List Mgmt. 2023 Trade & List Management Thread

[King Corey]

Edit: will update if ppl happy for this to sticky

Ok starting the hit list of names mentioned in any rumour as linked to us for 2023 trade period.

• Mac Andrew
• Hunter Clark
• Zac Fisher
• Sam Flanders
• Mitch Georgiades
• Liam Henry
• Dougal Howard
• Lewis Melican
• Jack Silvagni
• Dylan Stephens
• Adam Tomlinson

 

[Hearts to hearts]

I still think this trade has merit.

Say we end up with pick 2 & 3. (McKay leaves). We promise GC that we won’t bid on Walter with 2.

Trade pick 3 & Future 3rd to GC for Flanders & 5.

Might not seem fair, but if GC get ahead of the Walter bid they essentially end up with an additional first rounder top 5 pick (for Flanders) that they would never have had.

They get Walter & McKercher/Duursma

We get:

Flanders
Pick 2: Reid/Curtin
Pick 5: Watson

I do have some faith after last year that North will be clear on who we want and will be ready to trade as long as we get those players, no matter what anyone else thinks.

 

[kool kangas]

Our boy Sam Flanders with another 36 touches

Fisher another 28

Dow another 24

Not our boy until he signs...........

 

[kool kangas]

not necessarily. If they don't want to be there, I don't want them there.

Maybe we're better off with someone like TT's character out of the joint.

l noticed yesterday before the start of the game when the players first formed a huddle prior to the game starting that TT was about 2-3 meters outside the group by himself with what looked like no intentions to join in until he did in the last few moments before the game started...It didnt look good..

 

[Themanbun]

Our boy Sam Flanders with another 36 touches

Fisher another 28

Dow another 24

Their prices going up by the hour

 

[big_e]

l noticed yesterday before the start of the game when the players first formed a huddle prior to the game starting that TT was about 2-3 meters outside the group by himself with what looked like no intentions to join in until he did in the last few moments before the game started...It didnt look good..

Just watched it on the replay.

Nothing in it, imo.

 

[New_Roo]

I feel like we’ll let go of about 14 including Magoo. That leaves us having to bring in ten.

Five or six from the draft including Sanders, a couple of rookie picks and another two or three from trade/DFA.

If the new regime are any good they should be able find enough from that to take us forward.

Personally reckon it will be the other way around 2-3 draft and 5-6 trade


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Shinboner1]

The problem with cutting up to 16 players in one hit is that you won't bring in 16 good players in one draft. Of course, we only get to replace 12 of them. We have to cut 4 without replacements due to the 2 long term injury top ups and the 2 additional listings we were granted as a concession last year. We may or may not keep that concession. But still, 12-14 selections in a draft is a lot when most of these selections would be passed over by every other club. We'd be taking on quite a few rookie list type players along with delisted free agents.

We won't get 12 but we may get 8 servicable players including some good long tern draftees. Then we delist in 2 years and go again with less players needing to go.
If we only delist enough to bring 8 on then we may only get 4-5 which isn't enough.
There's no loss when we already know the guys we're delisting are shit.

 

[andana]

Clarko needs to do this again but in one go

The best Hawthorn trades in the 21st century

The official AFL website of the Hawthorn Football Club

www.hawthornfc.com.au

 

[spurs]

Flanders, Dow, Fisher, Clark and Stephens are the players we are targeting or just on a wish list? I saw an article about Stephens who might come over but no-one else. I would assume Clark is a near certainty to come to us after last year which IMO is a really good get. When McKay goes, I think we should target Hamling, Jonas, and Marchbank.

 

[JGreezy]

Flanders, Dow, Fisher, Clark and Stephens are the players we are targeting or just on a wish list? I saw an article about Stephens who might come over but no-one else. I would assume Clark is a near certainty to come to us after last year which IMO is a really good get. When McKay goes, I think we should target Hamling, Jonas, and Marchbank.

In order of likelihood I would go:

Stephens
Clark
...
Fisher
...
...
...
Flanders
Dow

Note: not based on inside knowledge, just reading articles and bigfooty comments

 

[spurs]

In order of likelihood I would go:

Stephens
Clark
...
Fisher
...
...
...
Flanders
Dow

Note: not based on inside knowledge, just reading articles and bigfooty comments

So Flanders and Dow and to a lesser extend Fisher aren't coming to us IYO?

 

[JGreezy]

So Flanders and Dow and to a lesser extend Fisher aren't coming to us IYO?

