Post BF Upgrade Feedback - Click Here

Remove this Banner Ad

2019 Draft thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter dlanod
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

šŸ„° Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

briztoon said:
I know he is.

Quite a few of us campaigning for the Lions to draft Tom Berry for two years.

Now weā€™ll start on Sam.

Weā€™re all for uniting talented brothers and best friends here at the Lions. Weā€™re a family club after all.
Click to expand...
Do you know much about him Briz? Is he similar to Alex, in the same position, is his kick as good as his bros?
 
a mayes ing said:
Do you know much about him Briz? Is he similar to Alex, in the same position, is his kick as good as his bros?
Click to expand...
Sweet FA. Just came across his name when reading a preview for the Geelong Falcons.

The preview mentioned he was one of a couple of their talented underagers who would be starting the season injured.
 
briztoon said:
I know he is.

Quite a few of us campaigning for the Lions to draft Tom Berry for two years.

Now weā€™ll start on Sam.

Weā€™re all for uniting talented brothers and best friends here at the Lions. Weā€™re a family club after all.
Click to expand...

Fair enough it was just a friendly FYI , maybe I mistinterpreted your thread title.:thumbsu:

While Im here is it OK to ask ..what the story with Lewy Taylor ..cant get a game? Injured?
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Turbocat said:
Fair enough it was just a friendly FYI , maybe I mistinterpreted your thread title.:thumbsu:

While Im here is it OK to ask ..what the story with Lewy Taylor ..cant get a game? Injured?
Click to expand...
Players are infront of him. He has too many deficiencies at the moment, he is very small and he can't tackle. He is probably up against McCarthy and McCarthy is very much infront of him
 
a mayes ing said:
Players are infront of him. He has too many deficiencies at the moment, he is very small and he can't tackle. He is probably up against McCarthy and McCarthy is very much infront of him
Click to expand...

We've clearly gone for more defensively minded people to have a role on the wing too (e.g. Robbo, Basti) which is the other place he has had a bit of playing time previously.
 
Turbocat said:
Fair enough it was just a friendly FYI , maybe I mistinterpreted your thread title.:thumbsu:

While Im here is it OK to ask ..what the story with Lewy Taylor ..cant get a game? Injured?
Click to expand...

Pretty much what a mayes ing has said. Under Fagan now, if you want to get a game, you need to play both ways and put in as much defensive pressure as you offer in offensive options.


a mayes ing said:
Players are infront of him. He has too many deficiencies at the moment, he is very small and he can't tackle. He is probably up against McCarthy and McCarthy is very much infront of him
Click to expand...
 
a mayes ing said:
Players are infront of him. He has too many deficiencies at the moment, he is very small and he can't tackle. He is probably up against McCarthy and McCarthy is very much infront of him
Click to expand...
Im so glad you said "at the moment". I have no doubt he can rectify these deficiencies and fight his way back into this team. Still young enough to do so and when he does develop that all round game in attack as well as defence he will be a nightmare for opposition. I think him, cutler, n robbo and possibly bundy as well have been given their areas of improvement to work on and their challenge now is to do so. Basti did it, matho did it, they can too. We will have terrific depth when they do. The difference this year is that there is now competition for positions all over the park. Those named are deffinately in our best 30, and will be important over the course of the year.
 
QLD Lion 2019 said:
And Jack Payne the year before. Not sure why we keep taking players with a history of long term injuries.
Click to expand...
We have a pretty good history of getting them right.

We did it at the trade table last year as well, I know it's very early but Lincoln McCarthy looks like he going to be fantastic for us. If we can get Marcus Adams right he'll be a great addition also.
 
jason pm said:
We have a pretty good history of getting them right.

We did it at the trade table last year as well, I know it's very early but Lincoln McCarthy looks like he going to be fantastic for us. If we can get Marcus Adams right he'll be a great addition also.
Click to expand...

Im talking about drafting kids with injuries not trading players in from other clubs. Hopefully they all end up being 10 year players.
 
