List Mgmt. 2023 Trade & List Management Thread III

[The Lone Latic]

If the Ginnivan rumour I've heard this arvo is even semi legit you're no way touching him with a 10 foot pole. Just stay away

 

[sruss]

Saints robbed and Braves make out like bandits I reckon. Unless there’s question marks on Coffield’s long term fitness?

 

[DuckYeah]

View attachment 1833437

Carltank definitely accruing points for the FOS twins.

 

[speedy]

View attachment 1833437

WB got coffield for next to nix. They keep getting kissed on the d!ck.

 

[DuckYeah]

If the Ginnivan rumour I've heard this arvo is even semi legit you're no way touching him with a 10 foot pole. Just stay away

What level bad? Oliver bad?

 

[rippersnipper]

Worst megatrade of all time that

 

[shinboner magic]

That’s a mega trade of diarrhoea

 

[LB2Snake]

If WC threaten to take McK at 1 whats our response?

Ah, not sure I follow……my point was we don’t wanna give up 2 and would rather trade pick 3 so we can take Harley and McK.
But I think we’d cope.

 

[Marstermind]

I went onto the Carlton board after the 2017 draft and made the point that this would be how SOS will be remembered. Good or bad.

Fortunately for us, it’s bad.

In his time at Carlton he just picked off blokes he'd got to the Giants who hadn't made it. Jaksch, Plowman, Marchbank, Setterfield, Pickett, Palmer to name a few.

Looks like his strategy at the Saints is to pick of failed early picks from his time at the Blues.

Kind of has the blinkers on.

 

[Marstermind]

That’s a mega trade of diarrhoea

Surely enough to clinch * as the winners of trade week though.

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

In his time at Carlton he just picked off blokes he'd got to the Giants who hadn't made it. Jaksch, Plowman, Marchbank, Setterfield, Pickett, Palmer to name a few.

Looks like his strategy at the Saints is to pick of failed early picks from his time at the Blues.

Kind of has the blinkers on.

Hubris out the yin yang.

 

[DocSholl]

If the Ginnivan rumour I've heard this arvo is even semi legit you're no way touching him with a 10 foot pole. Just stay away

Great, thanks for posting such a vague summary

 

[gustaaf]

View attachment 1833437

That's a lot of work to basically move two shitmen to another club for very little. The picks are also unlikely to make the world of difference. Perhaps the Bombers will do something with #35.

 

[Roo202]

Worst megatrade of all time that

 

[Rod Stroker]

View attachment 1833373
View attachment 1833374

The kicker is that Dow wanted to get drafted by us!

 

[LB2Snake]

If the Ginnivan rumour I've heard this arvo is even semi legit you're no way touching him with a 10 foot pole. Just stay away

Can’t you post a bit more info? Or maybe a PM?

 

[Marstermind]

Hubris out the yin yang.

 

[krakouers]

Reid it and weep: Eagles not set on Harley for No.1 pick

West Coast have refused to confirm they would take Harley Reid if they have the first selection in the draft, despite being seen as the best player in the draft pool.

thewest.com.au

"West Coast have refused to confirm they will take Harley Reid if they keep the first selection in the draft, despite him being touted as the best player in the pool for more than 12 months.

List boss Rohan O’Brien also said the Eagles are in no rush when it comes to deciding if they will retain the prized pick No.1 or split it for a bumper draft hand ahead of next month’s draft.

Reid is seen as the man every club would take with the first selection in this year’s draft, but O’Brien was keeping his cards close to his chest when asked if they had decided who they would pick.

“There’s a little bit more work to do there,” O’Brien said.

“We’re just waiting on some information around medicals and we’ll get together as a group and discuss all those things.

“We haven’t landed on an outright position just yet.”...

The trade period officially ends tomorrow, but clubs can trade picks only from Monday, October 23 through to Friday, November 10 as well as during the draft.

It gives West Coast plenty of time to decide what they will do with the No.1 pick, as clubs including North Melbourne try to pry it from their hands.

O’Brien said they had not fielded too many calls about a potential trade but expected that to ramp up in the coming weeks.

“To be fair I think clubs have got a number of other things on the go at the moment that they need to work through,” O’Brien told Trade Radio.

“That may change once the player exchange period finishes and we move more into selections.

“We’ve had a few calls but the phone hasn’t been ringing off the hook if I’m honest.”

O’Brien said they wouldn’t put a deadline on when they’d decide whether they’d retain the No.1 pick.

“Some clubs have indicated that they’d like to speak to us when the time is right and we’re happy to listen to anyone,” O’Brien said."

And given the comments are the really interesting thing beyond that:

 

[Hearts to hearts]

If the Ginnivan rumour I've heard this arvo is even semi legit you're no way touching him with a 10 foot pole. Just stay away

Great, thanks for posting such a vague summary

Can’t you post a bit more info? Or maybe a PM?

How about not. It’s gross and if there’s anything in it then apart from footballers there are civilian feelings to consider. We don’t have to salivate over this kind of rubbish.

 

[Rod Stroker]

Dow worth about a future 4th. Oof.

if we'd known a F4 would get it done, should we have made an offer? I reckon he'd offer more than a Mahony or Turner or other average blokes who are still on our list

 

[The Lone Latic]

What level bad? Oliver bad?

Oliver, possibly worse depending in your personal values

 

[LB2Snake]

Reid it and weep: Eagles not set on Harley for No.1 pick

West Coast have refused to confirm they would take Harley Reid if they have the first selection in the draft, despite being seen as the best player in the draft pool.

thewest.com.au

"West Coast have refused to confirm they will take Harley Reid if they keep the first selection in the draft, despite him being touted as the best player in the pool for more than 12 months.

List boss Rohan O’Brien also said the Eagles are in no rush when it comes to deciding if they will retain the prized pick No.1 or split it for a bumper draft hand ahead of next month’s draft.

Reid is seen as the man every club would take with the first selection in this year’s draft, but O’Brien was keeping his cards close to his chest when asked if they had decided who they would pick.

“There’s a little bit more work to do there,” O’Brien said.

“We’re just waiting on some information around medicals and we’ll get together as a group and discuss all those things.

“We haven’t landed on an outright position just yet.”...

The trade period officially ends tomorrow, but clubs can trade picks only from Monday, October 23 through to Friday, November 10 as well as during the draft.

It gives West Coast plenty of time to decide what they will do with the No.1 pick, as clubs including North Melbourne try to pry it from their hands.

O’Brien said they had not fielded too many calls about a potential trade but expected that to ramp up in the coming weeks.

“To be fair I think clubs have got a number of other things on the go at the moment that they need to work through,” O’Brien told Trade Radio.

“That may change once the player exchange period finishes and we move more into selections.

“We’ve had a few calls but the phone hasn’t been ringing off the hook if I’m honest.”

O’Brien said they wouldn’t put a deadline on when they’d decide whether they’d retain the No.1 pick.

“Some clubs have indicated that they’d like to speak to us when the time is right and we’re happy to listen to anyone,” O’Brien said."

And given the comments are the really interesting thing beyond that:

View attachment 1833468
View attachment 1833470
View attachment 1833471
View attachment 1833473

How flipping deluded are the WC supporters comments “picks 2 and 3 plus other pics”.
WE WILL NOT TRADE 2 AND 3……let alone other picks attached.
How stupid are they!!!!

 

[Shinboner1]

if we'd known a F4 would get it done, should we have made an offer? I reckon he'd offer more than a Mahony or Turner or other average blokes who are still on our list

Doubt he'd come.
Won't be getting a chance for consistent games at the Roos barring major injuries.
At least he'll compete for a spot at St kilda.

 

[The Lone Latic]

How about not. It’s gross and if there’s anything in it then apart from footballers there are civilian feelings to consider. We don’t have to salivate over this kind of rubbish.

I take it you may have heard similar given this reply. I mean if ppl are that desperate to know, there's a bit of digging to do on social media but I think it can be found if you try hard enough, and it may come out more in the coming days over time naturally

 

[krakouers]

If the Ginnivan rumour I've heard this arvo is even semi legit you're no way touching him with a 10 foot pole. Just stay away

Hey, Ancient Aliens has some quality material...