List Mgmt. 2025 Trade/FA Thread

[Cousin of Daicos]

Ed Richards is priority this offseason imo.

For me in order of priority it’s:

1. Rowell
2. LDU
3. Richards
4. JUH
5. Bont

If Harley Reid says he wants to leave then he would take Richard’s spot in third

 

[sr36]

I saw him play and he is Harley Reid without the need for a fend off. I don't think I've ever seen a junior just shake his hips and break away from tackles like he did. He was also kicking the ball 50mtrs from a standing start. My number 1 pick this year

Just shut up. **** the Suns. **** the Northern Clubs - they're going to dominate for a while. Meanwhile the rest of the country will be carrying on about Vicbias ...

 

[jmac70]

For me in order of priority it’s:

1. Rowell
2. LDU
3. Richards
4. JUH
5. Bont

If Harley Reid says he wants to leave then he would take Richard’s spot in third

If we do pick up a free agent, it is more likely to be a player no one has considered.

 

[manicpie]

Just shut up. ** the Suns. ** the Northern Clubs - they're going to dominate for a while. Meanwhile the rest of the country will be carrying on about Vicbias ...

I've got more good news. Brisbane will pick up another top 5 midfielder this year.

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

If we do pick up a free agent, it is more likely to be a player no one has considered.

Respectfully disagree

I’m extremely confident it will be at least one from my list

Although sure, if more than 1, then maybe it could be one of those and then one no one has considered a la Membrey

 

[Jen2310]

Respectfully disagree

I’m extremely confident it will be at least one from my list

Although sure, if more than 1, then maybe it could be one of those and then one no one has considered a la Membrey

Very possible its none on your list tbh
Wouldn't be surprised if all re-sign (though JUH isn't OOC, what happens with him remains to be seen)

 

[Jafo]

Whether true or not, hearing from a Dogs supporter mate that Bevo wanted JUH traded last year but the board felt differently.

JUH supposedly second strike and that Pies have already been into him for some time now and the suggestion is he’s Collingwood bound end of the year.

But of course, who knows and a lot would have to play out for this to happen.

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

Very possible its none on your list tbh
Wouldn't be surprised if all re-sign (though JUH isn't OOC, what happens with him remains to be seen)

Oh my list works off the assumption that any of those (or all) choose to leave

 

[BillyElliott]

Whether true or not, hearing from a Dogs supporter mate that Bevo wanted JUH traded last year but the board felt differently.

JUH supposedly second strike and that Pies have already been into him for some time now and the suggestion is he’s Collingwood bound end of the year.

But of course, who knows and a lot would have to play out for this to happen.

Rumours are also that after a couple of clubs did their own investigations into JUH & his issues & they decided, no thanks.

Interestingly, but not surprising :

No player has been suspended or named publicly after recording a second strike since the revised policy was introduced in 2015.

How does the AFL’s illicit drug policy work?

Under the AFL’s illicit drugs policy, Melbourne’s Joel Smith would record a first strike, receive a suspended fine and counselling. But here’s what happens under the league’s anti-doping code.

www.theage.com.au

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

Rumours are also that after a couple of clubs did their own investigations into JUH & his issues they decided, no thanks.

We can fix him

 

[sr36]

Very possible its none on your list tbh
Wouldn't be surprised if all re-sign (though JUH isn't OOC, what happens with him remains to be seen)

Let's get Kane-O to go completely nuts and add a couple of Jeremy's - Cameron and MacGovern. Both Free agents I think.

 

[Scodog10]

Ed Richards is priority this offseason imo.

Price doesn’t scare you? He’ll be a $1.2m pa proposition given Perryman’s in the $800-900k range.

 

[Dtennent94]

Price doesn’t scare you? He’ll be a $1.2m pa proposition given Perryman’s in the $800-900k range.

Respectfully, if we offered him say a 4-5 year deal, I am pretty sure he would not receive an average of 1.2m/y…

 

[Bianconeri]

If we do pick up a free agent, it is more likely to be a player no one has considered.

Are you telling me we’re going to finally land Fiorini?

 

[sideswipe]

Whether true or not, hearing from a Dogs supporter mate that Bevo wanted JUH traded last year but the board felt differently.

JUH supposedly second strike and that Pies have already been into him for some time now and the suggestion is he’s Collingwood bound end of the year.

But of course, who knows and a lot would have to play out for this to happen.

Second strikes are meant to be made public. But there's also the possibility that the club/afl agreed to keep schtum if the player was seen as somehow vulnerable.

 

[pablo disco bar]

Couldn't begrudge Darcy Cameron if he leaves and gets his pay day....deserves it and tbh should take it

 

[manicpie]

Owies ripped it up for WC, just saying

 

[Soups]

Price doesn’t scare you? He’ll be a $1.2m pa proposition given Perryman’s in the $800-900k range.

If he has the output he did on the weekend with The Bont out I think he’s worth it. Be interesting to see how he goes over the next 5/6 weeks.

 

[Apex36]

Price doesn’t scare you? He’ll be a $1.2m pa proposition given Perryman’s in the $800-900k range.

I think people are going to need to understand that $1m is the new $750-800k now. If players like TDK are getting offers upwards of $1.5m and Reid is supposedly getting a $2m offer despite him not yet warranting it, I think $1-1.2 for Ed is probably around the mark.

 

[cfc19902010]

LDU for me
Richards not far behind if not similar worth and need

 

[Jen2310]

Geelong interested in JUH
They believe they have the lifestyle of being out of melb fishbowl and closer to his family as an incentive. He's now formed a good friendship with Smith.

 

[Scodog10]

Respectfully, if we offered him say a 4-5 year deal, I am pretty sure he would not receive an average of 1.2m/y…

Did you catch Saturday nights game? He’s every bit a $1.2m player if he brings that on a regular basis.

I think people are going to need to understand that $1m is the new $750-800k now. If players like TDK are getting offers upwards of $1.5m and Reid is supposedly getting a $2m offer despite him not yet warranting it, I think $1-1.2 for Ed is probably around the mark.

I think his worth to the Dogs will sit somewhere in the $1m range, but to pry him out you’ll need to be getting toward the $1.2m. My comfort level would rest on what he can do with a full year in the midfield. I can justify it, but there would be an expectation that he’s the ****ing man if we land him.

 

[stormskye]

Geelong interested in JUH
They believe they have the lifestyle of being out of melb fishbowl and closer to his family as an incentive. He's now formed a good friendship with Smith.

There is almost 0 chance dogs will deal with geel if it eventuates.

 

[BillyElliott]

Geelong interested in JUH
They believe they have the lifestyle of being out of melb fishbowl and closer to his family as an incentive. He's now formed a good friendship with Smith.

What they really mean is they can cover things up easier in Geelong by being out of the fishbowl..

 

[Jen2310]

What they really mean is they can cover things up easier in Geelong by being out of the fishbowl..

Exactly lol