QLD Lion 2019 said:
Im talking about drafting kids with injuries not trading players in from other clubs. Hopefully they all end up being 10 year players.
Click to expand...
Yer I knew that, my 1st sentence was in response to your point and the rest was pointing out that this strategy is not just restricted to the draft.
 
QLD Lion 2019 said:
Im talking about drafting kids with injuries not trading players in from other clubs. Hopefully they all end up being 10 year players.
Click to expand...
Berryx2, Witherden, Answerth, Joyce, even Skinner.

Our recruiters have a history of drafting kids who have slid in the draft due to injuries in their draft year.

Itā€™s just not kids from our academy.

Even Mathieson slipped in his draft, but that was due to a terrible beep test at the draft combine, where he ran a 13 something beep test.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

If we ruled out any draftees who have been injured it would have a big impact on the players available.
 
briztoon said:
Berryx2, Witherden, Answerth, Joyce, even Skinner.

Our recruiters have a history of drafting kids who have slid in the draft due to injuries in their draft year.

Itā€™s just not kids from our academy.

Even Mathieson slipped in his draft, but that was due to a terrible beep test at the draft combine, where he ran a 13 something beep test.
Click to expand...
Robertson and Cutler as well iirc
 
We tend to target draftees who have missed a chunk of time via injury and have thus fallen down the draft order. We are typically pretty hot on these players in their underage year and are happy to take a punt with a lower pick. Many teams, not just us find good value drafting this way. That isnt to say that is all we do.. but i think it maximises the later pick risk/reward payoff.
 
It seems an obvious tactic to me (and one which is starting to pay off), have faith in your system to get these kids injuries right along with their regular development as players and you get higher tier talent for cheaper.

Say you have pick 45, do you take a top 20 player who has slid due to an injury in their draft year, or a player rated at that level who probably has a lower ceiling?
 

šŸ„° Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

jason pm said:
Great stuff from The Egg Beater.

What sort of player is he briz?
Click to expand...
Winger who can win his own ball. Offers good run on the outside, without that top line speed.

Something else from the game versus the Suns Academy, was that Wischnat was played in the middle as a contested mid. Possibly trying to develop him in to that hybrid big bodied mid slash mid sized forward.


I'm not sure if Wischnat makes the Allies squad for the U18 Nationals. He wasn't picked in the initial Allies Academy. It's possible that was a deliberate strategy to give him a kick up the backside to work harder (pure speculation on my behalf).

There are three highly rated contested mids in the various Allies academies and teams. Tom Green from GWS, O'Neill from Tas, both potential top 10, and Syd underage mid Gulden who might be better than both Green and O'Neill.

Add in the smaller Gold Coast mids, and there probably isn't a spot in the Allies midfield for Wischnat.
 
briztoon said:
Winger who can win his own ball. Offers good run on the outside, without that top line speed.

Something else from the game versus the Suns Academy, was that Wischnat was played in the middle as a contested mid. Possibly trying to develop him in to that hybrid big bodied mid slash mid sized forward.


I'm not sure if Wischnat makes the Allies squad for the U18 Nationals. He wasn't picked in the initial Allies Academy. It's possible that was a deliberate strategy to give him a kick up the backside to work harder (pure speculation on my behalf).

There are three highly rated contested mids in the various Allies academies and teams. Tom Green from GWS, O'Neill from Tas, both potential top 10, and Syd underage mid Gulden who might be better than both Green and O'Neill.

Add in the smaller Gold Coast mids, and there probably isn't a spot in the Allies midfield for Wischnat.
Click to expand...


Still waiting for that gun academy mid. Gun talls so far and Tozer to come but not that out and out gun mid like Heeney or Mills
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

briztoon
List Mgmt. Back2Back Rorts Baby (aka 2026 draft thread)
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
150
Views
10K
Miller1971
M
Mr Ripper
2026 Pre-Season Thread
17 18 19 20 21
Replies
521
Views
42K
briztoon
briztoon
ZoBlitz
  • Poll Poll
Certified Legendary Thread Lions go B2B : Grand Final, 2025 - Geelong vs. Brisbane Lions
39 40 41 42 43
Replies
1K
Views
58K
Maboo
Maboo

Remove this Banner Ad

šŸ„° Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom