE was fairish, though more than I expected given the trades to date.
Stewart was a bargain. Two rounds below what I thought he should be.
WHE with a year to run on his contract and Stewart out of contract also has an impact.

Stewart definite unders but that seems to be the way the trade market is at the moment.

I think WHE will be fair or good value over time for Collingwood, if it's considered overs then Gubby perhaps felt he owed us for his part in the 2014 draft class... Side note: WHE and his partner are close with Treloar and Kelsey.
 
Reckon we are pumping Richmond to pay as much of Deledio's contract as possible. I've no doubt this is the delay. If they pay 300k plus its just gold!

With their move for Caddy and Prestia they cant have him back so we can really screw them down on this.

The delay is Carlton and Gibbs need the pick for Marchbank
 

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Carlton have apparently traded our future 2nd to Hawthorn to help them get O'Meara.
Must have a trade gone through because I don't believe they have our's at the moment - we've got our's, Collingwood's and St Kilda's.

Edit: And Geelong have Carlton's.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2016 List Management: Contracts, Trading, Drafting, Academy

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top