Is band 3 2nd round compo and what happens if we don't have a 2nd round pick ?
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Analysis 2017 List Management Discussion Part II
- Thread starter BrisbaneCFC
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Status
Is band 3 2nd round compo and what happens if we don't have a 2nd round pick ?
HBF
Flying Scotsman
- Sep 24, 2002
- 156,523
- 102,204
- AFL Club
- Carlton
KJ has the talent, just not the drive to make it at AFL level.
What makes it worse was the SOS warned the footy club about taking him on, yet we still went ahead with the trade.
To think we could have drafted Peter Wright that year.
HBF
Flying Scotsman
- Sep 24, 2002
- 156,523
- 102,204
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Palmer has a contract for next year iirc, and I suspect Gorringe will be shown the door.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but wasn't Palmer on a 2-year deal? I didn't see him on our 'out of contract' list in the article from April.
EDIT: Didn't update page and you beat me to it HBF
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
- Sep 26, 2004
- 48,827
- 66,144
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Moderator
- #3,905
Band 1 - First round
Band 2 - End of first round
Band 3 - Second round
Band 4 - End of second round
If we don't have a 2nd round pick but receive band 3 compensation, the compensation pick will slot into where our pick would have been.
Any pick in the 20-30 range is a good win out of the Cas situation. While the pick on its own might not be to a great advantage, it can definitely be the "and something" that gets another high profile deal over the line.
We honestly have to thank Cas if that's what he nets us as we would have gotten penuts for him at the end of last season.
We honestly have to thank Cas if that's what he nets us as we would have gotten penuts for him at the end of last season.
- Banned
- #3,907
Imagine if Casboult does go, you can just picture him playing against us taking 15 marks, kicking 8.0 including the sealer after the siren from 20m in front. Bookmark it haha
- Mar 1, 2005
- 7,766
- 15,778
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- carlton
I'd be happy with getting our second pick back for Cas. It would be in the ballpark of what we'd get for trade anyway. A KPF one rung below the top players (maybe I'm being generous) at his age is worth a pick in the 20s.
Jimmae
Brownlow Medallist
Band 4 might be as late as 40.
- Sep 26, 2004
- 48,827
- 66,144
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Moderator
- #3,911
I think most of us would be and I suspect the club would be as well.
This year we're a bit lucky - for want of a better term - that our band 2 and 4 picks won't be far off 1 and 3, so if Levi gets paid we're well placed to benefit from it quite considerably.
There's also band 5 though. That's a 3rd round pick and I suspect that may be a different story. In a weak draft I'm not sure we'll be happy with a pick 40 odd for Levi, which is where I suspect the mooted interest in someone like Trengove might come into play.
Jimmae
Brownlow Medallist
???
Band 4 is end of second round, i.e. pick 37 at the minimum. That's miles away from band 3, but close to band 5.
Let's back-track to 2016: Ty Vickery - tier 2 key forward - netted a $500k x 2 year deal and earned Richmond Band 3 (2nd Round Pick) compensation.
Whilst the cap has gone up 20%, having the same money on the table; being a similar player; and having a deal twice as long (reported to be 4 years) for a total deal worth $2 million - I'd say the AFL will (and absolutely should) give us Band 3 compo i.e. in place of our traded 2nd round pick ~19/20.
Whilst the cap has gone up 20%, having the same money on the table; being a similar player; and having a deal twice as long (reported to be 4 years) for a total deal worth $2 million - I'd say the AFL will (and absolutely should) give us Band 3 compo i.e. in place of our traded 2nd round pick ~19/20.
All we can do is wait for the result.
Does the AFL advise the club which band of compensation they'd receive after a FA gets an offer?
After the deal is done I believe Shan. IIRC, they don't tell the club in advance - lest it affect their decision.
That'd be too easy now, wouldn't it
Heres Waite
Club Legend
I may be wrong, but didn't St Kilda enquire with the AFL about the level of compo when they lost Dal Santo?
Might have enquired but not sure the AFL would've actually told them up front.*
*Could be wrong
Vickery and Mayne got band 3 last year and Cas could potentially get a better offer and may sneak into band 2, which would give us two 1st rounders, to send to GWS for Josh Kelly.
Probably slightly unrealistic, but we can dream.
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Sep 26, 2004
- 48,827
- 66,144
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Moderator
- #3,920
Whoops, yes indeed.
- Oct 4, 2015
- 16,263
- 32,289
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Band 3 is 2nd round compo and if we don't have a pick it still counts as the pick after the one we would have had.
Yep and I don't care what it is. A lot of very good players have been drafted at 40 or higher. It's another pick for us and for SOS to work his magic. What number was Williamson recruited at?
I don't know about 'too easy' but it would certainly make too much sense for the AFL. Couldn't have clubs making informed decisions...After the deal is done I believe Shan. IIRC, they don't tell the club in advance - lest it affect their decision.
That'd be too easy now, wouldn't it
Chism
Franks & Beans
- Sep 7, 2008
- 40,412
- 41,215
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Cowboys/Pacers HotSpurs/Dodgers
Not real happy with Levi wanting out after all we did selecting him very late and maturing him into the great mark he is today and these blokes are hard to find in the AFL these days.
It just seems we put all the hard work and background into big bodied players and then they want to leave us when they are close to their prime i.e Sam Jacobs also.
Watch Levi kill us every time we play the Tigers now and he also leaves a void in back up ruck duties and Matty K needs help. We are going to still have a lot of holes to fill with only so many picks in the draft this season which is reported to be very weak.
AFL will screw us on compo as well i reckon.
It just seems we put all the hard work and background into big bodied players and then they want to leave us when they are close to their prime i.e Sam Jacobs also.
Watch Levi kill us every time we play the Tigers now and he also leaves a void in back up ruck duties and Matty K needs help. We are going to still have a lot of holes to fill with only so many picks in the draft this season which is reported to be very weak.
AFL will screw us on compo as well i reckon.
Levi doesn't want to leave, but we've hardly 'loved' him over the course of his time with us.
Jacobs didn't really want to leave, but left for the right reasons, having been fourth in line for ruck duties.
............and, as if Casboult is going to kill us with the mighty beast manned up on him.
Jacobs didn't really want to leave, but left for the right reasons, having been fourth in line for ruck duties.
............and, as if Casboult is going to kill us with the mighty beast manned up on him.
- Status
Similar threads
