Analysis 2018 List Management discussion Pt 2

[Stamos]

It's world class.

And so it should be

 

[La Dispute]

Goddard as a DFA too. Play him on a wing/half-forward line

Think we’d get decent value

 

[FRUMPY]

The club email headlined 'Silvagni calls time' had me scratching my head (popped up on my phone and hadn't read it). Was thinking surely not SOS and then surely not Jack. Had forgotten about Alex. Was a good pickup for last year, even just that game against the swans was worth it.

 

[Arr0w]

And so it begins, Alex Silvagni's retirement, who else will come off our list this year

 

[CJMB]

And so it begins, Alex Silvagni's retirement, who else will come off our list this year

Would guess all the planned retirements will be announced in the lead up to this weekend so the players can get a bit of a send off, playing or not.

 

[Soapy V]

Would guess all the planned retirements will be announced in the lead up to this weekend so the players can get a bit of a send off, playing or not.

Some may well have been told we can't make a decision until after trade period.

 

[Soapy V]

And so it begins, Alex Silvagni's retirement, who else will come off our list this year

Graham
O'Shea
Mullett
G-Mac

then a few may well be waiting. Be a few nervous players

 

[Soapy V]

Goddard as a DFA too. Play him on a wing/half-forward line

Think we’d get decent value

That's not funny

 

[Arr0w]

Graham
O'Shea
Mullett
G-Mac

then a few may well be waiting. Be a few nervous players

I think we may keep Mullet and move Shaw on, but both could go

Le Bois will be a consideration along with, Phillips and Casboult

 

[La Dispute]

That's not funny

1-year contract, play him on a forward flank and leverage his experience.

Hodge looked cooked but has had a decent year in Brisbane - no reason BJ can’t do the same with a change of scenery.

He will mellow

 

[Arr0w]

1-year contract, play him on a forward flank and leverage his experience.

Hodge looked cooked but has had a decent year in Brisbane - no reason BJ can’t do the same with a change of scenery.

He will mellow

No thanks, we have enough senior bodies/experience

 

[La Dispute]

No thanks, we have enough senior bodies/experience

Very little quality experience. Murphy, Doch, Cripps, Thomas, Simpson, Kreuzer and then a significant drop

BJ would be a very good get

 

[Robertio]

I just think there is no doubt we will pick him and as a rookie it's very cheap. Kid has ability. I think he has been "hidden" a bit

A lot.

 

[Stamos]

Very little quality experience. Murphy, Doch, Cripps, Thomas, Simpson, Kreuzer and then a significant drop

BJ would be a very good get

Always a good get.
Wait...

 

[Robertio]

I'm not so sure from what I have seen Soapy..

Could make a very good defender. Once he's with the big boys he will lift his intent at the footy, looks to have the skill department covered.

 

[Robertio]

I dunno if you can "hide" a 3rd generation Silvagni. He might be just not that good.

He might be a good player as well.

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

I think we may keep Mullet and move Shaw on, but both could go

Le Bois will be a consideration along with, Phillips and Casboult

Im wondering if we can tempt the Suns to take on Levi for a third rounder of theirs, 38 or 41. We don't have a third rounder. I think Levi could be a good experienced pick up for them for not much.

 

[CJMB]

1-year contract, play him on a forward flank and leverage his experience.

Hodge looked cooked but has had a decent year in Brisbane - no reason BJ can’t do the same with a change of scenery.

He will mellow

Would much rather that forward flank is filled by Fisher, Samo, Cuningham, Dow, Pickett, Lang or just about any of our younger guys.

Besides, even with our record membership numbers this year, I'm not sure we have the money for that kind of pretzel budget...

 

[Soapy V]

I think we may keep Mullet and move Shaw on, but both could go

Le Bois will be a consideration along with, Phillips and Casboult

Issue is we may make anywhere between 6-12 changes depending upon what happens during trade/FA period. We will be active so a fair few players may be waiting a while to learn their fate

 

[Arr0w]

Very little quality experience. Murphy, Doch, Cripps, Thomas, Simpson, Kreuzer and then a significant drop

BJ would be a very good get

Quality, Experience, Leadership are all different

Perhaps adding these names, Ed, Lobbe, Rowe, Wright. That's 10 names in total

Surely you have seen what Goddard has been like, even this year. I doubt the club would want that type of leadership

 

[La Dispute]

Would much rather that forward flank is filled by Fisher, Samo, Cuningham, Dow, Pickett, Lang or just about any of our younger guys.

Besides, even with our record membership numbers this year, I'm not sure we have the money for that kind of pretzel budget...

BJ is an upgrade on Matt Wright. Cuningham and Lang are average, there’s serious question marks on Pickett and we would really develop Fisher, SPS and Dow as mids.

 

[Soapy V]

Quality, Experience, Leadership are all different

Perhaps adding these names, Ed, Lobbe, Rowe, Wright. That's 10 names in total

Surely you have seen what Goddard has been like, even this year. I doubt the club would want that type of leadership

.....then add names like Shiel Dahlhaus McGovern maybe Miles. I count Cripps Docherty Plowman now as leaders and experienced players. In that area I think we are fine

 

[SkyhorseTamer]

Very little quality experience. Murphy, Doch, Cripps, Thomas, Simpson, Kreuzer and then a significant drop

BJ would be a very good get

Tell me how he’s at all quality. He may know his stuff but doesn’t appear to be overly well liked or respected. Could be wrong.

 

[La Dispute]

Quality, Experience, Leadership are all different

Perhaps adding these names, Ed, Lobbe, Rowe, Wright. That's 10 names in total

Surely you have seen what Goddard has been like, even this year. I doubt the club would want that type of leadership

Those guys are B-graders who haven’t had the benefit in playing in grand final teams.

BJ will bring plenty

 

[La Dispute]

Tell me how he’s at all quality. He may know his stuff but doesn’t appear to be overly well liked or respected. Could be wrong.

He’s played some good footy at Essendon, he’s just had a down year and found himself on the outer

.....then add names like Shiel Dahlhaus McGovern maybe Miles. I count Cripps Docherty Plowman now as leaders and experienced players. In that area I think we are fine

I’d be incredibly surprised if any of those names bar Miles are on the list next year. Myopic