Draft Review 2016 - Revisiting the 2016 AFL Draft

[Yoda_]

Can honestly say yep, got that wrong at time of writing. Obviously had a good stretch off games that made me over ate his position in the draft.

Things change, other players get better, some stagnate. Still, cant complain with an AFL standard AFL player even if it isn't going to amount to a superstar we all crave

 

[craffles]

Can honestly say yep, got that wrong at time of writing. Obviously had a good stretch off games that made me over ate his position in the draft.

Things change, other players get better, some stagnate. Still, cant complain with an AFL standard AFL player even if it isn't going to amount to a superstar we all crave

Fair assessment, the position you are drafted at guarantees nothing and there is a strange obsession with it well into players careers and even post. Sure, clubs could have gotten other players etc but what’s the point in those what if scenarios, they achieve nothing other than stroking some egos tbh.

 

[Wild Bill]

Fair assessment, the position you are drafted at guarantees nothing and there is a strange obsession with it well into players careers and even post. Sure, clubs could have gotten other players etc but what’s the point in those what if scenarios, they achieve nothing other than stroking some egos tbh.

It’s a re draft thread. Its only purpose is to expose the bad picks and highlight the good ones.

McGrath is a bad one.

 

[Wild Bill]

Daicos may start to play more in the middle. Went into beast mode in the last quarter - 16 disposals, 2 goals, quality centre clearances, quality score assists.

The highest ranked champion data quarter for the year.

 

[Yoda_]

It’s a re draft thread. Its only purpose is to expose the bad picks and highlight the good ones.

McGrath is a bad one.

is a (probable) 300 200 game captain a bad pick ?

 

[Wild Bill]

is a (probable) 300 200 game captain a bad pick ?

If he slid to Bris he wouldn’t get close to being captain or anywhere near 300 games. He isn’t a good number 1 pick - his disposal and decision making isn’t AFL standard.

 

[Yoda_]

If he slid to Bris he wouldn’t get close to being captain or anywhere near 300 games. He isn’t a good number 1 pick - his disposal and decision making isn’t AFL standard.

nuh

 

[Wild Bill]

nuh

Yeah you have to post that as you listed him as a better player than McCluggage, Larkey, Daicos just to name a few.

 

[Yoda_]

Yeah you have to post that as you listed him as a better player than McCluggage, Larkey, Daicos just to name a few.

couldn't care less about any of those players you listed, we are debating your suggestion that Andy McGrath is no good.

suggesting he isnt AFL standard is showing your tainted views as I would argue every club in the competition would welcome him into there best 23.

 

[RedmanWasHere]

All who are left are in the beginnings of their 10th pre-seasons.

We're now at the point of knowing what we're getting from each player.

Who'll be the second to 200 career games?

 

[Wild Bill]

couldn't care less about any of those players you listed, we are debating your suggestion that Andy McGrath is no good.

suggesting he isnt AFL standard is showing your tainted views as I would argue every club in the competition would welcome him into there best 23.

Whose spot does he take in Brisbane’s team? McCluagge’s?

You believe his disposal is AFL standard? His decision making is poor as well. Dump kick specialist.

 

[eth-dog]

Whose spot does he take in Brisbane’s team? McCluagge’s?

You believe his disposal is AFL standard? His decision making is poor as well. Dump kick specialist.

Please, this is pathetic even for you.

If we take any other player he goes pick 2. It's well known that GWS were taking him if we didn't. So not only is your argument pathetic due to your bias against Essendon but irrelevant because if we took McCluggage GWS take McGrath ahead of Brisbane.

It's a sad state you live in. When your club hasn't beaten the team you despise so much, who is also pretty shit, for a decade's worth of matches. And that club finding yours nigh on irrelevant and not even in the top third of rivals in the AFL. I'm sure you'll have some witty reply to this, deflecting away from that fact but everyone here knows the truth by now.