Prediction 2018 trade hypothetical thread

[sydney_gws]

It all depends if a club has a specific target they are after in the draft and whether they will be there at their pick. Max King was mentioned which is a great example, if Freo are very keen on him and see Cerra as a serious flight risk then it might be worth pulling the trigger.

Again, I wouldn't necessarily do it, but the value is around the right mark.

What if max king is also a flight risk.

 

[Donakebab]

What if max king is also a flight risk.

It's all purely hypothetical anyway, but there haven't been any rumours surrounding King not wanting to play outside of Vic, while there are around Cerra.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

What would Marco Paparone cost. A 3rd round pick?

Probably a $2 scratchie and a free coffee voucher would do it.

But I'm sure Brisbane would take a third rounder if you're offering...

 

[bungalow_bill]

It's all purely hypothetical anyway, but there haven't been any rumours surrounding King not wanting to play outside of Vic, while there are around Cerra.

Is it just a general feeling that he is unhappy in WA? Quotes from friends?

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

You would end up with 3 very good players if that happened...all for pick 5 or 6

Yes exactly that's why they at looking at that senerio to give away that early pick to one club for a player not worth that at this point in his career and a second round coming back, so they can move in and get J Magovern and can play in Victoria together.
Like is said it's only been a suggestion and a bit of poking by the club at this stage. But it was the person that told me a week afyer Josh resigned with the Lions that he is still getting to the Dogs.
And Boyd was going to come to the dogs before it was released, but also said Hurley would be a dog too but got that wrong.

 

[briztoon]

Brisbane at Brisbane, Saints at Etihad and GC at GC. All in the next 4 weeks. Should be very interesting to see

Brisbane have lost Harris Andrews for a few weeks, Gold Coast have lost Tom Lynch for the rest of the year, Saints have a worse midfield than yours.

 

[Crow till I die]

Yes exactly that's why they at looking at that senerio to give away that early pick to one club for a player not worth that at this point in his career and a second round coming back, so they can move in and get J Magovern and can play in Victoria together.
Like is said it's only been a suggestion and a bit of poking by the club at this stage. But it was the person that told me a week afyer Josh resigned with the Lions that he is still getting to the Dogs.
And Boyd was going to come to the dogs before it was released, but also said Hurley would be a dog too but got that wrong.

Just reading between the lines with what you are saying, your source thinks Mitch wants to come to the dogs. Not having a pop or anything, just interested to know if there is more to it as most at the crows think it (McGovern wanting to leave) is a beat up and a bit of muck raking by 'others' in the media

 

[Drewie11]

Brisbane have lost Harris Andrews for a few weeks, Gold Coast have lost Tom Lynch for the rest of the year, Saints have a worse midfield than yours.

Yeah Gibbs, Sloane and the Crouch’s are a shit midfield. Get off the sauce fella

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Just reading between the lines with what you are saying, your source thinks Mitch wants to come to the dogs. Not having a pop or anything, just interested to know if there is more to it as most at the crows think it (McGovern wanting to leave) is a beat up and a bit of muck raking by 'others' in the media

I want told if Mitch's manager has spoken to the dogs, just got told it is one plan in place among several

 

[Groin guru]

North:

Gaff and Sloane via free agency.

Shai Bolton for a third rounder.

DeGoey for a first rounder and Sam Durdin.

T.Thomas for a second rounder.

Mountford for west coast's second rounder.

Dumont for port's second rounder.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Is it just a general feeling that he is unhappy in WA? Quotes from friends?

There is nothing but the fact he hasn't extended his contract, which given his recent form was probably a good idea

 

[bungalow_bill]

There is nothing but the fact he hasn't extended his contract, which given his recent form was probably a good idea

Pffft

The trend these days is for kids to extend the initial contract in their first year and anyone that doesn't is assumed to be wanting out

 

[Nuggs Bunny]

North:

Gaff and Sloane via free agency.

Shai Bolton for a third rounder.

DeGoey for a first rounder and Sam Durdin.

T.Thomas for a second rounder.

Mountford for west coast's second rounder.

Dumont for port's second rounder.

What about Adam Cerra?

 

[Mego Red]

North:

Gaff and Sloane via free agency.