Nah, maybe I structured this poorly, but I would say fairly confident of Stephens and Clark, moderate chance of Fisher and a chance at Flanders or Dow but not confident.

 

[jaspers_barber]

Said few months ago we should chase Duggan. Dangle something to WC before he leaves the sinking ship next year. Immediate upgrade defensively on ziebell or McDonald

 

[spurs]

Said few months ago we should chase Duggan. Dangle something to WC before he leaves the sinking ship next year. Immediate upgrade defensively on ziebell or McDonald

Great player but I doubt he’ll leave

 

[pupstar]

Nah, maybe I structured this poorly, but I would say fairly confident of Stephens and Clark, moderate chance of Fisher and a chance at Flanders or Dow but not confident.

Pretty accurate i reckon to mate.

 

[Kciza]

I don't know how he's gone at VFL level this year, but the Dogs seem to have a logjam of talls, should we be targeting Jedd Busslinger who was highly touted last year?

 

[Serenity Now]

The Eagles beating the dogs makes things interesting

 

[Shinboner1]

WE ****ING GOT PICK 1 BABY!
TRADE PICK 1 TO MELB FOR 3 FIRSTS AND TAKE MANY PICKS TO THE DRAFT!

 

[krakouers]

I don't know how he's gone at VFL level this year, but the Dogs seem to have a logjam of talls, should we be targeting Jedd Busslinger who was highly touted last year?

Think we could get someone out of there, they have Croft still to come

 

[FootySmartSimpson]

Pick 1, 39> West Coast
Pick 3, 19> North
Pick 14, Flanders> Gold Coast
Pick 5, Flanders>North
Pick 19>Clarke, Pick 31
Pick 31>Stephens

McKay FA Combo: Pick 2

Draft hand:2,3,5,Sanders,31, 58, 59

End up:Reid, Watson, O’Sullivan, Sanders, Moir, 58, 59

Archer Corr Bergman
Reid O’Sullivan Goater

Stephens Davies-Uniacke Scott
Xerri Sanders Wardlaw

Thomas Comben Sheezel
Zurhaar Larkey Watson

I:Simpkin Phillips Ford Curtis

 

[Lomas]

Pick 1, 39> West Coast
Pick 3, 19> North
Pick 14, Flanders> Gold Coast
Pick 5, Flanders>North
Pick 19>Clarke, Pick 31
Pick 31>Stephens

McKay FA Combo: Pick 2

Draft hand:2,3,5,Sanders,31, 58, 59

End up:Reid, Watson, O’Sullivan, Sanders, Moir, 58, 59

Archer Corr Bergman
Reid O’Sullivan Goater

Stephens Davies-Uniacke Scott
Xerri Sanders Wardlaw

Thomas Comben Sheezel
Zurhaar Larkey Watson

I:Simpkin Phillips Ford Curtis

Let’s also trade to the bulldogs for their two first rounders, they need to get ahead of a father some, and a future first pick swap. For pick 6, Or For our future first and third

 

[Makeshift Park]

Pick 1, 39> West Coast
Pick 3, 19> North
Pick 14, Flanders> Gold Coast
Pick 5, Flanders>North
Pick 19>Clarke, Pick 31
Pick 31>Stephens

McKay FA Combo: Pick 2

Draft hand:2,3,5,Sanders,31, 58, 59

End up:Reid, Watson, O’Sullivan, Sanders, Moir, 58, 59

Archer Corr Bergman
Reid O’Sullivan Goater

Stephens Davies-Uniacke Scott
Xerri Sanders Wardlaw

Thomas Comben Sheezel
Zurhaar Larkey Watson

I:Simpkin Phillips Ford Curtis

It is a good problem to have, but I agree getting Reid and Curtin isn't as good as Reid, O'Sullivan and Watson.

 

[shinboner magic]

Trade period will be interesting

Ok we start with
Picks
1, 2(PP), 3 (FA), 14,39,53






We finish with

1, 2(PP), 3 (FA), 14,39,53

 

[chubbspeterson]

WE ******* GOT PICK 1 BABY!
TRADE PICK 1 TO MELB FOR 3 FIRSTS AND TAKE MANY PICKS TO THE DRAFT!

Nah not for two late 1sts (Dees will be top 4 next year) and pick 4. We need elite talent if we give up Reid. Deal must have as many top 8 picks as possible given this draft has an elite 7 or 8. Would have to be a staggering offer to do it imo.

 

[Johnny99]

So if we get band 1 for McKay, we can walk out of the draft with Reid and Curtin.....Clarko won't be needing that little blue pill tonight....