Remove this Banner Ad

Unofficial Preview 2020 Draft Discussion

  • Thread starter Thread starter HeHateMe
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
tommyk72 said:
I wonder if Adelaide will get pressure from board/sponsors to not bid on JUH. Seems fine for the Kid who is selected second (even adds a "something to prove element") but the board and sponsors may want the media coverage.
Click to expand...

Good question. Other departments don't usually expect to exert influence on selections. Probably won't here either, as if Adel rate him #1 then you have to call his name, as bulldogs might not match.
 
I tend to not want Thilthorpe because:

Recent flag winners tend to get their ruck/forward hybrids cheaply in the draft, or ready-made via trade: McEvoy, Cox, Hale, Otttens, Hawkins, T Lynch, even when Gardiner went to St Kilda. I can't think of a recent flag winner who used a high draft pick on a young 18 year old sky scrapper and it panned out on GF day.

And, tall athletic hybrids (that are expensive to obtain) have also proven prone to injury: Danniher, NicNat, Kruzer,

And I wouldn't trade pick 5 to St Kilda for Marshall (who is a proven performer with a big future). Thilthorpe is maybe as good, maybe a dud.
 
Stratton24 said:
Think it was just he really didn't want to move away which is kinda draft tampering but it didn't matter in the end as Gold Coast and Port didn't want him anyway with Rankine, King and Rozee available
Click to expand...

Don't think a Dr would sign a medical cert if it was just because he didn't want to move. Even lazy/poor GPs would not want their name on a document that is so prominent.
 
Luv_our_club said:
I tend to not want Thilthorpe because:

Recent flag winners tend to get their ruck/forward hybrids cheaply in the draft, or ready-made via trade: McEvoy, Cox, Hale, Otttens, Hawkins, T Lynch, even when Gardiner went to St Kilda. I can't think of a recent flag winner who used a high draft pick on a young 18 year old sky scrapper and it panned out on GF day.

And, tall athletic hybrids (that are expensive to obtain) have also proven prone to injury: Danniher, NicNat, Kruzer,

And I wouldn't trade pick 5 to St Kilda for Marshall (who is a proven performer with a big future). Thilthorpe is maybe as good, maybe a dud.
Click to expand...

I agree re ruck. His footage shows that he might be a legitimate forward so there's that angle. My knock on him would be that he fades in and out of quarters which might be his fitness. This can probably be fixed, at least as a forward.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Luv_our_club said:
Phillips does have some x-factor - some break away speed and goal sense. He could be closer to Selwood/S Mitchell than T Mitchell - someone able to find space on the outside because of his 2nd gear. We don't have that type of player currently.

I worry that Hollands will be something like Hunter Clark, I wish he had a little more exposed form as an inside mid. But he has been a star consistently in juniors and has performed in big games.

Archie Perkins could arguably be ranked highest if they played this year.


I reckon that whoever the Hawks pick will turn out the best. :)
Click to expand...
Hunter Clark was pretty good this year to be fair.
 
Luv_our_club said:
I tend to not want Thilthorpe because:

Recent flag winners tend to get their ruck/forward hybrids cheaply in the draft, or ready-made via trade: McEvoy, Cox, Hale, Otttens, Hawkins, T Lynch, even when Gardiner went to St Kilda. I can't think of a recent flag winner who used a high draft pick on a young 18 year old sky scrapper and it panned out on GF day.

And, tall athletic hybrids (that are expensive to obtain) have also proven prone to injury: Danniher, NicNat, Kruzer,

And I wouldn't trade pick 5 to St Kilda for Marshall (who is a proven performer with a big future). Thilthorpe is maybe as good, maybe a dud.
Click to expand...
Yeah we haven’t seen proper footage of thilthorpe as a fwd, he has great attributes but can he be a dominant key fwd in the AFL or is he going to be a David hale type of player who is used as a ruck with stints up fwd for a goal and contested marks every now and then, which isn’t the output you want from a top 5 pick. Probably won’t be at our pick anyway but he is a talent for sure.
 
Rocket72 said:
Don't think a Dr would sign a medical cert if it was just because he didn't want to move. Even lazy/poor GPs would not want their name on a document that is so prominent.
Click to expand...
Mental Health. GP’s will sign anything. It wasn’t binding any club could have drafted him.
 
HAWKSBESTEVA said:
Hunter Clark was pretty good this year to be fair.
Click to expand...
But not great. We need great not good
 
Stratton24 said:
But not great. We need great not good
Click to expand...
Last year he was great , this year he was good. I think he doesn’t really have any similarities to Holland’s Anyway. Holland’s is more skilled, a better goal kicker , better overhead mark.
 
Stratton24 said:
Mental Health. GP’s will sign anything. It wasn’t binding any club could have drafted him.
Click to expand...

Maybe some, but they'd be silly to. I wouldn't without referring to a mental health professional or objective evidence, at the very least a high DASS.
 
theiaofseed said:
GWS would be an ideal target no way they go to the draft with 10,13,15,20 and 26. It's a tough year do you use a high draft pick to get best chance of the cream or take a shotgun and get bolters. What keeps running in my mind is Hugh Goddard a few years back was touted as the number 1 pick in his underage year ended up going pick 19ish* a year later.