Shai Bolton for a third rounder.

DeGoey for a first rounder and Sam Durdin.

T.Thomas for a second rounder.

Mountford for west coast's second rounder.

Dumont for port's second rounder.

1. Maybe, but there's not a great history of free agents getting to you.
2. Articles saying he's coming to the Crows.
3. Durdin has no value, so you'd need to offer more.
4. Maybe for Tim Thomas. Tarryn will go earlier.
5. Overs for Mountford.
6. Maybe.

On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Suma Magic]

North:

Gaff and Sloane via free agency.

Shai Bolton for a third rounder.

DeGoey for a first rounder and Sam Durdin.

T.Thomas for a second rounder.

Mountford for west coast's second rounder.

Dumont for port's second rounder.

I reckon Mountford is worth more than Thomas.

 

[cotter101]

1. Maybe, but there's not a great history of free agents getting to you.
2. Articles saying he's coming to the Crows.
3. Durdin has no value, so you'd need to offer more.
4. Maybe for Tim Thomas. Tarryn will go earlier.
5. Overs for Mountford.
6. Maybe.

On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app

North get a 20% discount and can bundle picks to help pay for Thomas IIRC.

 

[briztoon]

Yeah Gibbs, Sloane and the Crouch’s are a shit midfield. Get off the sauce fella

Was thinking you were a Carlton fan when I replied, didn't even bother looking to see who you supported.

 

[philthy05]

North:

Dumont for port's second rounder.

Lol **** no

Dreaming

 

[Turbocat]

North:

Gaff and Sloane via free agency.

Shai Bolton for a third rounder.

DeGoey for a first rounder and Sam Durdin.

T.Thomas for a second rounder.

Mountford for west coast's second rounder.

Dumont for port's second rounder.

and then you woke up...

Most of these are unlikely.

 

[PAFC_1870]

Carlton still play Brisbane, St Kilda and Gold Coast

Pick 1 no certainty

Ironic given your name... forgot the Kreuzer Cup?

Carlton can do anything they put their mind too

 

[Hammer time 2018]

Do you think any clubs would consider the following? If so who do you think wins?

Carlton-
Out: pick 1, 23, 26 (based of current positions), Cunningham
In: cerra, b crouch, pick 8

Freo-
Out: cerra
In: Mitch McGovern, pick 26

Adel-
Out: b crouch, m McGovern, pick 8
In: pick 1, 23, Cunningham e

 

[Heisenberg_]

North:

Gaff and Sloane via free agency.

Shai Bolton for a third rounder.

DeGoey for a first rounder and Sam Durdin.

T.Thomas for a second rounder.

Mountford for west coast's second rounder.

Dumont for port's second rounder.

In what fantasy land do you think we’d hand over Bolton to you for a third rounder?

 

[M Malice]

Do you think any clubs would consider the following? If so who do you think wins?

Carlton-
Out: pick 1, 23, 26 (based of current positions), Cunningham
In: cerra, b crouch, pick 8

Freo-
Out: cerra
In: Mitch McGovern, pick 26

Adel-
Out: b crouch, m McGovern, pick 8
In: pick 1, 23, Cunningham e

The Crows get shafted in that deal IMO, Carlton the winners, no surprise though.

 

[Wally Walpamur]

Do you think any clubs would consider the following? If so who do you think wins?

Carlton-
Out: pick 1, 23, 26 (based of current positions), Cunningham
In: cerra, b crouch, pick 8

Freo-
Out: cerra
In: Mitch McGovern, pick 26

Adel-
Out: b crouch, m McGovern, pick 8
In: pick 1, 23, Cunningham e

Carlton winners, Adelaide and Freo get the equivalent of a swift kick to the nuts.

 

[Mego Red]

Do you think any clubs would consider the following? If so who do you think wins?

Carlton-
Out: pick 1, 23, 26 (based of current positions), Cunningham
In: cerra, b crouch, pick 8

Freo-
Out: cerra
In: Mitch McGovern, pick 26

Adel-
Out: b crouch, m McGovern, pick 8
In: pick 1, 23, Cunningham e

No from Adelaide. Take Crouch and Cunningham out of the deal and the Crows might say yes.

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk