List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion - part 2

[dudeintheswamp]

Yeah I'll be surprised if he nominates us, just don't see it.

Edit, Jsos that is

 

[Leap of Faith]

2020: 1.22 goals PG / 2.33 scores PG

2021: 1.98 goals PG / 3.4 scores PG

2022: 2.36 goals PG / 4.22 scores PG

2023: 2.8 goals PG (removing the Melbourne one when he was off in the first 10 seconds) / 4 scores PH

2024: 1.58 goals PG / 2.58 scores PG


You get max anywhere near fit and he is an elite tall forward in this competition.

Those numbers don't really seem to be those of an elite forward. I've got my rose coloured glasses off re Max King. He's frustrating as hell. Looks all the world like an injury bust. Hope I'm wrong. There should come a point where the club has to bite the bullet and stop hanging their hat on what he 'could be' and face up to what he is.

 

[stavro#4]

I really hope we don't get Ryan. Don't see why they'd be looking at him. Average performer. A little more than a goal a game. Nearly 29. Surely not worth it for a pick higher than a third rounder. What hole in the list does he fill exactly? If they spend a decent pick on him, I'd be nervous about what they're doing.

Honest question.

Have you seen much of Flyin Ryan?

Our WA crew on here have all been pretty happy at the idea of grabbing him - so long as it’s cheap.

 

[Joffaboy]

If you want to have a laugh, check out the Carlton list management thread where they are perplexed that we can fit Nas and TDK under our salary cap and, accordingly, we are obviously cheating somehow . Also, after that car interview from JSOS, a few want the Silvagnis to be told that they aren't welcome at the club anymore

Every accusation is a confession.

 

[Molly29]

You'd think that negotiations would run smoothly

Might get it done over dinner tonight!

 

[Hubnester]

I really hope we don't get Ryan. Don't see why they'd be looking at him. Average performer. A little more than a goal a game. Nearly 29. Surely not worth it for a pick higher than a third rounder. What hole in the list does he fill exactly? If they spend a decent pick on him, I'd be nervous about what they're doing.

Yeah the idea doesn't particularly excite me either. Unless for absolute peanuts, would rather pass.

 

[stavro#4]

Those numbers don't really seem to be those of an elite forward. I've got my rose coloured glasses off re Max King. He's frustrating as hell. Looks all the world like an injury bust. Hope I'm wrong. There should come a point where the club has to bite the bullet and stop hanging their hat on what he 'could be' and face up to what he is.

Charlie Curnows best Coleman medal season:

4.8 scores per game.

Aged 26.

Not a great deal better than max at 22.

 

[saintkildaman]

One Carlton supporting claiming on their board that when trying to confirm JSOS to Pies he was told Saints. No source but fk I hope he is dribbling shit

 

[Saints43]

A few over on the Carlton board seem to think that JSOS has chosen us

They just want players walking out the door to be a vendetta by a past employee, not the obvious that players are leaving a poor environment at the earliest opportunity.

 

[MrFoster]

Those numbers don't really seem to be those of an elite forward. I've got my rose coloured glasses off re Max King. He's frustrating as hell. Looks all the world like an injury bust. Hope I'm wrong. There should come a point where the club has to bite the bullet and stop hanging their hat on what he 'could be' and face up to what he is.

Cannot judge King’s output with one of the worst midfield in the AFL. Have said this many times, even if we had prime time Ablett, Lockett and Dunstan, they are not going to kick a lot of goals from long bombs to a crowded defence and slow/safe play.

 

[stavro#4]

One Carlton supporting claiming on their board that when trying to confirm JSOS to Pies he was told Saints. No source but fk I hope he is dribbling shit

That person is actually claiming he will take a one year deal with us and they wouldn’t get compo.

Like it just won’t happen.

But if it ****ing did!!!

 

[OxSaint]

Our trade and fee agency moves combined with the Enright speech of pushing for top 6 next year suggest we are confident that Max is on the right track. He is a major piece to it. No way we are top 6 without seeing plenty of big max.

 

[SainterinSydney]

That person is actually claiming he will take a one year deal with us and they wouldn’t get compo.

Like it just won’t happen.

But if it ****ing did!!!

Please God let that be true lol

 

[stavro#4]

Our trade and fee agency moves combined with the Enright speech of pushing for top 6 next year suggest we are confident that Max is on the right track. He is a major piece to it. No way we are top 6 without seeing plenty of big max.

Dodson debut video.

Max is in training gear. So would imply gym work.

 

[Joffaboy]

TmA few over on the Carlton board seem to think that JSOS has chosen us

To me it sounds like it is a finals team, that's why no nomination, however TDK hasn't nominated anyone yet either.

Please let it be us and the salt can flow.

Then nom Harry Dean Stanton

 

[SainterinSydney]

That person is actually claiming he will take a one year deal with us and they wouldn’t get compo.

Like it just won’t happen.

But if it ****ing did!!!

Can we say that the Blues are now suffering from full blown St Kilda Derangement Syndrome

 

[Veer Right]

Reading the Carlton board it appears JSOS is likely coming to the saints going by a couple of their posters who appear ITK.

 

[Mat Mann]

Please, all enjoy the comments

I was about to post the same thing

 

[Linton Street Saint]

That person is actually claiming he will take a one year deal with us and they wouldn’t get compo.

Like it just won’t happen.

But if it ****ing did!!!

I'm afraid there won't be any dinner first either Carlton

 

[Dard Ball Get]

Our trade and fee agency moves combined with the Enright speech of pushing for top 6 next year suggest we are confident that Max is on the right track. He is a major piece to it. No way we are top 6 without seeing plenty of big max.

Where can I find the Enright speech mate?

 

[stavro#4]

 

[stavro#4]

 

[SainterinSydney]

 

[XhazzafootyX]

My god I hope we aren’t interested in Campbell Chesser

 

[Joffaboy]

That person is actually claiming he will take a one year deal with us and they wouldn’t get compo.

Like it just won’t happen.

But if it ****ing did!!!

One year deal at minimum. Then reneg at market prices. Sounds like the Silvagni's hate Carlton enough to do it.