Remove this Banner Ad

AFL draft game 3.0

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Jezzza said:
Probably better to do it the way BS asked, at least that way we are all using the same system...
Click to expand...
When I did last game someone did theirs in a way completely different to the others, after an hour of trying to rework it myself, I decided that I couldn't without potentially misjudging the result and got them to redo it.
 
everyone has handed in their votes bar Juddy88,who hasn't been online in 3 days.
By golly it is close, the suspense is killing me!
Well done to everyone for having their votes in the correct format.
 
I think I've got last sewn up, TBH
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Hahaha! As long as my team gets ranked best Juddy all is forgiven :thumbsu:

You also forgot to add a TBH into your post. TBH its the latest craze could challenge the chiffon... or combine them together to form................

...

Haha you guys thought i'd write TBH in chiffon... idiots :p TBH
 
TBH you're a bit of a idiot, Rojo :D
 

Remove this Banner Ad

A garbage man
 
11th: FG- 19+21+21.5+21+16+20+22+17+13+20=190.5

10th : Mitchzz- 24.5+21+23+23+17+19+21.5+21+16+20=206

9th: Biggie= 24.5+19+19+22+23.5+17+22+23.5+18+21=209.5

8th: Mop= 23.5+21+19+24.5+23.5+18+22+23.5+19+20=214




(7th)CK= 23+23+23+24.5+21+19+23.5+22.5+19+21=219.5







(equal 5th)Happy= 24.5+21+21+24+24.5+23+21.5+23.5+23+23=229









(Equal 5th) Juddy88= 25+22+22+25+24.5+23+23+24+21.5+19=229













(4th) Jezza= 25+23+22+24+18+23+25+24.5+25+21=230.5













(3rd)Rojo=27+19+22+25.5+23+22+25.5+24.5+21+23=232.5

















(2nd)Beatlesmith= 25+24+20+26+25+19+24+26+23+22=234

That means the winner of Draft game version 3.0 is.....



















(1st)Fivestrings= 26.5+23+20+26+25+21+21+24.5+26.5+23=236.5

Well done Fivey, you had a great team. If you didn't pip me at the post i wouldn't be putting gypsy curses on you as we speak....
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

happy_eagle said:
Geez who gave Beatle 19 votes :D
Fair and honest
Click to expand...
this is the guy who considers akermanis and didak to be 'average' and cousins, van berlo and johnstone to not be 'decent'.

It wouldn't have bothered me if i had finished poorly, but considering that my other votes average was 24, a 5 point discrepancy is a little suspicious.
 
Who gave me 13? You pricks.

Can't say I wasn't expecting it, though
 
Top stuff Fivey I had you & BS as equal first with Rojo & Juddy88 as the next 2 so my votes were pretty close in that respect.

For anybody who's interested below is the PM with the breakdown of votes.

Flawed Genius

Backs: 7
Mid : 7.5
Fwds: 7

21.5

Overall the team is probably a bit young. Can’t see an who would be the 2nd ruckman. Also think the KPP’s are mostly undersized & Goodes is probably being played out of position.

Beatlesmith

Backs: 8.5
Mid: 9
Fwds: 8.5

26

Very solid team all round. Only concern in the forwards would be Robbo at CHF, perhaps a bit undersized but like the smalls & has Franklin. Very good rucks & midfield, the only questions I have is how good will the Tiges Cuz compared to the WC one?

BIGGIE.

Backs: 7
Mids: 8
Fwd: 7

22

Really good starting foursome in the middle, wings not quite as strong & probably lacks a bit of rotation depth as Rischa is the only mid on the bench. McPhee undersized at CHB. KPP’s in the forwards not yet proven goalkickers, BJ the only player who regularly kicks big totals.

Happy Eagle

Backs: 7.5
Mids 8.5
Fwds 8

24

Harley seems more suited to that 3rd tall role nowadays rather than playing as your traditional KPP. Rucks are ok not great & I just feel that starting midfield whilst very good is lacking a real linebreaker. Nice mix of players in the forward line, though Hall is probably past his prime.



Rojo Junior

Backs: 9
Mid: 8
Fwds: 8.5

25.5

Excellent backline. The midfielders in the center are very workmanlike but maybe lack a little in creativity, wingers are good & there are a couple of good bench players who add a bit of depth. Rucks are solid. Very good forwardline.



