List Mgmt. 2023 Trade & List Management Thread

[King Corey]

Edit: will update if ppl happy for this to sticky

Ok starting the hit list of names mentioned in any rumour as linked to us for 2023 trade period.

• Mac Andrew
• Hunter Clark
• Zac Fisher
• Sam Flanders
• Mitch Georgiades
• Liam Henry
• Dougal Howard
• Lewis Melican
• Jack Silvagni
• Dylan Stephens
• Adam Tomlinson

 

[zoomba23]

Thoughts on Jack Billings? Boomer brought his name up on RSN this morning.

I'd do it for a third rounder

 

[Sphynx]

What ever deal they've offered(unless the deal nets us Band 1 compo similar to what the Bombers did with Daniher/Lions) , we match it and force the trade.

Band 1, otherwise Bergman.

 

[Reagan Smash]

Dumb and Dumber reunite at Port

 

[Passmore]

Thoughts on Jack Billings? Boomer brought his name up on RSN this morning.

Anything more than a nominal late pick, you’d probably not bother. They likely just want his contract off the books.

 

[Passmore]

Dumb and Dumber reunite at Port

They’re getting ‘arry as well?

 

[XU1-ROO]

Good club Port. Go after players from a team that has been on the bottom of the ladder for 4 years. Will need Band 1 compo at min.

 

[Passmore]

Just back on the Pick 6/Carlton Salary Dump exercise.

I think it is 100% worth a look at.

To potentially enter a draft with 2/3/6/17 is a ridiculous hand to hold.

I'd be looking at trading any of pick 6 and 17 for established players. Preferably key defenders.

You’d assume we’d have a shit load of cap space. That should be our trump card.

 

[R00StaR]

Yep. Opposite of what we need at the moment.

I just dont see how we go after any mature players this year with our draft hand other than FA. Then we'd be nuts to use FA 'IF' we get a first round compo for McKay. FA is on the cards only if McKay stays.

We'd be nuts to trade for a quality mature player when we're in dire need of a quality small forward when our pick will likely net WizWatson.

Mckay for round 1 comp or keep. So Curtin as a replacement or we keep. Then if we removed all the older guys on our list, we could field the following team which is more than capable in 24 and with a very high unknown ceiling. If we got Curtin then Logue and Corr can do most of the KDP work.

McDonald, Logue, Bergman
Thomas, Corr, Sheezel
Ford, LDU, Scott
Stevo, Comben, Curtis
Zurhaar, Larkey, Watson
Xerri, Simpkin, Wardlaw

Phiilips, CCJ, Powell, Goater, George, Taylor, Tucker, Curtin(?), Perez, Harvey, Archer, Dawson, Lazzaro, Edwards, Dury, Young and Free.

Given Goldie is happy to mentor and be back up he gets another plus if McKay goes it might be wise to give JZ another one perhaps at the cost of Perez who we rookie. I previously wanted to keep Spicer but with Watson and Jnr i accept he's likely gone unless he really shows something soon, if so a possible rookie spot is there. Young id rookie.

The point of highlighting the team is to show we have quality everywhere with huge upside and simply dont need to be trading for any mid ranged senior player types.

 

[lockheed]

Sam Edmund reiterated that Ben McKay will land at Port Adelaide.

If they try and screw us over again, I'd match their offer. I don't want us to be their bitch, two years running.

 

[R00StaR]

Sam Edmund reiterated that Ben McKay will land at Port Adelaide.

They're the most likely, in the window
AND
they dont have a first rounder, so no skin off their nose to trigger us a first round compo.

 

[kool kangas]

With LDU, Simpkin, Wardlaw, Phillips and Powell + a other rotations we have no need for center square mids.

He would be ok as a back up for those mentioned above. He wouldnt cost much and could play in the VFL until needed..

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

Realistically what would he cost? It’s been 3/4 years since he was averaging 23+ disposals and nearly a goal per game.

Saints would want an early second, but depends on the size of the contract and how desperate the Saints are.

 

[kool kangas]

Sam Edmund reiterated that Ben McKay will land at Port Adelaide.

l take Sam Edmunds comments with a grain of salt..

 

[R00StaR]

Just back on the Pick 6/Carlton Salary Dump exercise.

I think it is 100% worth a look at.

To potentially enter a draft with 2/3/6/17 is a ridiculous hand to hold.

I'd be looking at trading any of pick 6 and 17 for established players. Preferably key defenders.

3 and 17 for pick one, under the proviso that we dont take Curtin.
Then take Reid, Watson and Caddy.

 

[R00StaR]

He would be ok as a back up for those mentioned above. He wouldnt cost much and could play in the VFL until needed..

If we wanted that we have Cunner already contracted.

 

[HBFlanker]

3 and 17 for pick one, under the proviso that we dont take Curtin.
Then take Reid, Watson and Caddy.

As strange as it sounds, i dont think we need Reid.

 

[ferball]

With LDU, Simpkin, Wardlaw, Phillips and Powell + a other rotations we have no need for center square mids.

There's people talking about trading Powell cos they think we have too many mids.

 

[ferball]

Yeah, yeah, Collingwood this, Collingwood that.

Phillips and Powell cover the ground just fine. McKay will likely be someone else’s issue.

Yep, sure do.

 

[ferball]

As strange as it sounds, i dont think we need Reid.

I completely agree. And I don't think we need pick one either.

 

[R00StaR]

There's people talking about trading Powell cos they think we have too many mids.

Yeah and then some that want more. We can simply keep Greenwood if we want a mature age backup, hard to see us getting much better. He's had a solid year.

 

[R00StaR]

As strange as it sounds, i dont think we need Reid.

Agree, id be happy to take Watson, Curtin, Caddy and whoever Ports pick nets us.
But if WC were to play ball to get Curtin id do it. Reid is a gun and can play almost anywhere.

 

[Sphynx]

They're the most likely, in the window
AND
they dont have a first rounder, so no skin off their nose to trigger us a first round compo.

They do have a future first and a few unsigned Victorian kids though (Bergman, Sinn....)

 

[Daniltchenko You Beauty]

AFL won't want to give us a priority pick so they don't piss off the other clubs but they can massage the compensation system to give us band 1 compensation. Two top five picks on the way

 

[roos 10]

AFL won't want to give us a priority pick so they don't piss off the other clubs but they can massage the compensation system to give us band 1 compensation. Two top five picks on the way

 

[Flawed Genius]

I'm still taking Dow for nothing. Get his salary off Carlton books. Buy Dow, Williams & 6. McKay goes to Port, we either get a 1st PP or we force a trade.

#1 WCE
#2 NMFC (own)
#3 NMFC (PP)
#4 NMFC (McKay pick)
#5 HAW
#6 RICH
#7 GWS
#8 NMFC (Carlton)
#9-#18 Who cares
#19 NMFC (Port pick)

In: Dow (mid depth, potential improvement in new club), Williams (releases Goater/Bergman to a wing, replaces Hall long term if fit), Watson @2 (elite small forward), Edwards @3 (long term Goldstein replacement and cover for if Xerri ends up being no good) McKercher @4 (all round midfielder/wing jet), A.Reid @8 (either end KPP for development), Freijah @19 (HBF/wing hard running athlete)

Out: McKay, cash, #2, #3, #4, #8, #19, delistees

:Stern look