ablett vs hodge

[geelong_crazy26]

I believe that ablett is comfortably ahead of hodge.He just has that X factor about him that hodge dosent seem to have and is far more damaging with the ball.I think the fact that hodge dosent break the lines enough really does go against him.

lets look at the achievements of the two

ablett
premiership player
AA player
most valuable player of the year as voted by players
best player of the year as voted by the coaches

hodge
AA player

 

[estibador]

Juddy rulz all!!!111

 

[Tigersman]

Tough call.

Hodge just. But another year by Ablett at last years standard would probably swing me the other way.

 

[Upgrayedd]

I believe that ablett is comfortably ahead of hodge.He just has that X factor about him that hodge dosent seem to have and is far more damaging with the ball.I think the fact that hodge dosent break the lines enough really does go against him.

While Albett is better then Hodge on the form on 2007, Your "hodge doesnt break lines or is damaging" with the ball is the stupidest thing you have EVER said. Give hodge the ball at HFF and most coaches are shitting themselfs.

 

[The Casey Cat]

I believe that ablett is comfortably ahead of hodge.He just has that X factor about him that hodge dosent seem to have and is far more damaging with the ball.I think the fact that hodge dosent break the lines enough really does go against him.

I really wish you barracked for a different team! All garbage topics like this do is make people more likely to troll us.

 

[estibador]

I'd take Hodge btw.

Tough, classy players who can hit a target on the chest from 55m don't grow on trees.

 

[geelong_crazy26]

I'd take Hodge btw.

Tough, classy players who can hit a target on the chest from 55m don't grow on trees.

tough ? the bloke got 8 disposals in the most important game of his life, not saying hes not good but hes clearly not tough if he dosent stand up when hes most needed

 

[geelong_crazy26]

While Albett is better then Hodge on the form on 2007, Your "hodge doesnt break lines or is damaging" with the ball is the stupidest thing you have EVER said. Give hodge the ball at HFF and most coaches are shitting themselfs.[/quote

and coaches wouldn't do the same if ablett had the ball 50 meters out from goal

 

[geelong_crazy26]

Tough call.

Hodge just. But another year by Ablett at last years standard would probably swing me the other way.

how many elite years has hodge had ? 1 at the most

 

[geelong_crazy26]

lets look at the achievements of the two

ablett
premiership player
AA player
most valuable player of the year as voted by players
best player of the year as voted by the coaches

hodge
AA player

I think we have a winner

 

[PUSSIES_07_FLAG]

My biased "Cats fan" opinion: Ablett

My unbiased expert Footballing opinion: Ablett

 

[TheNewEra]

You are an absolute clown at best. 2 totally different players. Hodge can play all over the ground and will end up being a leigh matthews type who will kick a lot of goals and Ablett is a superstar but will only ever be a midfielder or resting forward pocket. do not come compare them u clown. why do u idiot remember the game he was playing injured and not remember the adelaide game where i believe he won us the game.

 

[Roy boys]

From a neutral fan i believe Hodge is the perfect package when it comes to a midfielder/Utility. He scores goals, he assists goals, he has as good a left foot as anyone in the game, he can rebound from half back, he can get the loose easy footy, he can win the hard footy. All these things Ablett can do to but Ablett can't hurt blokes or Tackle like Hodge & for this reason & for the example he sets i choose him over anyone in the AFL as a package of a midfielder, still take Brown & pav as 1 & 2 thoe.

 

[Upgrayedd]

and coaches wouldn't do the same if ablett had the ball 50 meters out from goal

When did i say they wouldnt? could you link me to it?
Also, i dont think you should be calling into question hodge's toughness when Ablett wears make-up

 

[__aria__]

Why?

 

[clarkoscluster]

Get over your Hawthorn obsession dickwad.

 

[geelong_crazy26]

You are an absolute clown at best. 2 totally different players. Hodge can play all over the ground and will end up being a leigh matthews type who will kick a lot of goals and Ablett is a superstar but will only ever be a midfielder or resting forward pocket. do not come compare them u clown. why do u idiot remember the game he was playing injured and not remember the adelaide game where i believe he won us the game.[/quote]

because the game against north was the most important game of his life.He wasnt injured at all you just want to make a excuse.

 

[geelong_crazy26]

Get over your Hawthorn obsession dickwad.

this is not a have a go at luke hodge thread, im just saying hes not as good as ablett

even mike sheehan had ablett a long way ahead of hodge in his top 50

 

[Upgrayedd]

He wasnt injured at all you just want to make a excuse.

Neither was christopher reeve, he was faking it.

Any numbat could tell he was struggling to be even on the park,

 

[clarkoscluster]

this is not a have a go at luke hodge thread, im just saying hes not as good as ablett

even mike sheehan had ablett a long way ahead of hodge in his top 50

And Mike Sheehan is widely regarded as a clown. Everyone knows that. I repeat - Get over your Hawthorn obsession dickwad. Do you deny that you aren't obsessed?

 

[geelong_crazy26]

I think its also worth noting the impact that the 2 have had on there clubs.

the year before hodge came to hawthorn they finished 4th

the year before ablett came to geelong they finished 12th

since hodge came to hawthorn they have finished
10th
9th
15th
14th
11th
6th

since ablett came to geelong
9th
12th
4th
5th
10th
1st

 

[geelong_crazy26]

And Mike Sheehan is widely regarded as a clown. Everyone knows that. I repeat - Get over your Hawthorn obsession dickwad. Do you deny that you aren't obsessed?

yes i do deny it ,stick to the topic please

 

[clarkoscluster]

yes i do deny it ,stick to the topic please

If you do deny it, why are 95% of your threads Hawthorn related?

 

[geelong_crazy26]

If you do deny it, why are 95% of your threads Hawthorn related?

all my threads about hawthorn are true which means it is not a obsession but rather a valid football opinion.

 

[geelong_crazy26]

The main reason why most of my threads are about hawthorn are because I spend most of my time over in bay 13, so I am there to troll and hawthorn are easy targets.