- Jun 9, 2008
- 13,505
- 15,339
- AFL Club
- Carlton
But surely you must understand that draft picks are better than actual players.
Umm what?

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

BigFooty AFLW Notice Img
AFLW 2025 - AFLW Trade and Draft - All the player moves
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
But surely you must understand that draft picks are better than actual players.

Our winning margin has dropped by 17% last 3 weeks! Work on it Voss!!In the last month
59 point win
60 point win
53 point win
50 point win![]()
Mimicking those that want to trade out good players to get draft picks.Umm what?![]()
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
In our hands now…I know I know the whole IF thing doesn’t count but IF we scored 1 more point in round 1 we’d be 6th right now with a healthy percentage and west coast next week. Crazy. Hopefully haven’t left it to late
Wayne Hughes?9
Mimicking those that want to trade out good players to get draft picks.
Even read that someone suggesting that we trade tdk for Geelongs first (might even be as low as 20 after academy srlections) and give them a future 2nd as part of the deal. I mean come on.

Gawn is definitely the benchmark ruckman in the league. Rucks need to be valued by a combination ofI thought TDK did some awesome things yesterday. He always has a great highlights package and yesterday it was his ferocious tackling that is etched in my memory.
However, the numbers say that statiscitcally he broke even with Lycett. TDK had a couple more touches, clearances & tackles, but he's finished with a lower hitout to advantage %, and Port (just) won clearances. Unless you are Max Gawn having 30 touches a game with huge influence around the ground, the primary measure of success for a tap ruckman is to impact clearance. We didn't get that impact from TDK yesterday.
I know TDK's still a work in progress.. but at this point in his career I would expect him to torch Lycett who has struggled to keep his spot at Port. And if that's not happening at clearance then he should be using his athleticism to punish a plodder like Lycett around the ground.
5 weeks ago I wanted him out of the club. "goneski' was my exact wording.
Since then he invested in the team ethos, no more half hearted , one arm tackles. No more 'couldn't give a fig' attitude.
I sit corrected.
Before yesterday's results (and I had us beating Port), I had us missing the 8 by 2 points, presuming losses against the Pies and the Dees.Has anybody actually studied the draw? Anyone for a ladder prediction?![]()
And they sell Carlton Draught in cans at Marvel!!Loved the game, and had the rare chance to be there.
Very even performance and loved the intensity, but I'm now clear why Dow hasn't been playing seniors. Too slow in decision making and execution and didn't handle pressure well enough. Maybe I'm being unfair, but while he did a couple of good things, some of the errors were concerning.
I think he showed exactly why the MC have treated him the way they have.Dow was borderline electric in those congested contests… bearing in mind he’s barely played AFL footy recently. Only highlighted how ridiculous it is that we haven’t given him more game time imo.
RibbitWe’ve just beaten the side that has won 12 in a row, the second best side in the comp by 50 points.
Let that sink in peeps!!!
Geelong Sydney & Richmond are the ones we need to worry about percentage along with us we’ve all drawn games…We have 6-7 more percentage than * and Bulldogs, they play each other next week. We play West Coast. Should pass one of them into the 8 next week, on both more points and with better percentage.
Reckon Paddy is playing nervously, quite different to his demeanour in the 2s.It's better but yeah not great. Tbf, he seems to take the longer option more than hit up the short one.
In the end it won't matter, he won't be here next year. I do enjoy him getting a gig though, I just want him to do well after showing great character the last 12-24 months
Pretty sure he's got the sub role sown up at present which is a credit to him.
Sent from my CPH2005 using BigFooty.com mobile app
Ribbit
Reckon Paddy is playing nervously, quite different to his demeanour in the 2s.
He was changing his mind every possession he had last night, rather than playing off instinct.
A lot of pressure on him I reckon, to some degree self imposed.
What’s a helicopter?same
![]()
Carlton’s audacious finals charge amid McKay injury fears
Carlton are on the rampage and making an audacious run for the finals after pricking Port Adelaide’s bubble - but they may have to make their charge without Harry McKay.www.theage.com.au