List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion - part 2

[Dr Spaceman]

NAS was not smiling when he walked off the ground, so he is definitely leaving. But luckily he was smiling during the song so he changed his mind and is staying after all. Rest easy everybody.

#nasmouthwatch

 

[mighty_sainters]

From someone close to the crows.

They genuinely DK what Naz wants. Being very tight lipped. Numbers being thrown around by PA are above 2m according to them.

Wonder how Port will appease JHF, Butters and Rozee since his contract will be double theirs.

Butters has already seemingly made his mind up unhappy with the NWM situation, courting a move back to Victoria. If only Port didn’t low ball Butters and initially offered 2 million a season they wouldn’t be in this position.

^ Sarcasm

See how easy it is to spin shit for the sake of a story.

I’m all in on TDK and Aleer, they’ll improve us not just next season, but when we hope to be contending soon.

 

[Yawkey way]

But people said we had Heath last week. So tear up TDKs contract

Did he ruck ?

 

[Joffaboy]

Did he ruck ?

He didn't do anything. Was subbed for a reason.

 

[Joffaboy]

Don’t forget 0 game Dodson who were guaranteed to lose with the TDK contract

They'll come for him . Apparently Pou is leaving as well because he was played forward.

 

[stavro#4]

Heath was worse than Marshall

Don’t forget 0 game Dodson who were guaranteed to lose with the TDK contract

They'll come for him . Apparently Pou is leaving as well because he was played forward.

Now, maybe… shock horror.

The club aren’t run by complete clowns like a few like to claim on big footy and that maybe they know best…

 

[BilboJackins]

My info re: TDK is that it is not $1.7m for the life of the contract.

First 2 years inflated using banked money from previous cap space (I was told almost like a sign on bonus).

Subsequent years probably closer to 1.2-1.3.

Another note (and this could be a sticking point for some of the stalling contracts) Saints don’t like to include mandatory TPP increases in contracts. A point of contention with the substantial increases coming in the near future.

 

[heynow85]

154K views · 862 reactions | Ross Lyon crashed the post-game interview and Brad Hill's daughter is trying to convince Nas to stay! 😂 | 3AW Football

Ross Lyon crashed the post-game interview and Brad Hill's daughter is trying to convince Nas to stay! 😂

www.facebook.com

 

[topbillings]

154K views · 862 reactions | Ross Lyon crashed the post-game interview and Brad Hill's daughter is trying to convince Nas to stay! 😂 | 3AW Football

Ross Lyon crashed the post-game interview and Brad Hill's daughter is trying to convince Nas to stay! 😂

www.facebook.com

COME ON HARRIET!! Get it done.

 

[Joffaboy]

My info re: TDK is that it is not $1.7m for the life of the contract.

First 2 years inflated using banked money from previous cap space (I was told almost like a sign on bonus).

Subsequent years probably closer to 1.2-1.3.

Another note (and this could be a sticking point for some of the stalling contracts) Saints don’t like to include mandatory TPP increases in contracts. A point of contention with the substantial increases coming in the near future.

Don't tell people that, the only reason SOS is going after TDK is because he has an Italian blood vendetta against the Blues.
Interesting about TPP, should make an exception for NAZ.

 

[Dard Ball Get]

Now, maybe… shock horror.

The club aren’t run by complete clowns like a few like to claim on big footy and that maybe they know best…

Will need to see that in print

 

[stavro#4]

My info re: TDK is that it is not $1.7m for the life of the contract.

First 2 years inflated using banked money from previous cap space (I was told almost like a sign on bonus).

Subsequent years probably closer to 1.2-1.3.

Another note (and this could be a sticking point for some of the stalling contracts) Saints don’t like to include mandatory TPP increases in contracts. A point of contention with the substantial increases coming in the near future.

No idea about the top part.

But the bottom part would be true. We had less than 5 players with a mandatory increase in the last increase.

