2018 Rate My Team (Post JLT)

[Mitchell54]

These are basically the 2 structures i'm considering
Rookies will be shuffled
Mid premos are still not locked

This setup



Or

This Setup

Changes considering in this team

Goldy --> Nank (depends on what happens with Pruess)
If the above happens then i'll be considering
Petracca --> Billings


Thoughts will be greatly appreciated as i'm in the final stages of consolidating a team

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Smith McLean and Walters should be top 6 by the end of the year caddy ofcourse is a risk but that’s why you have 30 trades no point taking no risk and having the same team as everybody else

Top 6 in your team or top 6 forwards overall?

 

[atlas1]

These are basically the 2 structures i'm considering
Rookies will be shuffled
Mid premos are still not locked

This setup

View attachment 469148

Or

This Setup

Changes considering in this team

Goldy --> Nank (depends on what happens with Pruess)
If the above happens then i'll be considering
Petracca --> Billings
View attachment 469168

Thoughts will be greatly appreciated as i'm in the final stages of consolidating a team

So Goldy + Petracca v Nank + Billings?

Would go Nank and Billings

 

[Seymour Skinner]

So how far into the first game will we before for HS and all the live scores websites shit themselves?
I'm tipping that the scores will freeze halfway through the first quarter.

 

[Dennis Trumpet]

Newest version with Parker.

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Current team

Not 100% happy yet for some reason and starting to get pretty nervous. It would be nice to nail a starting team for once! I have around 20k left.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Current team

Not 100% happy yet for some reason and starting to get pretty nervous. It would be nice to nail a starting team for once! I have around 20k left.

View attachment 469177

Structure wise, looks great ......just a matter of settling your thoughts on a few players

 

[Mitchell54]

So Goldy + Petracca v Nank + Billings?

Would go Nank and Billings

Yeah. For options regarding that 2nd team it is that
Would leave me with 200 dollars left though

differences between the 2 teams above is
Sicily, Lycett, Parker/Cripps & def rookie (leaves 3 def rookies including Naughton)
V
Laird, Goldy, mid Rookie & def Rookie (leaves 3 def rookies including Naughton & 3 mid rookies including Brayshaw)

 

[Gavin Excell]

Parker back in favour? Personally i had thought he was a fading premo

 

[nameless]

Parker back in favour? Personally i had thought he was a fading premo

A fading premo at 25yrs old?

 

[stevebbb]

Parker back in favour? Personally i had thought he was a fading premo

 

[Gavin Excell]

Interesting. I thought he was late 20s

 

[Better Loosen Up]

View attachment 469188

View attachment 469187

DELETE THIS POST!!!!!!!!!

 

[Plugger Mcnally]

This is my team so far. After a few years off, it is proving a hard task. I think there is some good value with mid price this year and many upgrades.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

This is my team so far. After a few years off, it is proving a hard task. I think there is some good value with mid price this year and many upgrades.
View attachment 469189

delete and start again

 

[Better Loosen Up]

This is my team so far. After a few years off, it is proving a hard task. I think there is some good value with mid price this year and many upgrades.
View attachment 469189

Great team! Wouldn't change any of it!

 

[Dennis Trumpet]

This is my team so far. After a few years off, it is proving a hard task. I think there is some good value with mid price this year and many upgrades.
View attachment 469189

 

[Spacedog]

Current setup. Choosing a ruck after gawn is hard. I'm just going with ryder, hes pretty safe except the bye is shit. I'll worry about it when it happens I guess. I dont want lycett at all. The only other option id consider is martin atm. Everyone else is pretty much locked. Ive left about 120k in the bank for danger but I'm not sure how Id get him or who would go.

 

[blackshadow]

This is my team so far. After a few years off, it is proving a hard task. I think there is some good value with mid price this year and many upgrades.
View attachment 469189

Was that an auto pick team?

Sent from my F8331 using Tapatalk

 

[Spacedog]

Was that an auto pick team?

Sent from my F8331 using Tapatalk

You're laughing now but just see who is laughing when E Hughes averages 120.

 

[Spacedog]

This is my team so far. After a few years off, it is proving a hard task. I think there is some good value with mid price this year and many upgrades.
View attachment 469189

I like the Conor Menadue pick. He should be a good option for your VFL supercoach side.

 

[Leftyitis]

Is it okay having 3 players from the same team in the one line, as I have Fyfe, Banfield and Brayshaw. Should I only pick 2 or is lots of people picking these 3

I feel if you consider the players to be premo then so be it. I like Brayshaw and Banfield, however, I'm not going with two rookies from the same team, soley due to lack of loopholing prospects.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

I feel if you consider the players to be premo then so be it. I like Brayshaw and Banfield, however, I'm not going with two rookies from the same team, soley due to lack of loopholing prospects.

Stupid reason IMO

 

[atlas1]

This is my team so far. After a few years off, it is proving a hard task. I think there is some good value with mid price this year and many upgrades.
View attachment 469189

I'd keep Fyfe, Whitfield, Sicily from that team.

Yeo is apparently playing a new role and may not score as well as last year.

Daniher, Weitering and Smith have the potential to be real PODs.

Trac is better suited as a forward.

Fritsch, Coffield, Murray and Holman should be good rookies.

Nuke the rest of your team though.

 

[ROOINYOU]

Current team

Not 100% happy yet for some reason and starting to get pretty nervous. It would be nice to nail a starting team for once! I have around 20k left.

View attachment 469177

Sidebumb a great POD and can go large too
Good use of Sicily DPP with Keefe.
Good team!