Adam Cooney or Brock McLean

[Scraggerz]

4 years on now arguably the two best to come from the 03 draft who would you take?

 

[.M a t t.]

Both?

 

[Scraggerz]

Both?

serious responses only thanks

 

[Warwick]

Personally, i'd probably just stick with Jed Adcock.

That's if you wanted the best player from that particular draft.

 

[whelan=legend]

Polls board is thataway----->

 

[Hot Spenny]

serious responses only thanks

But you just stole the idea from another current thread.

Both.

 

[kosi_23]

Jed Adcock will be the best player from that draft.

But in relation to the question Cooney>McLean

 

[Jono B]

Adcock

 

[mulhollanddrive]

Agree:

Adcock > Cooney > McLean.

Adcock deliverered this year, Cooney has the talent but is up and down, McLean has a reputation from 1 game.

 

[NimChief]

McLean every day of the week.

twice on Sundays

 

[dales.girl38]

Cooney, but I think McLeon is grossly overrated anyway.

 

[MC_9]

Personally, i'd probably just stick with Jed Adcock.

That's if you wanted the best player from that particular draft.

agreed

but Mclean > Cooney

 

[whelan=legend]

Agree:

Adcock > Cooney > McLean.

Adcock deliverered this year, Cooney has the talent but is up and down, McLean has a reputation from 1 game.

Your obviously judging McLean from this season only, where he broke his foot in round 1, and played with a groin injury at the end of the year.

You will eat your words next year when hes injury free

 

[The Enigma]

McLean is the total package. Cooney is a flanker. I haven't seen Adcock enough unfortunately so I'll reserve judgement.

 

[Big Jols]

Mclean>Cooney

 

[Trump]

In terms of finals winning performances and consistency when injury free.

Easily Maclean.

Adcock > Maclean > Waters > Mundy > Cooney ( Dud)

 

[CowboyFromHell]

Agree:

Adcock > Cooney > McLean.

Adcock deliverered this year, Cooney has the talent but is up and down, McLean has a reputation from 1 game.

He has performed in finals. Alot of your players fell over when they finally got there this year.

While Cooney and McLean are both midfielders they play rather different roles and they both do them well. I'll of course stick with McLean. I don't know why supporters come in here with the Adcock crap when he has no part in this thread.

 

[.M a t t.]

Agree:

Adcock > Cooney > McLean.

Adcock deliverered this year, Cooney has the talent but is up and down, McLean has a reputation from 1 game.

Doesn't help that he didn't have a full pre-season to possibly take the next step.

 

[Scraggerz]

In terms of finals winning performances and consistency when injury free.

Easily Maclean.

Adcock > Maclean > Waters > Mundy > Cooney ( Dud)

Lmao clearly the most unintelligent poster on Big Footy

 

[TheWiseOne]

For the Hawks

Waters

 

[Trump]

Lmao clearly the most unintelligent poster on Big Footy

You'd like to think so.

But you have started a separate thread to convince yourself that Cooney isnt a dud after what I said in the 03 draft thread.

You must be insecure.

 

[CowboyFromHell]

Lmao clearly the most unintelligent poster on Big Footy

Typing on here like it's a text message doesn't help your cause either.

 

[Scraggerz]

You'd like to think so.

But you have started a separate thread to convince yourself that Cooney isnt a dud after what I said in the 03 draft thread.

You must be insecure.

No just want some people with a clue about football to share their opinion.

I actually rate McLean quite highly and definitely would have taken him over Ray
I just want to know if people would take him over Cooney

 

[Trump]

No just want some people with a clue about football to share their opinion.

I actually rate McLean quite highly and definitely would have taken him over Ray
I just want to know if people would take him over Cooney

What has Cooney done other than be picked number 1 in the national draft that has him so far ahead of Maclean.

He is clearly behind not only Maclean but Adcock also.

 

[whelan=legend]

What has Cooney done other than be picked number 1 in the national draft that has him so far ahead of Maclean.

He is clearly behind not only Maclean but Adcock also.

its McLean