 

[LennyHayes77]

If only some of our boys had this mindset. Stay loyal no matter what. I guess they've all forgotten since it was removed from our logo!

 

[jwikked]

Max King goes alright

When?

 

[Sainter62]

When?

Typically when he's on the field

 

[ThomasR]

My info re: TDK is that it is not $1.7m for the life of the contract.

First 2 years inflated using banked money from previous cap space (I was told almost like a sign on bonus).

Subsequent years probably closer to 1.2-1.3.

Another note (and this could be a sticking point for some of the stalling contracts) Saints don’t like to include mandatory TPP increases in contracts. A point of contention with the substantial increases coming in the near future.

That all makes sense. I think there is not a question that NWM would be our highest paid player in 2028, if he stays

 

[jwikked]

That all makes sense. I think there is not a question that NWM would be our highest paid player in 2028, if he stays

Which lines up with what Tom Morris said, that NWM was offered the biggest contract St Kilda has ever offered.

 

[OxSaint]

My info re: TDK is that it is not $1.7m for the life of the contract.

First 2 years inflated using banked money from previous cap space (I was told almost like a sign on bonus).

Subsequent years probably closer to 1.2-1.3.

Another note (and this could be a sticking point for some of the stalling contracts) Saints don’t like to include mandatory TPP increases in contracts. A point of contention with the substantial increases coming in the near future.

That was always the logical explanation but most on here want to keep Losing their minds over paying $1.8 million for a ruckman.

 

[gringo2011]

Marshall was smashed by Nankervis

I don't know what you watched.

 

[gringo2011]

Wonder how Port will appease JHF, Butters and Rozee since his contract will be double theirs.

Butters has already seemingly made his mind up unhappy with the NWM situation, courting a move back to Victoria. If only Port didn’t low ball Butters and initially offered 2 million a season they wouldn’t be in this position.

^ Sarcasm

See how easy it is to spin shit for the sake of a story.

I’m all in on TDK and Aleer, they’ll improve us not just next season, but when we hope to be contending soon.

The difference is that he'd be their best player or close to it. Some B grade plodder isn't thinking that he's worth just as much.

 

[Yawkey way]

He didn't do anything. Was subbed for a reason.

He played forward where our school yard kick to kick didn’t favour him. My question was did he ruck, from what I saw on tv I’d say no or very little.

Based on that he’s been judged harshly, but it was a debacle from start to finish almost unwatchable.

 

[StFly]

He played forward where our school yard kick to kick didn’t favour him. My question was did he ruck, from what I saw on tv I’d say no or very little.

Based on that he’s been judged harshly, but it was a debacle from start to finish almost unwatchable.

He rucked when there were stoppages in our F50, should tell you enough given the deartth of stoppages in our F50 since they intercepted a fair chunk. Will note that when subbed we did run into the "no St Kilda ruck" calls cause no one else CBF showing up to ruck and then of all people, Pou did.

So you know, not a thing to start critiquing on for this match just gone.

 

[Yawkey way]

He rucked when there were stoppages in our F50, should tell you enough given the deartth of stoppages in our F50 since they intercepted a fair chunk. Will note that when subbed we did run into the "no St Kilda ruck" calls cause no one else CBF showing up to ruck and then of all people, Pou did.

So you know, not a thing to start critiquing on for this match just gone.

Point is we used a ruckman as a de facto forward and with atrocious entry it didn’t work and he was subbed.

If people want to question his worth at least judge him as a ruckman.

 

[ScrappyDo]

The cap used to be 11-12m when that number was considered to be big.

So yes. Its not a large number anymore.

What % of your cap was 450k in 12m

Aren't you an accountant???

 

[Noddah]

He’s a dancer not a bull and he

**** I’m not trying to reply to this I can’t work this bloody thing few to many beers but who here would honestly be happy if we gain tdk but loose windhager I’m confident he will stay but I genuinely think if we win our next premiership in next 10 years he has to be a massive part of that