Trading pick 4 and landing Reid, Macrae and Bruhn might not be a bad option.
Click to expand...
Reading the papers, they think we will go Perkins/Phillips and take some project talls with our later picks.
 
HAWKSBESTEVA said:
Hunter Clark was pretty good this year to be fair.
Click to expand...

HC was good, and he showed improvement, and next year he could be a great player. But Hunter Clark will need to have more influence inside the packs, which is no small thing, and which is my concern for Hollands.

Hollands does not have blistering pace on the outside, and he does not have enough demonstrations of his inside abilities. Along with his knee.

I guess it depends whether you want to take a risk for a player with the most upside, or go with a safe bet. For mine, Hollands is not the safest bet of all the gun smalls.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Luv_our_club said:
HC was good, and he showed improvement, and next year he could be a great player. But Hunter Clark will need to have more influence inside the packs, which is no small thing, and which is my concern for Hollands.

Hollands does not have blistering pace on the outside, and he does not have enough demonstrations of his inside abilities. Along with his knee.

I guess it depends whether you want to take a risk for a player with the most upside, or go with a safe bet. For mine, Hollands is not the safest bet of all the gun smalls.
Click to expand...
Holland’s makes up for it with his classiness through packs, High footy IQ, ability to kick goals from 55m out on his opposite side. Yeah agreed on the last part, IMO when you have a high pick you want a home run so you should take the most talented player which is Holland’s at our pick if he is there.
 
HAWKSBESTEVA said:
Holland’s makes up for it with his classiness through packs, High footy IQ, ability to kick goals from 55m out on his opposite side. Yeah agreed on the last part, IMO when you have a high pick you want a home run so you should take the most talented player which is Holland’s at our pick if he is there.
Click to expand...

I think I may still be scared by Mitch Thorpe v Selwood.

I fear Hollands being an overpriced sports car when I should be thinking/hoping he is a Rolls Royce like Hodge.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Chioli said:
Surely the only way we trade pick 4 is if we rate Perkins and Hollands on the same level and we are confident that the suns are taking Phillips. And then would take bombers offering 6+8 for 4. Otherwise I think we will take Hollands at 4 and be ecstatic.
Click to expand...
He probably thinks Brunh higher than Perkins and Hollands and does not expect Brunh to be picked up until at least first pick of GWS. Everyone is entitled to their opinion.

As had been said, it is that type of year, where a kid at pick 60 might turn out better than pick 10. It is not as if we have not had that in the past, look at picks we took B Hill, Stratton, Puopolo, Siciliy.

Being positive, if HFC do not trade with GWS, then perhaps being alittle in dream land, you hope that we have been monitoring some kids where for some magical reason others have not and pick them up with our late picks.

We do have a number of holes in our list, so the more quality kids coming through next 3+ years, the better. It is not like we only need a FB or small forward. Hence, attractiveness with getting more look in top 30 players. Having said that who ends up being a star could be different to top 30 players we and media know via phantom draft the last few months.
 


"They're [the groins are] really good. I'm really happy with where they're at. I'm back into some decent running in the gym," Thilthorpe said this week.

"I think I'm on track to start session one of pre-season."

"I'd love to go to the Crows at pick one, that'd be awesome, but there's pros and cons for everything. Going interstate would be really fun and I'd love the new environment and learning stuff for myself away from home.

[I look up to] "Tom Lynch from Richmond. Just the way he crashes packs, and his workrate. And then Brodie Grundy in the ruck, the modern ruckman that I try to emulate," he said.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

Strapping Young Lad
    • Like
Injury 2026 Injury Discussion
Replies
14
Views
2K
ppphawk
ppphawk
Rowie6
    • Like
List Mgmt. List management discussion 2026
6 7 8 9 10
Replies
225
Views
22K
BigTonkaTroy
BigTonkaTroy
Dixie Flatline
    • Like
    • Love
Memberships Hawthorn membership 2026 discussion thread
2 3 4
Replies
96
Views
8K
peetoo
peetoo
Pinoy Hawk
    • Like
    • Love
Training 2026 Off-Season & Preseason reports and discussion
85 86 87 88 89
Replies
2K
Views
247K
Randy Campbell
Randy Campbell
eldorado
    • Haha
    • Like
    • Wow
Unofficial Preview 2026 Hawk's Hypothetical Trade Discussion
927 928 929 930 931
Replies
23K
Views
1M
Big Hotdog
Big Hotdog
TylerDurden
    • Like
    • Wow
Video Highlights “Full Sweat” Channel 7 Doco discussion
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
140
Views
9K
matey
M
Titch3Votes0MooreAA
    • Love
    • Like
  • Locked
Player Watch 2025 AFL Draft Thread (Welcome to our new Central Districts overlords!)
143 144 145 146 147
Replies
4K
Views
241K
Strapping Young Lad
Strapping Young Lad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom