Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Riley Beveridge saying we'll start negotiations with Himmelberg, Frampton and Gollant around the bye week.
Why are we bothering with Himmelburg and Frampton honestly.Riley Beveridge saying we'll start negotiations with Himmelberg, Frampton and Gollant around the bye week.
EFARiley Beveridge saying we'll start negotiations with Himmelberg, Frampton and Gollant around the bye bye week.
Why are we bothering with Himmelburg and Frampton honestly.
They're not ever going to be premiership players we need to do better.
If we haven't already started negotiations with Gollant, we're morons and don't deserve to keep him.Riley Beveridge saying we'll start negotiations with Himmelberg, Frampton and Gollant around the bye week.
You don't dump 'em until you know for sure what else you'll be replacing them with. Given our stocks it was always unlikely we got rid of both, Frampton was probably the most likely to keep cause he can fill in 3 positions.Why are we bothering with Himmelburg and Frampton honestly.
They're not ever going to be premiership players we need to do better.
I mean, I can also fill all 3 positions. I won't be any good at AFL level but that really has not stopped Frampton. No good up forward at AFL level. No good as a ruck at AFL level and badly found out that he can't defend 1 v 1 at AFL level.You don't dump 'em until you know for sure what else you'll be replacing them with. Given our stocks it was always unlikely we got rid of both, Frampton was probably the most likely to keep cause he can fill in 3 positions.
I have never seen him play, but a 25yo small forward...surely not! Mutineer?
Brett Turner
Club: Glenelg, SANFL
Age: 25yrs
Height: 185cms
Weight: 88kgs
“Brett Turner, a 25-year-old forward, he had 38 (disposals) and kicked four (goals) against Adelaide’s SANFL side earlier this year, so the Crows have been linked a little bit to him now, they might take him in the mid-season pool.”
Draft guru names four players who are attracting interest for the Mid-Season Rookie Draft
The 2022 mid-season rookie draft is less than two weeks away.www.sen.com.au
Frampton can play 3 positions... but he plays all 3 of them badly.You don't dump 'em until you know for sure what else you'll be replacing them with. Given our stocks it was always unlikely we got rid of both, Frampton was probably the most likely to keep cause he can fill in 3 positions.
The idea though is you're not willingly starting either of them. They're absolutely break glass scenarios. Frampton ain't getting anything at the trade table unlike Himmelberg might as well.Frampton can play 3 positions... but he plays all 3 of them badly.
Himmelberg can only play 2 positions, but at least he's shown that on a good day he can play well as a forward. He can't do it consistently, but he has shown the ability to do it, which is something that Frampton has never done.
That's simply not true. We have Tex - then you can throw a blanket over Thilthorpe, Himmelberg, Fog & Gollant. Based on his performances so far this year, Himmelberg is currently our #2 KPF - definitely not a "break glass" option at all. He's not consistent, but he's delivered more and more consistently this year than any other forward not named Tex Walker.The idea though is you're not willingly starting either of them. They're absolutely break glass scenarios. Frampton ain't getting anything at the trade table unlike Himmelberg might as well.
Neither of them are consistent, best 22 players, so there's no need to keep both. Turf one for the maximum return and develop someone else with the other list spot.
Riley Beveridge saying "we'll start negotiations with Himmelberg, Frampton and Gollant around the bye week."Why are we bothering with Himmelburg and Frampton honestly.
They're not ever going to be premiership players we need to do better.
That's the whole point. We don't have better options, so we should go find one instead of keeping the pile we have one we have.You could argue that he should be a "break glass" player if we had better KPF options, but that's nothing more than wishful thinking. Those better KPF options don't exist. The reality is that we don't have good KPF options at present, and he's clearly more than a "break glass" player. He's the least worst of some bad options, but he's still the least worst option we have.
Frampton, on the other hand...
He just couldn't force he way into the strong Brisbane midfield, was racking them up in the NEAFL. He was a highly rated U18 drafted at pick 24 as an academy player, don't think we've done much other than played him in the seniors.Certainly we seem to have unlocked the full potential of Keyes better than Brisbane had
An attitude adjustment maybe? Like Stengle he looks much slimmer than when he was here.
He's still the best one in the pile, until you can actually recruit that better option.That's the whole point. We don't have better options, so we should go find one instead of keeping the pile we have one we have.
He's an inconsistent player in a pile of inconsistent players and is now in his 5th year. There's nothing to be gained from keeping him.
Probably best to keep him as ‘break glass’ for next year, probably by delisting him and re-drafting him onto the rookie list, but I think we all hope Thilthorpe emerges as the clear leader of the pack over the next 18 monthsHe's still the best one in the pile, until you can actually recruit that better option.
Agreed. Getting rid of both Billy & Berg is asking for trouble, as it would rip a huge hole in our list. Getting rid of Billy is a complete no-brainer, which means retaining Berg for at least another year.Probably best to keep him as ‘break glass’ for next year, probably by delisting him and re-drafting him onto the rookie list, but I think we all hope Thilthorpe emerges as the clear leader of the pack over the next 18 months
Riley Beveridge saying we'll start negotiations with Himmelberg, Frampton and Gollant around the bye week.
We should trade Berg and recontact Gollant imo. Frammers probably gets another year but I'm hoping we trade in a decent KPD EOY.Riley Beveridge saying we'll start negotiations with Himmelberg, Frampton and Gollant around the bye week.
Before trading in a KPD I’d like to see what Borlase / McAsey / Worrell can do in an AFL side .We should trade Berg and recontact Gollant imo. Frammers probably gets another year but I'm hoping we trade in a decent KPD EOY.
No chance that happens. Our side is stacked!Before trading in a KPD I’d like to see what Borlase / McAsey / Worrell can do in an AFL side .
I would even like to see Himmelberg played at CHB, what have we got to loseBefore trading in a KPD I’d like to see what Borlase / McAsey / Worrell can do in an AFL side .