Buckley v Hird v Voss

[raskolnikov]

If Buckley stayed at Brisbane he wouldve been Voss's captain

He would have three premiership medallions as well.

 

[MarkJohnson#1]

Voss always wins these polls because people other than their own supporters hate Collingwood and Essendon, hence they see Voss as a neutral vote, therefore these polls are invalid.

 

[NimChief]

Geez - I can't believe no one has thought to ask this question before.

Yep, unique thread.

 

[Claude Balls]

Voss > Hird >>>> Buckley

Voss ahead of Hird only due to longevity and consistency etc. Hird could do things IMO that the other two couldn't and so is perhaps the most inherently talented. It is just unfortunate for him that he suffered so many injuries. Buckley is inferior to both, despite still being immensely talented. He just never seemed to have the same impact on the result of matches, even when the Pies were thereabouts for a few years.

 

[bourbons]

Hird for mine.

I go for Carlton and I still love watching him. Footballing genius.

 

[boncer34]

Hird coz he's done something the others haven't.

 

[DeeHughMan]

Voss >>> Hird >>> Buckley

agreed.

Buckley=Roo=West=Harvey

Hird a bit above. Voss above him. Voss had that leadership that actually lifts the whole team. something only the greats have

 

[DeeHughMan]

Hird coz he's done something the others haven't.

What? Voss has done it all and then some. what year was hird at his best i am sure it was when Voss was the best player in the comp

 

[boncer34]

What? Voss has done it all and then some. what year was hird at his best i am sure it was when Voss was the best player in the comp

Incorrect. Hird's done something Voss never did.

 

[DapperDon]

Incorrect. Hird's done something Voss never did.

Lara Bingle?

 

[DonMania#5]

Incorrect. Hird's done something Voss never did.

Norm Smith Medal