Juddy 88

Backs 8
Mids 8.5
Fwds 8.5

25

Solid backline maybe just lacking someone who can go with a really nippy small forward. Very good midfield just lacking a really dominant ruckman though Hale from what I’ve seen tends to play more as a forward. A dangerous forwardline, if Treadrea was a few years younger would be right up there.



Mitchzz

Backs: 7.5
Mids 8
Fwds 7.5

23

Ok backline would be a bit worried about Tambling & McMahon though. Very good mix of players in the starting 4 of the midfield, doesn’t quite seem to have the depth of rotation as some of the other teams. Brown at FF is still an unknown quantity at this stage the HF line is very good though.


Mop

Backs: 8.5
Mids 8
Fwds 8

24.5

Very good KPP’s in the backline probably one real class user of the ball coming out of defence though. Starting midfield is really workmanlike, probably not the fastest & lacks a real linebreaker with good disposal. A couple of good KPP's but maybe be lacking in anyone who can provide some real defensive pressure.



5Strings

Backs: 8
Mids 9
Fwds 9

26

Solid backline. Excellent starting midfield & with Jolly & I assume Petrie in the ruck would be very hard to stop. Very good KPP’s in the forwardline & a couple of very good players in Davis & McVeigh on the flanks. Would have been a 9.5 if the crumber was someone a little better Eddie.


Crimson King

Backs: 7.5
Mid 8.5
Fwds 7

23

Plenty of run from the backline & whilst Croad is good have my doubts about Gilham. Some very good midfielders & solid back-up from the bench. Not sold on Kosi as a FF can be very inconsistent & would have to pinch hit in the ruck leaving Lucas as your only big forward
 
My votes are as follows (i was pretty much got it all in order, meaning im a gun evaluator :))

1st Beatle
Defence: 8/10
Midfield: 9/10
Forwards: 8/10
TOTAL: 25
The prick was the first to jump the gun (on the gun) that is Ben Cousins. Lack of CHF is counteracted by the fact you got Buddy.

2nd Fivey
Defence: 7.5/10
Midfield: 8.5/10
Forwards: 9/10
TOTAL: 25
Question marks on Whelan and Betts selections. Not good enough players for the best sides. Solid forward line and liked the midfield.

3rd Happy
Defence: 7.5/10
Midfield: 8.5/10
Forwards: 8.5/10
TOTAL: 24.5
Good KP players and crumbers in the forward line. Couple of gun mids make a solid team.

4th Juddy
Defence: 7.5/10
Midfield: 8/10
Forwards: 9/10
TOTAL: 24.5
Not sold on Carlile yet. Gun forward line, one of the best in the game. Strong midfield as well

5th CK
Defence: 7.5/10
Midfield: 8.5/10
Forwards: 8.5/10
TOTAL 24.5
Very average bench, which led to yours being ranked last of the 24.5 scoring teams. Still pretty even overall team.

6th Jezza
Defence: 7.5/10
Midfield: 8.5/10
Forwards: 8/10
TOTAL: 24
Good midfield, including the options on the bench. A few pretty good players spread over the ground.

7th Mop
Defence: 8/10
Midfield: 8/10
Forwards: 7.5/10
TOTAL: 23.5
Too many Eagles players, we sucked last year so your team shouldnt consist of mainly our guys Not really any deadset stars outside of the midfield.

8th Biggie
Defence: 7.5/10
Midfield: 9/10
Forwards: 7/10
TOTAL: 23.5
A few odd selections, and you probably jumped the gun too early on a few players. Seemed like you missed the boat on KP players as well.

9th Mitchzz
Defence: 8/10
Midfield: 8/10
Forwards: 7/10
TOTAL: 23
Your main target up forward is a guy whos impressed in 1 game for us. Also you missed out on a few selections... you had to pick 4 guys at one stage IIRC and you made a mess of those choices. That cost you.

10th FG
Defence: 6/10
Midfield: 9/10
Forwards: 6/10
TOTAL: 21
You just got r*ped by missing out on a heap of selections and it shows. At least you still assembled a gun midfield.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom