List Mgmt. 2023 Trade Thread - Part I

[George]

 

[MightySaint]

69 may be hard, unless she’s 205cm?

Ahhh, who's going to tell him? George, did you know your bromance is with a 12 year old?

 

[Sarcoidevo]

What is Bergman's position / role?

For me it's a no ..... reckon there is likely to be a class gap down the line ..... with Nas going on to become the better player

Do Adelaide still have their 1st pick in this years draft?

 

[gringo2011]

pssst... it's not sucking toes

happy to help

Different technique over there.

 

[gringo2011]

What is Bergman's position / role?

For me it's a no ..... reckon there is likely to be a class gap down the line ..... with Nas going on to become the better player

Do Adelaide still have their 1st pick in this years draft?

Wingman but can kick a goal and play defence.

 

[goodie23]

What is Bergman's position / role?

For me it's a no ..... reckon there is likely to be a class gap down the line ..... with Nas going on to become the better player

Do Adelaide still have their 1st pick in this years draft?

They do but no way in hell would they part with it in a Nas trade. They've traded out their 2nd and 3rd rounders but have Gold Coast's and North's 2nds.

Port meanwhile have already traded their 1st, 2nd and 3rd, they currently have Collingwood's 2nd and West Coast's 3rd. So basically they can **** right off.

Lore's amazing spreadsheet is great for keeping up to date with this stuff:

 

[bird_man]

What is Bergman's position / role?

For me it's a no ..... reckon there is likely to be a class gap down the line ..... with Nas going on to become the better player

Do Adelaide still have their 1st pick in this years draft?

If that is the case you can ask for more on top in a trade

I can't see Adelaide giving away their first for him this year if it's going to be another low finish for them though, unless we are giving up something else ourselves

Best we could probably get is a future first from either

 

[Winmar2Lockett]

If that is the case you can ask for more on top in a trade

I can't see Adelaide giving away their first for him this year if it's going to be another low finish for them though, unless we are giving up something else ourselves

Best we could probably get is a future first from either

The Cows can stump up Rachele


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Barrels]

OOC at season’s end…

Adams
Byrnes
Bytel*
Campbell
Caminiti
Clark
Coffield
Connolly
Gresham*
Higgins
Highmore
Jones
McKenzie
Peris
Ross
Stocker
Wanganeen-Milera*
Webster
Wood

So… who’re we keeping?

The bolded for me, but those with an asterisk, I’d see what we can get by way of trade or FA compensation…

 

[Dard Ball Get]

OOC at season’s end…

Adams
Byrnes
Bytel*
Campbell
Caminiti
Clark
Coffield
Connolly
Gresham*
Higgins
Highmore
Jones
McKenzie
Peris
Ross
Stocker
Wanganeen-Milera*
Webster
Wood

So… who’re we keeping?

The bolded for me, but those with an asterisk, I’d see what we can get by way of trade or FA compensation…

Looks good to me. Shame Highmore can’t quite crack it, would be nice to see him picked up somewhere else.

 

[bird_man]

OOC at season’s end…

Adams
Byrnes
Bytel*
Campbell
Caminiti
Clark
Coffield
Connolly
Gresham*
Higgins
Highmore
Jones
McKenzie
Peris
Ross
Stocker
Wanganeen-Milera*
Webster
Wood

So… who’re we keeping?

The bolded for me, but those with an asterisk, I’d see what we can get by way of trade or FA compensation…

I’d be doing everything to keep Gresham

He’s only 25, should be at his prime still if we get into a position to really push into contention

The chances of getting someone better with a pick we get for him are slim and we would have to wait 5 years before we knew if it was worth it

NWM is likely gone so we should get something decent for him

I can’t see us getting anything for Bytel. He almost didn’t get a contract this year and I think he was looking for a new home himself.

If we want more draft picks it might be worth shopping someone like Billing’s around. His body has let him down and a few younger guys look like going past him now

Jones probably the only one not bolded really worth keeping IMO but that would depend on if he had a good run with injuries. Seems like his body just isn’t up to it

 

[Barrels]

I’d be doing everything to keep Gresham

He’s only 25, should be at his prime still if we get into a position to really push into contention

The chances of getting someone better with a pick we get for him are slim and we would have to wait 5 years before we knew if it was worth it

NWM is likely gone so we should get something decent for him

I can’t see us getting anything for Bytel. He almost didn’t get a contract this year and I think he was looking for a new home himself.

If we want more draft picks it might be worth shopping someone like Billing’s around. His body has let him down and a few younger guys look like going past him now

Jones probably the only one not bolded really worth keeping IMO but that would depend on if he had a good run with injuries. Seems like his body just isn’t up to it

Everyone knows how I feel about Gresh… but if someone comes with a massive offer…

I agree Bytel probably isn’t worth much on the market, and probably far more to us than elsewhere, but something is better than simply delisting.

Jones I like, but he’s made of tissue paper at this point. Same as DMac.

 

[bird_man]

Everyone knows how I feel about Gresh… but if someone comes with a massive offer…

I think we’d have to finish pretty low on the ladder for it to be worth it though

I’d be disappointed to lose him for pick 11

He’s huge for us. Even his first two weeks haven’t been his best but he’s had some big moments that have helped turn the momentum of a game.

Hard to find players like that

 

[Barrels]

I think we’d have to finish pretty low on the ladder for it to be worth it though

I’d be disappointed to lose him for pick 11

He’s huge for us. Even his first two weeks haven’t been his best but he’s had some big moments that have helped turn the momentum of a game.

Hard to find players like that

He’s been my boy since his draft year… but footy is a business these days…

He has to want to stay too.

 

[gringo2011]

I think we’d have to finish pretty low on the ladder for it to be worth it though

I’d be disappointed to lose him for pick 11

He’s huge for us. Even his first two weeks haven’t been his best but he’s had some big moments that have helped turn the momentum of a game.

Hard to find players like that

Yeah, they keep winding back FA compensation. Unless he's paid like one of the top few players in the league end of first round would be about it, so around pick 20 with all the academy and FS taken out. I doubt we get anything as good with that pick.

 

[ScrappyDo]

OOC at season’s end…

Adams
Byrnes
Bytel*
Campbell
Caminiti
Clark
Coffield
Connolly
Gresham*
Higgins
Highmore
Jones
McKenzie
Peris
Ross
Stocker
Wanganeen-Milera*
Webster
Wood

So… who’re we keeping?

The bolded for me, but those with an asterisk, I’d see what we can get by way of trade or FA compensation…

Adams
Byrnes
Bytel
Campbell*
Caminiti
Clark
Coffield
Connolly
Gresham
Higgins
Highmore
Jones
McKenzie
Billings
Allison*
Peris
Ross
Stocker
Wanganeen-Milera
Webster
Wood

Peris should have one more year as a cat B.

Campbell, if there's a replacement
Highmore, not really good enough
Jones, injuries
McKenzie, injuries
Billings' heartless manlett
Allison, consider paying out

Draft 3, one spot open for SSP

 

[stavro#4]

I think we’d have to finish pretty low on the ladder for it to be worth it though

I’d be disappointed to lose him for pick 11

He’s huge for us. Even his first two weeks haven’t been his best but he’s had some big moments that have helped turn the momentum of a game.

Hard to find players like that

You can force a trade and risk the market dictating the price of a deal you’ll match.

 

[bird_man]

You can force a trade and risk the market dictating the price of a deal you’ll match.

You can but I still don't see us getting the value that will be lost from him going

As I said, he's an extremely important part of our team. Genuine goal kicking forward mid that can win clearances.

Those guys don't grow on trees

He's also at that age bracket that we can't really afford to lose. He's someone you might think about trading at the start of a rebuild

 

[Barrels]

Billings' heartless manlett

 

[Mowman]

Leathlean' heartless manlett

 

[George]

Ahhh, who's going to tell him? George, did you know your bromance is with a 12 year old?

Yes.

 

[bird_man]

They do but no way in hell would they part with it in a Nas trade. They've traded out their 2nd and 3rd rounders but have Gold Coast's and North's 2nds.

Port meanwhile have already traded their 1st, 2nd and 3rd, they currently have Collingwood's 2nd and West Coast's 3rd. So basically they can **** right off.

Lore's amazing spreadsheet is great for keeping up to date with this stuff:

George can you please sticky tape this to the top of the thread?

 

[StCicatriz]

George can you please sticky tape this to the top of the thread?

holy **** how does melbourne have pick 6?

 

[11men1cup]

holy * how does melbourne have pick 6?

Luke Jackson. Million dollar man

On Pixel 7 Pro using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[StCicatriz]

Luke Jackson. Million dollar man

On Pixel 7 Pro using BigFooty.com mobile app

i knew that just wanted to highlight how ****ed freo are once again

its a thing of beauty

 

[CursingFijian]

OOC at season’s end…

Adams
Byrnes
Bytel*
Campbell
Caminiti
Clark
Coffield
Connolly
Gresham*
Higgins
Highmore
Jones
McKenzie
Peris
Ross
Stocker
Wanganeen-Milera*
Webster
Wood

So… who’re we keeping?

The bolded for me, but those with an asterisk, I’d see what we can get by way of trade or FA compensation…

I heard Cal Twomey suggesting Collingwood should go hard at Gresham on his new Gettable podcast.