List Mgmt. 2025 Trade/FA Thread

[Matt_352]

Yuck no thanks

 

[manicpie]

It's a yes to Hobbs from me

 

[Matt_352]

It's a yes to Hobbs from me

Surely we can do better? What about Mackenzie from the Dawks

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

Hobbs, Caminiti, Blight....We must be really wanting to make the VFL finals next year.....

 

[sr36]

Yep. But you have to nod and agree for a bit

With all these players coming to us to have medicals wives. Have we gone a bit keys in the fish bowl?

 

[Do_Beta_Rapport]

Wonder if they’ll find something wrong with his feet in the medical, bloke cannot kick.

Makes Taylor Adams look like prime Nathan Buckley when it comes to pinpoint passes.

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

 

[Pistol Night]

With all these players coming to us to have medicals wives. Have we gone a bit keys in the fish bowl?

We were thinking about it but with keyless entry these days the magic is lost

 

[Pistol Night]

Wonder if they’ll find something wrong with his feet in the medical, bloke cannot kick.

Makes Taylor Adams look like prime Nathan Buckley when it comes to pinpoint passes.

A good doc might pick that up

 

[domus]

Hobbs, Caminiti, Blight....We must be really wanting to make the VFL finals next year.....

You don't trust our club's judgement anymore? Three preliminary finals and hopefully two grand finals in four years not enough to suggest our coaching/recruiting staff know what they are doing?

 

[manicpie]

Surely we can do better? What about Mackenzie from the Dawks

Mackenzie would be amazing but not sure how we get him. I could see a role for Hobbs, I reckon he'll continue to improve and he's pretty good in congestion. Could be a great tagger if we choose to go that way next year

 

[manicpie]

You don't trust our club's judgement anymore? Three preliminary finals and hopefully two grand finals in four years not enough to suggest our coaching/recruiting staff know what they are doing?

I like those 3 suggested players

 

[domus]

Surely we can do better? What about Mackenzie from the Dawks

Can't get a game in a side with a weakness in the middle- though Blockhead Newcombe makes a difference.

 

[domus]

Didn't Frampton do quite well when Moore was out of the side this season?
I thought he did ok. Howe was in to, so that would've helped him.

Reflex response every bloody time Collingwood looks at someone who hasn't won a Brownlow or Norm Smith. It gets boring after a while. Leigh Brown? Spud! Rubbish! Brodie Holland -Reject! Yuk! Billy Frampton? Dud playing in their seconds most of the time. Even Darcy Cameron was a yawn. Who? Some big bloke who can't get a game in Sydney.

 

[domus]

Jezz he must be real shit

Like Leigh Brown and Billy Frampton, I suppose.

 

[Pistol Night]

Like Leigh Brown and Billy Frampton, I suppose.

I loved Leroy

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

You don't trust our club's judgement anymore? Three preliminary finals and hopefully two grand finals in four years not enough to suggest our coaching/recruiting staff know what they are doing?

Ofc l trust the clubs strategy, but l can't see any of these 3 moving the dial much next year in terms of improving our current side. They would be depth if anything.
I would like us to look deeper into our list next season for the improvement to come from within, particularly with players like Harrison coming back next year.
I do like our pursuit of Jack Buller. He is one who could come in and make an impact....

 

[domus]

Ofc l trust the clubs strategy, but l can't see any of these 3 moving the dial much next year in terms of improving our current side. They would be depth if anything.
I would like us to look deeper into our list next season for the improvement to come from within, particularly with players like Harrison coming back next year.
I do like our pursuit of Jack Buller. He is one who could come in and make an impact....

That's clearly what they are doing- we have to have depth and then it's up to the new blokes to fight hard for their place in the side.

 

[Pistol Night]

Whats the latest on Stoopid Flanders? If he picks the Saints hes really getting into character

 

[thommo_legend]

Whats the latest on Stoopid Flanders? If he picks the Saints hes really getting into character

Melbourne apparently

 

[Go Woods]

Whats the latest on Stoopid Flanders? If he picks the Saints hes really getting into character

Hardwick just stated, he ain't getting traded, time will tell.

 

[Hardas]

It's a yes to Hobbs from me

Trade sl_t...

 

[JuniorB]

Mackenzie would be amazing but not sure how we get him. I could see a role for Hobbs, I reckon he'll continue to improve and he's pretty good in congestion. Could be a great tagger if we choose to go that way next year

His development has been stifled at bummerland.
For the right price he could be handy.
According to the bummer website, he is rated elite for handballs and tackles.
That said, we want players who are elite for kicking.

 

[swoop42]

Have people considered this whole Hobbs story is a complete fabrication?

 

[Peters_Nuts]

Have people considered this whole Hobbs story is a complete fabrication?

Too late. My pitchfork is out