2018 Rookies

[Mofra]

Lachie Murphy's JS prospects - good, fair, poor?

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Lachie Murphy's JS prospects - good, fair, poor?

fair IMO

 

[tommyv49]

Naughton, Murray, Doedee, Finlayson & Murphy.

Need 3 starters, think i'm just gonna go bye their JLT averages,
Which would mean Naughton Murray and Finlayson.

 

[Marlowe]

Save me time...whats the verdict?

Imagine it's Brayshaw.

 

[Sir Hugh Percy]

I googled and watched some footage of Clark, Banfield, Brayshaw and LDU. After watching this the decision is reasonably obvious.

Yeah of course, I mean... yeah. But... just out of interest, what do you reckon?

 

[Me Myself and I]

Naughton, Murray, Doedee, Finlayson & Murphy.

Need 3 starters, think i'm just gonna go bye their JLT averages,
Which would mean Naughton Murray and Finlayson.

Same five for me to pick from. I'm going with the three you picked.

 

[LuvtheKangas]

Amazing how we can rationalize a decision .....of course LDU's scores were poor, for a rookie at his price .....so what changes, simply because Brodie is not picked

It's why I never bother with these Twats that set themselves up as SC gurus on twitter. They're 100% reactionary.

LDU has never left my side. As a North supporter, I watched closely and am very pleased with what I saw. Good JS and midfield role suggests that he is a safe pick.

 

[Untouchables22]

Lachie Murphy's JS prospects - good, fair, poor?

I would think poor to fair.

We are looking for someone to replace Charlie Cameron's role, long term, whether that him or Hampton (or Galluci or Knight when they are fit) I guess we will find out.

Tex will come back in for Fogarty (or Jenkins). Tom Lynch will also need to come back in. Although he plays a different role to Murphy, there's only so many you can squeeze into a team.

 

[Sir Hugh Percy]

Who has the better JS: Barry or Banfield?

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Who has the better JS: Barry or Banfield?

Banfield

 

[Gene Simmons]

I'm gonna pull the trigger on Brodie but to who?

Either LDU, Clarke or Barry

Note; already have Brayshaw, Garlett, T.Kelly, Holman as my other midfield rookies...

 

[suns303]

With Will Brodie not getting named, im thinking LDU or Hunter Clark? I think LDU has better job security but clark may be a better scorer, what do you guys think?

 

[Hai_Newman]

fair IMO

I'm taking Finlayson over him.

 

[SavDog23]

I'm gonna pull the trigger on Brodie but to who?

Either LDU, Clarke or Barry

Note; already have Brayshaw, Garlett, T.Kelly, Holman as my other midfield rookies...

I'm in the same dilemma.
I went to Barry, but I don't think he will play that many games, so i'm tempted to keep Brodie on the bench this week in hopes Dew doesn't be a total campaigner and leave him out in RD 2 as well.
******* campaigner coaches at it again.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

I'm in the same dilemma.
I went to Barry, but I don't think he will play that many games, so i'm tempted to keep Brodie on the bench this week in hopes Dew doesn't be a total campaigner and leave him out in RD 2 as well.
******* campaigner coaches at it again.

Take Clark or LDU, in that order IMO

 

[DaveyBoy123]

Naughton, Murray, Doedee, Finlayson & Murphy.

Need 3 starters, think i'm just gonna go bye their JLT averages,
Which would mean Naughton Murray and Finlayson.

I think many have the same 5... & most will go the same 3 as you on field.

I'm actually a little concerned on Doedee... That Crows back line looks rather tall. I know Kelly & Brown can play small'ish, but I can't see all 5 of them (including Talia & Hartigan) playing from week to week... And Cheney is also lurking as an emergency.

Any thoughts on this Crows supporters?

 

[raymagoo]

Nick Holman to debut #supercoach

Not a debut already played at blues

 

[raymagoo]

Take Clark or LDU, in that order IMO

Can you take Clark when not even dunstan can get a game?

 

[raymagoo]

Annnd there's the random bloke we've never heard of.

If you followed footy a bit more you might! Dad was a champion hawk and he spent a few years on blues rookie list

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Can you take Clark when not even dunstan can get a game?

Dunstan is poo

Clark > Coffield > Dunstan

 

[raymagoo]

Dunstan is poo

Clark > Coffield > Dunstan

Averaged 100 the last 6 weeks or so last year

 

[Faz 2000]

Can you take Clark when not even dunstan can get a game?

I was surprised about that. Dunstan not on bench, not even an emergency. What the hell? Wasn't he being talked up as future captain material? And he was bloody good at the end of last year too.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Averaged 100 the last 6 weeks or so last year

dont let stats get in the way of my thinking

 

[pincrusher]

Think this is already common knowledge, but just in case....

 

[Seymour Skinner]

Higgins smacked the Blues in the VFL praccy
had 11 touches at half time (3rd most), don't know how many he ended up with.
Ended up with 3 snags tho.