That's worse than signing Mackay to a 4-year deal. At least Mackay was in the best 22 when that deal was done, and didn't fall out of the best 22 until the 3rd year of his contract. Menzel has never been in our best 22, and probably never will be. Giving him 4 years is bordering on criminal negligence.Heard Troy Menzel signed a four year deal, so speculatively 2019.