List Mgmt. 2024 Trade & List Management Thread - Part 3

[giantroo]

Spoiler: 2024 Draft Picks

 

[The Nostradamus]

Ethan Phillips also delisted

 

[King Hansen]

Cully culled.

 

[King Hansen]

Pick 29 from 2022, which is what our pick 25 will be after the bids, got delisted today from WC.

 

[DuckYeah]

Thats a fairly brutal delisting.. must have lost his leap or something after his knee, poor campaigner

 

[hoffseason gains 01]

Thats a fairly brutal delisting.. must have lost his leap or something after his knee, poor campaigner

Yeah especially for those bigger mids a hit to the athleticism can render them almost useless unfortunately

 

[Samsquanch]

Fun fact, they a called ‘nibble pies’ in Warrnambool.

Alright.

I'm not saying I'm wrong. I never actually denied the "nibble pies" thing. I am certain that my position is that the term was never used to the east of Alansford and it was purely a Warrnambool thing.

I have just been informed by my cousin who grew up in Alansford and later, in Warrnambool until she moved to Perth in 1984 that "nibbles" or "nibble pies" is real.

Apparently.

 

[ferball]

Tell me again, which draft class was he a part of? *








* (rhetorical question)

Rhetorical Aye???


2020!!!

 

[roos_fanatic08]

I’d get Culley & Grainger-Barass down to the club for pre season with eyes on George’s list spot as an LTI.

 

[Marstermind]

Tell me again, which draft class was he a part of? *








* (rhetorical question)

 

[chickenonachain]

I’d get Culley & Grainger-Barass down to the club for pre season with eyes on George’s list spot as an LTI.

I’d rather one or two of those Werribee boys I reckon they would have a good crack at it

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

I’d rather one or two of those Werribee boys I reckon they would have a good crack at it

Tend to agree, at least from a needs pov.

 

[bengrina]

If we are unable to get value by splitting pick 2 what do you think we could get by trading our future first? Would it be possible to get 1 of saints 7 or 8 or demons 9? I understand we tried getting suns 13 with our future first so imagine we had enquired with saints and demons and told no?

 

[Makeshift Park]

I’d rather one or two of those Werribee boys I reckon they would have a good crack at it

Genuine question as a VFL numpty who only watches North games:
Where would we play Brew?
We've got Phillips as our first preference as tagger.
Wardlaw tackles all day long
Parker for leadership and accountability
Maybe as a defensive forward?

 

[Themanbun]

If we are unable to get value by splitting pick 2 what do you think we could get by trading our future first? Would it be possible to get 1 of saints 7 or 8 or demons 9? I understand we tried getting suns 13 with our future first so imagine we had enquired with saints and demons and told no?

Not sure. Clubs will likely value it around pick 4-5. But then in the 2024 draft you could get the 4th on your board at pick 10 or so, so it really depends on who their targets are.

 

[Themanbun]

Genuine question as a VFL numpty who only watches North games:
Where would we play Brew?
We've got Phillips as our first preference as tagger.
Wardlaw tackles all day long
Parker for leadership and accountability
Maybe as a defensive forward?

Ship has sailed on Brew for us. Personally would have traded out some of our young midfield capital a few years ago and got him in but that time has passed too.

 

[Makeshift Park]

Ship has sailed on Brew for us. Personally would have traded out some of our young midfield capital a few years ago and got him in but that time has passed too.

Alright, so say you're Rawlings, who would you recruit from Werribee?

 

[Themanbun]

Alright, so say you're Rawlings, who would you recruit from Werribee?

Garoni first then Bice. The latter is the better prospect but with Daniel coming in, Hardeman, Goater, etc. he's less of a need.

 

[Makeshift Park]

Garoni first then Bice. The latter is the better prospect but with Daniel coming in, Hardeman, Goater, etc. he's less of a need.

Even if Garoni was stuck behind Darling, Teakle, Maley and a 2024 draftee?

Or only if we went for a midfielder or Tauru at 2?

 

[Themanbun]

Even if Garoni was stuck behind Darling, Teakle, Maley and a 2024 draftee?

Or only if we went for a midfielder or Tauru at 2?

Yep. 1-2 of those will be playing AFL. Maley has been thrown around in the ruck and is still a speculative prospect as much as I rate him.

Garoni would step in and be our best VFL forward by a long way and I think would work well with Finbar.

 

[chickenonachain]

Genuine question as a VFL numpty who only watches North games:
Where would we play Brew?
We've got Phillips as our first preference as tagger.
Wardlaw tackles all day long
Parker for leadership and accountability
Maybe as a defensive forward?

To be honest I don’t know I would just rather get someone who’s going to bust his gut at training to try and get a game than someone who’s been delisted who more than likely is finished. Give someone a chance you never know what we may get

 

[The Filth Wizard]

Late thoughts on trade period.

Not my concept but - it's very unlikely Brady is operating in a vacuum. He's probably coordinating the feeler contacts with agents but would bet he's largely being dictated requirements by Clarkson then tasked with making them happen.

I doubt Thursfield was thrilled to lose #25 and it was an overpay. But I'm inclined to clear Brady on this one. It smacks of a captain's call, the whole "Daniel wants to play for Alastair Clarkson". I suspect Brady was given the names Parker and Daniel and asked to secure them, with no option of retreat.

Overall, this trade period was the strongest indicator that they've now looked at everyone 27+ on the list, grabbed the bucket, then moved swiftly to rebalance that lack of senior poise and presence.

So mission accomplished in terms of slightly fixing list structure.

I suspect this view is 100% accurate.

 

[ToxicMegaPunts]

Has to be one of the quickest pathways out of the system I've seen for a top 5 pick.

Fischer McAsey was also pick #6 just one draft class prior. I think he was delisted by the Crows after only 2 or 3 years.

 

[Themanbun]

Fischer McAsey was also pick #6 just one draft class prior. I think he was delisted by the Crows after only 2 or 3 years.

I think he quit though for personal reasons.

 

[The Filth Wizard]

I’d rather one or two of those Werribee boys I reckon they would have a good crack at it

I think they both have to be drafted. Culley and DGB could train on with us and join as a DFA. At least with these two you can go into preseason training to gauge it.

 

[chickenonachain]

I think they both have to be drafted. Culley and DGB could train on with us and join as a DFA. At least with these two you can go into preseason training to gauge it.

Are they not able to train with us with view for a rookie spot?