List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion - part 2

[Sheepey]

Sounds like a man that's mentally out the door. Devastating if true

 

[_Maximus_12]

I put my hopes in what I see with my own 2 eyes and what I hear with my own 2 ears.

Without having seen the above - everyone was posting saying he is gone and needs to talk to his family.

What he actually said was that he had spoken to them and his agent.

So on live TV he has said he has spoken 2 2/3 of the groups who needs to know. Do you think stkilda is still unaware or do you think they already knew when Ross slipped Eddie his headline on Tuesday?

My family have been a part of my decision, is a big part of the hold up, in fact likely the entire hold up.

We’re so used to things not panning out, 80% of this forum are already safeguarding themselves to expect the worst.
Need only remember back to the Alice Springs game where Nas said he wanted to be apart of the best st Kilda side ever. I suggest you watch wilkies interview pre game with Xander.
Nas and Windy at the two driving the culture: they’re not leaving it

 

[The Jack]

I’m going early and saying fcuk tony74 for making us believe

Been alot of guessing going on in this thread.

 

[botts]

Alright. Who wants to make some bets. I’ve got 100 bucks on nas leaving. Who wants to take me up on the offer

 

[jwikked]

My family have been a part of my decision, is a big part of the hold up, in fact likely the entire hold up.

We’re so used to things not panning out, 80% of this forum are already safeguarding themselves to expect the worst.
Need only remember back to the Alice Springs game where Nas said he wanted to be apart of the best st Kilda side ever. I suggest you watch wilkies interview pre game with Xander.
Nas and Windy at the two driving the culture: they’re not leaving it

I'll believe the St Kilda curse has been lifted, if we sign Nas for more than 2 years. 2 years, or trade, and our curse continues to exist.

I do think he's the one to lift it, it just needs more than a 2 year commitment to lift this curse.

 

[phantom13]

My favourite part is when they pick and choose which journalists we should listen too.

I really appreciate that the club having confidence is headline worthy now.

I recall the same headline level confidence about Battle signing, how’d that pan out.

 

[jwikked]

I'll believe the St Kilda curse has been lifted, if we sign Nas for more than 2 years. 2 years, or trade, and our curse continues to exist.

I do think he's the one to lift it, it just needs more than a 2 year commitment to lift this curse.

Nas broke our bad bounce curse last week, I'm worried that if he leaves, we will be afflicted with it once again.

 

[tomjoad]

Never is a long time.
He’s a second year player having an awful year.
But throwing the baby out with the bath water…nah.
What pick do you honestly think we’ll get for him?

We are so impatient with our young players.
Look at what’s being heaped on Travaglia ffs.
And Pou - off a shocking season, injury wise.

Yep this.
Trav, Tarau, Pou (due to injury), Boxshall...these guys get a free pass this year.
Wilson, Garcia, etc. Only their 2nd year...and have shown a bit. Wouldn't be writing any of them off yet.
Year 3 is when we can assess and sharpen some knives.
Year 4 knives come out, and the gun gets loaded.

 

[XhazzafootyX]

I really appreciate that the club having confidence is headline worthy now.

I recall the same headline level confidence about Battle signing, how’d that pan out.

You can be confident all you like it means nothing. And from all reports Adelaide and port Adelaide are confident aswell

 

[SainterinSydney]

Mooney mentioned in another interview he spoke to Corey Enright pre game… his last comment to Nas might be hinting something

What did he say, as I didn't catch it? The way people are overreacting on this forum i assume it was, "Crom 4 life".

 

[Mr Platinum]

If we have a mass exodus I'm using it to break free of this club. I'd get my winters back and be a more productive person.

You’ll be back, guarantee it. Clubs don’t revolve around one player, how many flags did God win at Geelong,

This stuff didn't happen when George was in charge, so to suggest he's the dictator is wrong. There's a mod that does 90% of the punishments now, and that's a dictator move.

Mowman is a great poster, and not having him able to give his opinions is wrong.

Mowman is the worst bloke in Australia, a forum bully.

 

[Saint12]

If we have a mass exodus I'm using it to break free of this club. I'd get my winters back and be a more productive person.

Come on just another 10 to 15 more winters or so for the rebuild

 

[Sir Owens]

Nas is 10000% gone. That interview was another train wreck. The final straw.

A terrible night to be a Saints supporter.

 

[Sainter88]

What did he say, as I didn't catch it? The way people are overreacting on this forum i assume it was, "Crom 4 life".

He said we’re finally going to get Fyfe

 

[SainterinSydney]

Geez, bring back Young Gun #6 lol

 

[MightySaint]

It's funny, I was more confident in our future prior to our 4 game winning steak

 

[my name was taken]

woman’s weekly missing a trick not releasing their own footy record.

I can see the pitch now “How to read between the lines: Here’s what he really means and why you’re not hysterical”

 

[Anythings_sipposible]

Jesus Christ everyone needs to relax. A footballer, after a game of football, is not playing 4D chess with the words they choose in a post game interview. My lord.

Maybe Nas is leaving, maybe he isn't. Short of an actual answer either way, anyone reading into body language and word choice in a post game interview is playing a mugs game.

 

[Diehard Saint]

I think that post game interview has said it all. Nas is gone. Mentioned his family in the big Decision he needs to make. Not good. That’s as bad as I’ve seen it

Why? Doesn’t mean he’s going home. Just meant he discussed it with them. Because why wouldn’t you discuss a big decision like this with your family? And why would you need to discuss anything if you’ve decided to go home?

 

[PandaG]

Mid August and no signature is a massive indicator.

Probably just means
1. It’s a big decision
2. His form moved a needle a few times

 

[Diehard Saint]

Disagree.

He would need to discuss it with his family because he isn’t coming home.

Exactly my feeling.

 

[The Jack]

Club doesn’t seem too fussed throwing Nas up in front of the media since the Melbourne game.

Not sure what to read into that, or whether in fact it’s interesting or not.

 

[jwikked]

TDK beat Goldstein in their last match 29 hit outs to 20.

Tonight:
Goldstein 41, Marshall 29.

Peter Wright with 11, for what it's worth.

I'll say it again - Marshall is the most overrated ruck in history.
He's great around the grounds, but he's not a ruckmans pube

 

[phantom13]

Jesus Christ everyone needs to relax. A footballer, after a game of football, is not playing 4D chess with the words they choose in a post game interview. My lord.

Maybe Nas is leaving, maybe he isn't. Short of an actual answer either way, anyone reading into body language and word choice in a post game interview is playing a mugs game.

100%

People talking about cheeky smiles and shit, most ex footballers look like smug campaigners and Nas and co aren’t saying shit especially when they’re literally not saying shit.

 

[beside the seaside]

Club doesn’t seemed too fussed throwing Nas up in front of the media since the Melbourne game.

Not sure what to read into that, or whether in fact it’s interesting or not.

Worth remembering that Battle did a lot of the interviews too towards the end of last year. Means nothing.