A.Swallow vs M.Murphy

[yogi89]

my mate is talking up M.Murphy as one of the best afl players im saying A.Swallow is ahead of him

 

[blue_trinity]

Is this a joke? your an idiot if you think swallow is ahead of him, and your mates an idiot if he thinks murphy is a top afl player.
He may be one day, but at the moment theres probably about 50 payers ahead of him.

still better than swallow though

 

[Joshen]

Same draft, difference is Swallow was Round 3 Murphy was Priority Pick #1 regardless of who is better North definitely got better value.

 

[HyperAgressiveDonk]

Murphy isn't an elite footballer and nor is Swallow. Much of a muchness for who will be the better footballer in the future. But as pointed out North got the better value.

 

[Dan]

In terms of last season...they both had pretty good year. However over their careers so far.....I'd have Murphy in front of Swallow.

 

[The Zebra]

****, this is actually a good poll.

Line bal I reckon. Murphy has plenty of talent but is a bit of a front runner, Swallow is a maniac at the contest but lacks Murphy's class.

I would lke Murphy in the kangas team, but can't say i would give him up for Swallow. If they played together, Swallow would lead and Murphy would follow.

 

[Frothies Mcveigh]

So far Murphy has been the better player, but Swallow had the better 2010 season.

 

[Byron_Clanger]

Murphy because he was the number 1 pick

 

[Domenic Fotia]

This poll is a joke.

Swallow is not fit to carry Murphy's bag to the ground.

Only one eyed North supporters and anti-Carlton supporters would vote for Swallow.

 

[The OBSTacle]

This poll is a joke.

Swallow is not fit to carry Murphy's bag to the ground.

Only one eyed North supporters and anti-Carlton supporters would vote for Swallow.

You're a joke if you think there is some great divide between Swallow and Murphy.

 

[HyperAgressiveDonk]

You're a joke if you think there is some great divide between Swallow and Murphy.

I wouldn't take anything Domenic Fotia says to seriously. He is extraordinarily biased. Check out the Nic v Kreuzer thread. He said exactly the same thing, in that people who don't vote for the Carlton bloke, are anti-Carlton.

 

[Dazb86]

Tough poll. Murphys a better user of the ball and Swallows a better extractor that runs hard both ways.

For my team I'd go with Murphy.

 

[Sin City]

Is this a joke?

This poll is a joke.

Wrong and ignorant

Great poll with two good players. Obviously I love Murphy and look forward to a huge injury free year from him in 2011. Swallow has turned into a very good player, tackling machine and as pointed out was great value for where he was drafted. Should be a good poll to bump and to review their performances this year.

 

[TigerTime88]

Murphy and quite easily....

 

[Red Black and Blue]

Swallow's 09 was very good as well. Probably about the same as Murphy's last year. Very close poll, but have to Swallow based on most recent form.

 

[Schulzenfest]

Swallow in a shit team, Murphy in a good one.

 

[Joshen]

Swallow in a shit team, Murphy in a good one.

Since neither is in one who would you take?

 

[I am a tiger too]

can't split em