List Mgmt. 2022 List Management and trading thread

[Scorpus]

I saw this format on the West Coast board and thought it might help understand our current list position

 

[ams4crows]

We could have taken Carmichael and Turner and who ever was better we could have kept on the list but no we had to stick with the good bloke we decided on two months ago

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

We are in desperate need of a developing ruckman, we could get one in ND but if it’s anyone over 18 we’ve missed an east opportunity

 

[Trigger13]

Blame the coaching staff. Grabbing a mature age midfielder reeks of them desperately trying to find ways to get marginally better now. The long term doesn’t exist in their eyes. Cooked

 

[Bearded Clam]

Hamish on Turner: “As a player he offers a point of difference for our midfield in he has good speed and lateral movement and can go left and right foot out of stoppage." Whos fault is that Hamish?

Hamish is so far up his own arse that he wouldnt even realise the unbeleivble irony in that comment..

He has beleived the bullshit many spoke about him being this draft guru a few years back and now thinks he is unquestionable..

 

[aabp1978]

185 is medium/small size for a mid these days.. they are getting up around the 190-195 mark now days..

But we are still stuck in 2017… still thinking we need a mosquito fleet because thats what beat us in the GF..

Which has clearly completely ducked with the clubs hea

Average height for a midfielder is ~184 cm.

There are a handful of tall midfielders, but they are the exception, not the rule.

Just looked - Oliver is 187cm...Wines 187cm...Sam Walsh 184cm...Jack Steele 187cm, so at 185cm he is hardly a midget. Anyway, like I said I know nothing about him as I never watch SANFL....hope he isnt awful..thought though we should have picked up Voss with the second pick..did actually watch the state game and thought he was great and a ready made replacement for Brown...

 

[Bearded Clam]

We have enough listed players that we still need to see play. Melting over a mid season draft is quite funny.

We wont see many more of those young listed players you speak of play in the midfield.. you watch the 25 year old plodder take their midfield minutes!.

 

[pjcrows]

He'll probably come in and be our best mid.

 

[baldandbroke]

Perfect opportunity to get 2 of the best available young talent in given we are in rebuild mode... & this.

I think everyone that is doing a bit of an El Guapo.

Could it be that once again you are angry at something else …

 

[DJ75]

It baffles me.

KPD
Butts - a lock
Murray - Questionable at best
Frampton - not the answer
Borlase - untried and undersized
Worrell - Undersized, better suited to mid-sized

KPF
Walker - nearly finished
Thilthorpe - Promising, but questionable as a key forward
Fog - Undersized. Questionable at best
Himmelberg - Nope.
Gollant - a 3rd tall, not a key position

Ruck
ROB - Useful when at 100%. Awful once he is below that.
Strachan - Good skilled, but already at the age he should be ready and is still easily pushed away.
Thilthorpe - Probably his best position. Not ready though.
That's it. There is nothing else.

I can't believe that not one of the players available have enough upsize to at least give a go for 18 months. At least 3-4 of those listed are clearly not up to it and need to be cut.

 

[George CantStandYa]

He'll probably come in and be our best mid.

Whose spot is he taking?

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

I think everyone that is doing a bit of an El Guapo.

Could it be that once again you are angry at something else …

Did you miss us passing on our 2nd pick?

We don't have a cap issue & lack talent on our list.

Yet, you think this ok... well i don't as it's a missed opportunity!

 

[Mutineer]

2021 SANFL Post Season Top 50 - 11-30 - SANFL

sanfl.com.au

19 - Brett Turner (Glenelg)​

Recruited from West Adelaide, Turner rewarded his new team with an exceptional campaign as a big-bodied midfielder. Runner-up in Glenelg’s best-and-fairest, Turner also earned a spot in The Advertiser SANFL Team of the Year while ranking first in the competition for inside 50s, fourth for clearances, seventh in disposals and third in tackles.

 

[Bearded Clam]

Whose spot is he taking?

Definitely not Keays, laird or crouch’s spot..

 

[latinoheat]

Blame the coaching staff. Grabbing a mature age midfielder reeks of them desperately trying to find ways to get marginally better now. The long term doesn’t exist in their eyes. Cooked

Think the decision rests with the recruiting department, not coach

 

[screech]

Jesus. He’s not even in the top 2 mids at Glenelg.

Yeah but he played well against us so we cannot pass him up

Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk

 

[Trigger13]

Think the decision rests with the recruiting department, not coach

The coaches have a massive say in the mid-season draft.

 

[pjcrows]

Whose spot is he taking?

