Biggest Draft Blunder

[Carn Hawkas]

Your biggest draft blunder, was trading pick 1 and 36 to us. You could of had Hodge and Mitchell.

 

[Rob]

Ben Edwards. Pick 6, and we delisted him before the season even started.

Thread closed.

 

[sabre_ac]

Ben Edwards. Pick 6, and we delisted him before the season even started.

Thread closed.

AHAHAHAHA

All you can do is laugh, I didn't know he was delisted before the season even began.

Incredible.

 

[sabre_ac]

Your biggest draft blunder, was trading pick 1 and 36 to us. You could of had Hodge and Mitchell.

Little reason in comparing players that were chosen with draft picks...You need to look at the value of the picks.

Pick one was potentially worth Bartel, Judd, Hodge or Ball...

Equating pick 36 to Mitchell doesn't fly with me...It was good/lucky drafting by the Hawks...It coul have also potetially been:

Jarrad Wright
Rod Crowe
Tom Davidson
Shane Harvey

etc

 

[Rob]

AHAHAHAHA

All you can do is laugh, I didn't know he was delisted before the season even began.

Incredible.

What made it even more ridiculous is that Edwards being from Claremont and it also being our 2nd year, we could have taken him for nothing as a zone selection. chose not to, wasted a very high draft pick on him, then realised he was shite and got rid of him so we could take a player in the pre season draft.

No, i'm not making it up. I've got no doubt it was the biggest piece of incompetence in our history, and probably in the history of the draft.

 

[pinkus maximus]

Your biggest draft blunder, was trading pick 1 and 36 to us. You could of had Hodge and Mitchell.

it doesn't work that way

we may well have picked polak with pick 1 and some other dud at 36

 

[raffrox]

Your biggest draft blunder, was trading pick 1 and 36 to us. You could of had Hodge and Mitchell.

We wouldn't have picker Mitchell though. He was running around for the Box Hill Hawks so you guys always had the inside running on him imo.

But otherwise you're dead right.

 

[raffrox]

it doesn't work that way

we may well have picked polak with pick 1 and some other dud at 36

So what you are saying is that because we may have makde an even stupider decision it doesn't work that way?