List Mgmt. 2023 Trade Thread - Part I

[George]

 

[gringo2011]

I reckon we take Sinn and Berg, giving them Nas and a future 1st to pay for Kosi. Bend them over on some later picks and everyone wins.

Sinn looks a potential injury bust. Not so keen on that deal. Would rather take our pick in the draft. Berg as a straight swap would be my preference.

 

[gringo2011]

Feckless poster...how very dare you

Don't worry about Scrappy, I find you very feckful Tommy.

 

[ScrappyDo]

My point is the same as yours mate.

Was just putting out there that Pickett looks to be staying.

Sorry, I'm accustomed to people arguing over nothing for no reason..

 

[Mowman]

I reckon we take Sinn and Berg, giving them Nas and a future 1st to pay for Kosi. Bend them over on some later picks and everyone wins.

God hope not
We get bent over there
Sinn can’t get on the park and hasn’t be able to since u/18 year

 

[Strahany]

Wouldn't be against the proposed NWM + future 2nd for Sinn + Bergman. Of course, this would all depend on how each of these 3 pan out across the season.

 

[gringo2011]

Not really

If Port want him they will have to find something for him. Adelaide will finish lower on the ladder so they would gobble him up in the PSD

It won’t just be one second rounder. Even Giants for 2 x second round picks for Caldwell from Dodoro who was adamant he was only worth one.

I think if Port really want him they will make room for him, but if they decide they want to keep everyone on their list then I think they will just allow Adelaide to go after him.

He's not exactly a super sexy target outside St Kilda. I doubt they give that many shits about him. It's not the strongest hand we hold.

 

[ScrappyDo]

Sorry boss, was a bit confusing. Thought Port were paying for Pickett with their future first

That is too much to give up for Sinn and Bergman

Bergman and Nas would be close to a straight swap

Sinn would be worth the same as Freeman with his body, it would be a poor move for the club to give up a first for him

I haven't been tracking Sinn but l think we're all around the straight Nas for Berg mark.

 

[bird_man]

He's not exactly a super sexy target outside St Kilda. I doubt they give that many shits about him. It's not the strongest hand we hold.

Not sure about that

Adelaide were very keen on him in the draft

It’s always hard to get great value for in contracted home sick kids but I don’t think we get totally pantsed on this one

 

[BucketsandBanger]

Interesting all this talk of Nas. Did I hear Lyon say yesterday he spent 20 minutes talking with a 2nd year player this week who’s not on his game at the moment. Logically that has to be Nas. He was better in the second half but still doesn’t look anywhere near comfortable at the level at the moment in my opinion. Rushes everything. The most important thing if he stays or goes is for him to play well this year and continue his development. Can’t let the off field stuff get in the way of on field.

 

[Winmar2Lockett]

Interesting all this talk of Nas. Did I hear Lyon say yesterday he spent 20 minutes talking with a 2nd year player this week who’s not on his game at the moment. Logically that has to be Nas. He was better in the second half but still doesn’t look anywhere near comfortable at the level at the moment in my opinion. Rushes everything. The most important thing if he stays or goes is for him to play well this year and continue his development. Can’t let the off field stuff get in the way of on field.

Aside from a few blown kicks I thought Nas was fantastic (two were tough kicks that we want him to keep trying to hit.) His defensive running was brilliant.

He's as composed as any 2nd year player that I can remember.

 

[SaintsofSteel]

Interesting all this talk of Nas. Did I hear Lyon say yesterday he spent 20 minutes talking with a 2nd year player this week who’s not on his game at the moment. Logically that has to be Nas. He was better in the second half but still doesn’t look anywhere near comfortable at the level at the moment in my opinion. Rushes everything. The most important thing if he stays or goes is for him to play well this year and continue his development. Can’t let the off field stuff get in the way of on field.

Agree I think he might have been punishing himself after those couple of turn overs, but to his credit he kept taking the inside kicks. Would still like to see a bit more physicality/urgency in his game. He is only a slight build but he needs to apply himself a bit more physically.

 

[The Punter]

Agree I think he might have been punishing himself after those couple of turn overs, but to his credit he kept taking the inside kicks. Would still like to see a bit more physicality/urgency in his game. He is only a slight build but he needs to apply himself a bit more physically.

I've seen this with a few players - the urgency "look" is us not him. We want to see a specific, obvious physicality. A number of players never exude what the outside believes is physicality or urgency. I wouldn't worry about it.

 

[CaptainRisky]

Berg does want to come back and it will be us when he does

 

[AirWinmar]

I've seen this with a few players - the urgency "look" is us not him. We want to see a specific, obvious physicality. A number of players never exude what the outside believes is physicality or urgency. I wouldn't worry about it.

100%. His has a running style that is very smooth as well. 1st time I saw him live, couldn't believe how quick he was

 

[g_TRAIN]

Interesting all this talk of Nas. Did I hear Lyon say yesterday he spent 20 minutes talking with a 2nd year player this week who’s not on his game at the moment. Logically that has to be Nas. He was better in the second half but still doesn’t look anywhere near comfortable at the level at the moment in my opinion. Rushes everything. The most important thing if he stays or goes is for him to play well this year and continue his development. Can’t let the off field stuff get in the way of on field.

Maybe Oscar Adams as well?

Or could be a case of NAS judging himself harshly for some of his skill errors where he felt he was off his game a bit in that area.

He was certainly good for us on the weekend overall though.

 

[DougalHoward]

Maybe Oscar Adams as well?

Could be Oscar Adams, Jack Peris or NWM

 

[sunny3193]

Berg does want to come back and it will be us when he does

Is this you being ITK, or just a vibe?

 

[Dr Spaceman]

Berg does want to come back and it will be us when he does

Is this you being ITK, or just a vibe?

Can confirm the above based on an extreme, humungous, mega ITK interaction involving both myself and the good Captain

 

[CaptainRisky]

Is this you being ITK, or just a vibe?

Im no ITK but my source was speaking with his family and said he loves Port , has no issue with the club he just wants to come home and is a Saints supporter, so im guessing the club will already be putting a plan ( Target ) in place for when Nas decides to tell them he wants to go home .
Berg would be a good result IMO

 

[sunny3193]

Im no ITK but my source was speaking with his family and said he loves Port , has no issue with the club he just wants to come home and is a Saints supporter, so im guessing the club will already be putting a plan ( Target ) in place for when Nas decides to tell them he wants to go home .
Berg would be a good result IMO

Thanks Captain.

 

[gringo2011]

Aside from a few blown kicks I thought Nas was fantastic (two were tough kicks that we want him to keep trying to hit.) His defensive running was brilliant.

He's as composed as any 2nd year player that I can remember.

He missed a heap of targets but he's new to the role and super inexperienced. I'll cut him slack until he hits the 50 to 100 game mark.

 

[CaptainRisky]

He missed a heap of targets but he's new to the role and super inexperienced. I'll cut him slack until he hits the 50 to 100 game mark.

In his Port jumper

 

[gringo2011]

In his Port jumper

Bergs will come in and make us forget hopefully.

 

[SaintsofSteel]

Im no ITK but my source was speaking with his family and said he loves Port , has no issue with the club he just wants to come home and is a Saints supporter, so im guessing the club will already be putting a plan ( Target ) in place for when Nas decides to tell them he wants to go home .
Berg would be a good result IMO

Bergman or Sinn would both be a good pick ups regardless of NWM decision. They are good in the air for their size and we cant get enough of those players IMO. With RTB at the helm I think our club will be a whole lot more attractive to outside players than it has been for a very long time ie Watters, Richardson, Ratten (what an inspirational group).

 

[sunny3193]

Im no ITK but my source was speaking with his family and said he loves Port , has no issue with the club he just wants to come home and is a Saints supporter, so im guessing the club will already be putting a plan ( Target ) in place for when Nas decides to tell them he wants to go home .
Berg would be a good result IMO

Just looked up Bergman and see he is a St Bede’s product.
Makes me wonder if your ITK has a spiritual connection?
Brother…..?
Did you and Dr Spaceman have a Mass experience recently?