I don't know. My point was basically - our midfield is horrific, there's every chance he actually gets a spot and holds it. More an observation of our midfield than an approval of his selection - I've never seen him play.

 

[safeandsound]

Whatever happens, just don’t select Turner at 4 and pass at 19

Well played Sir .

 

[latinoheat]

It baffles me.

KPD
Butts - a lock
Murray - Questionable at best
Frampton - not the answer
Borlase - untried and undersized
Worrell - Undersized, better suited to mid-sized

KPF
Walker - nearly finished
Thilthorpe - Promising, but questionable as a key forward
Fog - Undersized. Questionable at best
Himmelberg - Nope.
Gollant - a 3rd tall, not a key position

Ruck
ROB - Useful when at 100%. Awful once he is below that.
Strachan - Good skilled, but already at the age he should be ready and is still easily pushed away.
Thilthorpe - Probably his best position. Not ready though.
That's it. There is nothing else.

I can't believe that not one of the players available have enough upsize to at least give a go for 18 months. At least 3-4 of those listed are clearly not up to it and need to be cut.

This 100%. Should have gone a ruckman

 

[rocket18]

Would be totally ridiculous to pick a midfielder tomorrow, we already have a conga line of young midfielders that can't get any meaningful midfield minutes. Throwing another joker into the mix for the last 11 games is pointless. Grab the best KPD available and just bloody play him in the senior team, we've seen what happens when we have no Butts - would also free Doedee up a bit not having to defend someone 10cm taller than him every game.

Having said that I expect the AFC to select a slow mid that will play 2 games in the forward pocket before the season ends and we pass on our other selection.

We should have a poll on what people expect us to do - not what we should be doing.

Don't ask me for Saturdays lotto numbers - they're hard to predict.

Unfortunately predicting the next AFC duck up is like shelling peas.

 

[DJ75]

2021 SANFL Post Season Top 50 - 11-30 - SANFL

sanfl.com.au

19 - Brett Turner (Glenelg)​

Recruited from West Adelaide, Turner rewarded his new team with an exceptional campaign as a big-bodied midfielder. Runner-up in Glenelg’s best-and-fairest, Turner also earned a spot in The Advertiser SANFL Team of the Year while ranking first in the competition for inside 50s, fourth for clearances, seventh in disposals and third in tackles.

I can't believe we posted those highlights. Check out the clearance against us at the 50s mark brilliant work from our mids....

 

[rocket18]

It baffles me.

KPD
Butts - a lock
Murray - Questionable at best
Frampton - not the answer
Borlase - untried and undersized
Worrell - Undersized, better suited to mid-sized

KPF
Walker - nearly finished
Thilthorpe - Promising, but questionable as a key forward
Fog - Undersized. Questionable at best
Himmelberg - Nope.
Gollant - a 3rd tall, not a key position

Ruck
ROB - Useful when at 100%. Awful once he is below that.
Strachan - Good skilled, but already at the age he should be ready and is still easily pushed away.
Thilthorpe - Probably his best position. Not ready though.
That's it. There is nothing else.

I can't believe that not one of the players available have enough upsize to at least give a go for 18 months. At least 3-4 of those listed are clearly not up to it and need to be cut.

We still have so many idiots at our club who think they are a lot smarter then they really are.

 

[DJ75]

This 100%. Should have gone a ruckman

Having developing rucks is also great currency. Clubs are very willing to trade for a 24-28 year old ruck. Port have done this very well over the years.

 

[Eagleboy2011]

2021 SANFL Post Season Top 50 - 11-30 - SANFL

sanfl.com.au

19 - Brett Turner (Glenelg)​

Recruited from West Adelaide, Turner rewarded his new team with an exceptional campaign as a big-bodied midfielder. Runner-up in Glenelg’s best-and-fairest, Turner also earned a spot in The Advertiser SANFL Team of the Year while ranking first in the competition for inside 50s, fourth for clearances, seventh in disposals and third in tackles.

The SANFL website has him out for another 2-3 weeks injured. Will he actually play for us.

 

[GreyCrow]

' guys guys bigfootys gonna melt when we take Turner'

' they can piss off theyre only customers - and anyway half the bastards dont go to any games and post from home''

'but still Roo they drive the commentary in football circles - look thats where the muffin crowd came from'

'haha bloody hell those muffins paid for themselves ''

'but what can we do to shift the focus'

''ehh i know tell Nicksy Parnells playing this week'

''omg the lad looks like a 14 year old''

hehe I had a full beard at 14 - anyway play him - that'll make em talk about Paddy'