manicpie
Brownlow Medallist
- Joined
- Jul 19, 2019
- Posts
- 29,262
- Reaction score
- 53,961
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Disco balls?I'm gonna cross my balls
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

LIVE: Adelaide v Geelong - Rd 13 - 7:00PM Thu
Squiggle tips Cats at 57% chance -- What's your tip? -- Injury Lists » -- All Rd 13 Games
BigFooty Tipping Notice Img
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 13
The Golden Ticket - Corporate tickets, functions, Open Air Boxes at the Adelaide Oval, ENGIE, Gabba, MCG, Marvel, Optus & People First Stadiums. Corporate Suites at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Disco balls?I'm gonna cross my balls
Structure won us the flag ie adding a like for like with Frampton replacing McStay.It won us a flag so it can't be that bad.
The value of Talls is winning games to get into finals - agree they have less influence in finals. But you won’t get there without them.More likely to work in high pressure games in fact imo. Get the ball to ground inside 50 and take marking interceptors out of the game. Then let your small forwards get to work and dominate. It’s no coincidence that it’s uncommon for talk forwards to kick big bags of goals in grand finals. Often small forwards and goal-kicking mids do the damage. High pressure with taps and knock-ons and ground ball gets that lead to goals are more the norm
Shiny onesDisco balls?
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
I don't think anyone is suggesting that another tall isn't required down there to replace Dan & help Checkers & consequently bring the ball to ground for our smalls. It's just that we need not rely on that tall to get our goals. Our smalls can do that.Structure won us the flag ie adding a like for like with Frampton replacing McStay.
Going small wouldn’t have negated Andrews.
THAT is the type of commitment it takes to go back to back, folks!I'm gonna cross my balls
Definitely AJ's time to shine & make the most of this opportunity. Big positive is that he's come back super fit & strong.So the dilemma now is can Johnson be the KF. Vastly different style of fwd compared to McStay.
Guess we'll find out, have no doubt the mc have spoken to Ash and the squad about it or will if they haven't.
What the strategy will be should be fascinating.
I was thinking more along the lines of kicking the ball into open space rather than to pack contests and letting the mosquito fleet get to workThat requires a key forward. It’s the exact reason McStay was recruited in the first place.
Shiny ones
Kpf's are a thing of the past somewhat. Nowadays it's the mobile forwards. We are pretty well set up in this regard.I was thinking more along the lines of kicking the ball into open space rather than to pack contests and letting the mosquito fleet get to work
My thinking as well bro.I was thinking more along the lines of kicking the ball into open space rather than to pack contests and letting the mosquito fleet get to work
I mean that the club specifically chose Dan because we didn't want a completely dominant forward. We wanted a player to provide a contest. We can do that through Frampton, Cox, Cameron, freddy and Steene if it really concerns you about our lack of height. We went with Frampton to curb Andrews, very different to what you're suggesting. I would love McStay in the side next year but I seriously doubt we can't win the flag without him
We just need talls to provide a contest when the defence is set. It's flipped in terms of skillset. You want classy kpds who mark it consistently and grunt kpfs who bring it to ground and take an occasional clunk.There aren't any KF currently in the competition that take heaps of contested marks in pack situations. The best ones are leading forwards. In a fast moving game style like ours, we don't really need a KF who's a certain height. We have 2 really good lead up forwards in Johnson and Reef. I still think that this will play in our favour. We will be even more unpredictable and versatile next year, while we pick off all the other teams Key Forwards because they will be so predictable, a bit like this year.
Nah. They don't star in finals, but they're more important because there's more kicks to a contest. They matter in terms of providing a contest and bringing it to ground.The value of Talls is winning games to get into finals - agree they have less influence in finals. But you won’t get there without them.
Its really hard to tell, given the match sim is barely that given the small amount of players. But I've seen more of Hustwaite in the match sim than Bytel (who seems to be playing forward- not one of the starting mids that I could see)Hey Jen, which one of Hustwaite and Bytel do you think the Pies will take? Either of them impressing in match sim?
Glass half full. I love your work.We "chose" Dan because he was the only KPP on the market and within our price range.
Frampton is a shocking forward. Krueger is not giving you any aerial contests. Steene is a VFL kid. Cameron massively struggled in the forward line... Cox sometimes gives contests, sometimes he's non existent.
It's going to be a massive issue in 2024, Fly will have his work cut out.
Yeah, you'd think we'll need to be a bit patient.Its really hard to tell, given the match sim is barely that given the small amount of players. But I've seen more of Hustwaite in the match sim than Bytel (who seems to be playing forward- not one of the starting mids that I could see)
Once the seniors are back on Monday, we may get a better idea
Dan only played 14 games in 2023, and whilst he was good, we still found a way to win the flag without him.We "chose" Dan because he was the only KPP on the market and within our price range.
Frampton is a shocking forward. Krueger is not giving you any aerial contests. Steene is a VFL kid. Cameron massively struggled in the forward line... Cox sometimes gives contests, sometimes he's non existent.
It's going to be a massive issue in 2024, Fly will have his work cut out.
Talk about panic merchant, lolGlass half full. I love your work.